September 2010
S M T W T F S
« Aug    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  

Mini Reviews

Because otherwise these books are never going to get reviewed!

Ten Things I Love About You, Julia Quinn

Annabel Winslow is looking for a rich husband to rescue her family from the poorhouse.  And she’s found a potential suitor, an aged, lecherous earl, of whom she isn’t at all fond, but she figures she has to resign herself to her fate – even if he does nearly assault her.  Then she meets the earl’s nephew, Sebastian, and everything changes.  They may be falling in love, but will Sebastian have the funds to save her siblings?

Much the same as the last book in this series, What Happens in London, this book is very sweet and very funny.  It’s easy to become fond of both characters and believe in their romance, even if everything is far too rosy for real life.  The series lacks the real fantastic romantic potential of the Bridgerton series, but still all of them provide a nice, quick diversion from every day life.

Lead Me On, Victoria Dahl

Jane Morgan has worked very hard to get her position as an administrative assistant to an architect.  She rescued herself from years of bad behavior as a teenager in order to turn herself into a real adult – even if that means she’s neglected her family.  But she can’t seem to kick her attraction to big, tattooed, rough men, no matter how many businessmen she dates.  When Billy Chase steps into her office, she simply can’t resist him – but can she fit him into her new life?

I think I may be the only romance reader in the world who had some issues with this book – I just found that it wasn’t really to my taste.  Dahl’s writing is funny and smooth, so no problems there, but I couldn’t connect with her characters and the book was a little too raunchy for my tastes.  Jane spends most of the novel as a complete snob, and it bothered me that she judged people so heavily on their appearances when she knew perfectly well that people could be more than that.  I should have been delighted that her prejudices got absolutely torn apart and she had to face reality, but I was already too annoyed with her to bother!

My negative reaction to this book won’t really stop me from reading more Victoria Dahl, though – the concept of the book was very good and I liked the writing a lot.  I think I’ll try another one of her books and see if the characters annoy me less!

Stealing Water, Tim Ecott

Tim’s parents give up their home in Ireland to move to South Africa, a land where Tim’s father believes he has a respectable job waiting, and where Tim’s mother believes she will finally be free of the boggy Irish weather.  But things don’t turn out as they expect and the family become virtual vagabonds, struggling to get by.

This was okay, but I think is one instance where I enjoyed the idea of the book more than the book itself.  The family’s South African life is so full of crazy, illegal antics that, even though they were often necessary to survive, it made me uncomfortable.  There were aspects I enjoyed, though; my favorite bit was when Tim worked in a Johannesburg hotel, at a total contrast to his home life, and became acquainted with guests solely based on their voices.  It was clever and funny.  I also enjoyed glimpses of period department stores and cities.

I also struggled because I couldn’t really understand the way his parents worked; I would basically never do what they all did, much less not return immediately, or as soon as I could, once I realized things were going haywire.  I felt for Tim quite often but it was hard to relate to everything that happened.

Visions of Heat, Nalini Singh

Faith is an F-Psy, meaning she can predict the future.  She’s one of the best, which also means that she is bound to go mad eventually, but she’s making her family rich in the meantime.  Outside her home lurks Vaughn, a changeling jaguar who longs to know more about the girl he senses behind the walls of the compound.  When Faith comes out, she and Vaughn collide, opening her to emotions and physical sensations she’d never dreamed of.  When the Psy world no longer begins to make sense, Faith wonders if she and Vaughn can make a life for themselves without it.

I definitely enjoyed this, and the world-building that went on, but I didn’t really find it to be anything particularly out of the ordinary.  As usual I find Nalini Singh’s love scenes a little too racy and a little too frequent for my personal taste.  I’ve read that she tones down the heat in the next volume, though, as well as lays on the plot, and I’m really interested to see what happens to Judd, so I think I’ll keep on reading.

I am an Amazon Associate. I did not receive any of these books for review.

Review: Monsters of Men, Patrick Ness

This review contains spoilers for the entire Chaos Walking seriesDon’t read this, read them!

War makes monsters of men, and Todd and Viola are discovering just how true that saying is.  Separated once again, Todd has remained with the mayor to keep him calm while Viola has gone with the Answer and her new shipmates to broker a compromise.  Into the mix we’re thrown a third character with his own perspective on events, set to radically change both the way Todd and Viola think about their new world and their strategy for the forthcoming war.

Everything about this book is basically awesome.  Patrick Ness has taken on enormous issues in this series and executed them perfectly, without a hitch, sending out clear anti-war themes but at the same time showing just how humans are so susceptible to dictatorships and strong personalities.

First of all, what struck me as so eerily true to life is the way that Mayor Prentiss can simply take charge, how he can twist reality to suit himself without ever suffering any flack for it.  It reminded me most of the way that the media can twist things as they wish, but most people don’t bother to research (or watch more than one TV channel) so they’ll never know the truth of the way the world works.  Even Todd and Viola know vastly more than they’re told, but they still find it easier to settle into the same grooves they’ve known their whole lives.  Todd himself finds it easiest to dehumanize the Spackle because they aren’t exactly the same as him even though they are thinking, speaking beings like he is, just because he’s committed atrocities against them and needs a reason to do so.  The introduction of the third character throws a wrench into those plans, both for readers and for Todd.

Throughout the book my heart ached most for Todd and I simultaneously feared for him.  He gets far too close to the Mayor and is convinced he’s acting for good, but I knew he couldn’t be, that the mayor was a force for dissent and fear.  But as we learn by the end, even that’s not entirely true.  The worst character in the series is himself multi-faceted with surprising reasons for how he works, which don’t excuse him but help us understand him.  Each and every character with page time in this book is a complex human being with believable motives and actions.  It’s a genuine work of art.

The entire book is sobering in its depiction of war, especially as Todd is growing up in the midst of it.  It’s evident from both his actions and even from the text itself as the spelling mistakes and grammatical errors slow down drastically in this third installment.  He’s becoming a man, but how I feared he wasn’t going to live to get all the way there.  The constant battles and struggles speedily mature him, so much so that it was easy to forget his true age.  Not all that much time has passed since he first discovered Viola, that pocket of silence amidst the Noise.  And I keep talking about Todd, but it was Viola who became my favorite character, for her strength and reason and love.

I wish I was talented enough to articulate clearly the many ways Monsters of Men – and the rest of the series – made me think and feel.  I borrowed this book from the library but I know it’s one that I’ll need to own and reread in its entirety.  It’s incredibly powerful in so many ways and I truly think is literature at its finest; it’s a series with a lot to say about the world, not only Todd’s but our own, and with a fantastic story to go along with it.  What more could any reader ask for?

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Review: Notes from a Big Country, Bill Bryson

After twenty years in England, Bill Bryson and his family moved back to his native United States, for reasons he can’t quite fathom.  To his surprise, his country has changed a lot since he last lived there.  Even though he isn’t particularly inclined to write a newspaper column about it, his friend asks him to, and his essays are published weekly.  This book is a collection of some of these essays, on topics ranging from the tax system to sports to garbage disposals.

I’m on a bit of a Bill Bryson spree these days, so I picked this book up without really thinking about it.  I found its quality to be more variable than the first two books of his I read, but overall it was still very enjoyable.  Bryson’s humor is excellent and he makes even the most mundane exchanges into passages that have me giggling away, to the extent that my husband asks what’s so funny and is, I suspect, now eager to get his hands on one of Bryson’s books.

The funniest passages were easily the ones that I have had experience with.  This book is now quite dated; it was published in 1998 and so all of the essays are from before that time.  As a result, things in America aren’t the same as they were, but I can remember a lot of this from my childhood.  The catalogues, for example; it did feel at times like we got a catalogue for everything under the sun without ever actually asking for them.  Plenty of trees were wasted for this purpose, but some of the products in catalogues were delightful and exciting, even if I can’t actually remember ever ordering anything out of them.

Some of the sections didn’t work quite so well; these are generally the few that don’t consist of actual anecdotes but are just him trying to demonstrate the absurdity of things like tax forms.  There are also some outdated ones which no longer strike the right note, like his comments on computers.  Overall, though, these are only a few pages long so they don’t detract too much from the overall humor of the book.

It’s also best to approach this knowing that mostly he makes fun of Americans and American things, but as he seems to do this with everything, it didn’t bother me.  It just amused me because most of it was true and his style of writing makes it clear that nothing is really an insult at all.  It’s just, for the most part, a very amusing book about American culture.

Notes from a Big Country is not quite a travelogue, but it’s an entertaining look at America through a former expat’s eyes.  Despite the few off notes, if you like Bill Bryson’s books, you’ll enjoy this one too.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Review: A Castle in Spain, Matthew Parris

One spring morning in Catalunya, Matthew Parris came across an awesome sight; a large, moldering, old house that immediately spoke to him.  Clearly medieval and once high status and in the process of remodeling, the house had been left to sit and rot for at least fifty years.  It was called L’Avenc; virtually everyone in the small nearby town knew about it and thought its slow destruction was sad, but none of them was going to save it.  So Parris, his sister Belinda and her husband, and her husband’s brother put together the money and purchased the house themselves.  The remodelling took longer and was more expensive than any of them had imagined, but their goal to save the house kept them going through catastrophe after catastrophe.

I’ve seen it bandied about that this entire book is mostly an advertisement for the holiday cottages Parris and his family built alongside the house, but I thought it was quite a lot more than that, especially considering I didn’t even realize that you could stay there until halfway through the book.  (Of course, I want to now, so if it was an advertisement, it worked.)  I loved the fact that these four people took on this medieval house.  One of them did research into its origins and found out the various stages of its actual construction; parts of it date from the 12th century.  Anyone who spends hundreds of thousands to rescue a medieval house is awesome, and this book truly gets across the author’s love for this house and its character.

He also conveys the vast difficulty, sometimes seemingly insurmountable, of actually restoring the house.  The roof was falling in, the floors were rotting away, and there were no plumbing, electricity, or telephone lines.  The construction went on for years, hampered by legal difficulties and an angry neighbor who cut off the family’s water supply and refused to reinstate it.  It’s not even finished when the book is, although I think it must be by now.

A Castle in Spain is also partly travelogue, with Parris extoling the virtues of various parts of Catalunya (also spelled Catalonia).  He expresses plenty of regret that people mostly visit Spain to go to cramped beaches and cities instead of exploring the beauty of its interior, Catalunya in particular.  I must admit that despite my recent interest in travelogues, I found these parts a bit boring.  I would love to visit Spain, but I am not sure Parris’s writing style is that suited to it, and I found his discussions of the house much more interesting.

This book is a very interesting tale of a family and a mission, with some history and culture thrown in for good measure.  It is perhaps not the most standout of its genre, but it certainly made me curious about the area.  I wish I could actually afford one of the holiday cottages, if only to see it all myself in person.  Recommended if you like travelogues, memoirs, and old, crumbling houses. It seems to be out of print, but used copies are about for fairly low prices.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Review: Bess of Hardwick, Mary S. Lovell

Bess of Hardwick wasn’t born to privilege.  The daughter of a relatively small landlord, she rose to high status slowly and purposefully.  Placed in high status houses, she married four men and outlived all of them.  She also outlived three monarchs and built a number of houses, the most prestigious of which is Hardwick Hall in Derbyshire.  She became one of the richest and most powerful women in Elizabethan and early Stuart England, a time when women were still chattel, and died wealthy, in a house that she herself had constructed, after a long and productive life.

My first encounter with Bess of Hardwick was in the novel A Woman of Passion by Virginia Henley.  I was still in my initial romance novel stage of reading, and much of that particular novel is romantic, but it really led me to be curious about the woman behind the fiction, the actual Bess of Hardwick.  It also ends when she marries Shrewsbury, or so I recall, which leaves plenty of interesting years completely without mention.  Then just recently I visited Hardwick Hall myself and was reminded of why I was so interested in her.  The house itself is ridiculously impressive, with its huge windows, imposing winding staircases, and immense visiting halls.  I wanted to know more, and so when I saw this book in the library, I decided it was time.

On first impression, I was actually amazed at how easy this was to read.  I love history, but it does take longer to read and naturally provokes more thought than an average fiction novel, at least for me.  This, though, was so interesting and enjoyable that I actually found myself going well beyond my daily page targets because I just was so curious about what happened next.  Bess’s childhood is mostly skimmed over, of necessity really since very little information is available about her specifically.  Instead, the author regales us with all sorts of interesting information about Tudor childhoods in general and Bess’s family in particular.  I knew some of it, but not all of it, and I was completely fascinated, as I was with most of the book.

Lovell then goes on to talk about Bess’s various marriages, her children, and her gradual rise to power and prominence.  She quotes from plenty of letters, although mostly from others to Bess, and keeps everything in a neat and tidy timeline so that it’s easy to trace Bess’s life from start to finish.  There are plenty of details and documentation, and she does argue with the generally accepted historical record sometimes – including denouncing some of my favorites, those pesky historical “facts” which seem to have no basis in actual documentation.  These are generally started by a historian somewhere along the way (usually in the 19th century) who of course did not name his sources and probably just made up that particular fact.  There is no way of actually knowing if it’s true or not, so it’s best to stick with what we actually do know.  So the book was not just an entertaining biography, but intellectually stimulating as well.

Bess of Hardwick brought home to me how much I miss history with its fascinating portrait of a woman who proved her worth over and over again.  Undoubtedly Bess would have been the CEO of some humongous corporation these days, but in her own time she was a clever, enchanting woman who made her money work for her, loved her husbands and children, and generally proves everyone who denounces Tudor women wrong.  I would enthusiastically recommend this book to anyone who enjoys history, especially Tudor history.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Review: Wu, Jonathan Clements

Empress Wu was the first woman in Chinese history to become a reigning empress.  Getting there wasn’t easy; as a lower concubine, which she became at the age of 13, Wu was little more than a servant, and would have been banished to a convent forever on the death of Emperor Taizong.  Luckily for her, she encountered his son Gaozong before his death, and Gaozong became enamored with her, taking her from the convent and eventually replacing his current empress with her.  With that mission accomplished, Wu set forth on her goal to achieve recognition for herself and, in some ways, for all Chinese women; her methods may have been brutal, but so was the time in which she lived.

Anyone who thinks the Tudors are exciting and scandalous should try on the 7th century Chinese for a change!  I was frankly amazed at all the drama, scandal, and murder that went on in this court and over the course of the book.  It’s fairly well documented but even so, I’m quite shocked that other people can treat each other so badly and not really seem to notice.  This book was nothing short of exciting, especially for non-fiction; it’s no wonder that Wu’s life has been depicted in writing and in film a number of times over the years.

I didn’t know too much about Wu to start with; I had never read anything about her, but after I finished Under Heaven I set out looking for non-fiction about the same time period.  This is set a number of years before, but the events herein had a large impact on the following history, so I just went with this book.  Let me tell you, my interest in Chinese history is properly rewarding.  Wu was a completely fascinating woman and I’m surprised that we have so much information on someone who lived so long ago.  I can place her nicely in the context of Europe and I’m amazed at how different the cultures are.

I was also surprised at how many things were the same in China as they would be in the late nineteenth century.  Now, I haven’t read any non-fiction about that period yet, but just from reading Empress Orchid I recognized the huge palaces, the tropes of different levels of concubines with different names brought in purposely to please the emperor, the huge amount of ceremonial events, and of course the endless intrigue.

What I loved most about this book, however, was easily Clements’s even-handed treatment of Wu and all of her cronies.  Yes, she did some pretty terrible things; there were some more terrible things she might have done or her relatives might have done under her name; and then there were good things that she did.  For example, she murdered the Empress before her and a rival concubine by drowning them in wine after dismembering them.  She also may have conveniently offed her kids.  That’s pretty bad, and I don’t think anyone is going to absolve her of those crimes.  But she also raised the profile of women by increasing the mourning time for mothers and insisting on incorporating female halves of traditionally male ceremonies.  Yes, she was ruthless and furthered her own ambitions, but she also did her part to make women important, too.

I also loved at the end how Clements stepped back and looked at Wu’s behavior in light of other, male emperors, and came to the conclusion that she behaved similarly to them.  She had lots of lovers, she killed her enemies, but China prospered under her rule.  Men who behaved just like that were regarded as heroes, while she has been regularly vilified throughout history.  Is it just because a woman had the daring to act like a man?

I don’t know, but I like historians who question prejudice about women.  Murder is never a good thing, but should a woman be condemned for it more than a man?  I don’t think so.

Anyway, I’ll just conclude by highly recommending Wu. I think the subtitle (the Chinese empress who schemed, seduced, and murdered her way to become a living God) isn’t so good, but the book itself is just excellent.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library – but you can bet I’ll be buying this guy’s other books.

Review: Down Under, Bill Bryson

There are more things in Australia that can kill you than anywhere else, so how could Bill Bryson ever keep away from writing a travel memoir about the country?  In his travels from coast to coast and several places in between, Bryson both entertains and informs us about a place that, for its size and place in the world, we know surprisingly little about.

Bill Bryson is a delightful writer and I almost wish I’d discovered him sooner!  Down Under is my first proper travel book by him and I can’t tell you how eager I am to read more.  It’s true that I know very little about Australia, so much of the information he shared was completely new to me.  In my job, I’ve done some writing about Australia, but mainly about tourism; it was fascinating to have the historical perspective given to me so I could set it aside my knowledge of the country’s more hospitable places.

My favorite parts of the memoir were generally when he was exploring the middle, largely uninhabitable parts of the country.  It’s hard to believe just how many expeditions were launched there – and equally hard to believe that the Australians haven’t managed to spread across such a vast amount of land.  Yet with Bryson writing, I could feel the dust and the heat and I am pretty sure I now know why no one really wants to live there; not only is it far from every amenity but there’s truly no purpose to eking a life out in such difficult conditions.

I like that Bryson seems to travel in the same way that I do; I’d struggle to really identify with someone who does things I’d never experience.  As it is, Australia is expensive, and I won’t go there for years if ever, so I could almost feel like I was experiencing things through his eyes.  He chats with people, visits monuments that I’d visit, and at the same time shares the fascinating history and culture of the country.  I can’t imagine a better honorary tour guide.  I wouldn’t have minded some pictures, but he writes well enough that I could picture the locations in my head – or just look online, as I did several times – easily enough.

What truly disturbed me overall was the treatment of native Australians – a problem that lies more with the Australian government than with Bryson.  I was appalled to learn about the Stolen Generations and even more saddened to discover that many Aboriginal Australians drift through life, missing out on schools and jobs or any parts of modern life.  It’s even sadder to hear the way that white Australians have simply given up and don’t know what to do about it.  I almost wish Bryson had brought this more to the forefront of the book, rather than asking about it occasionally and being stymied, but I’m not sure what else he could have done, especially not if he aimed to keep the tone of the rest of the book light and funny as he did.

Anyway, I thought Down Under was an excellent read.  It certainly helped me get a broader picture of Australia and educated me in some senses at the same time.  I can’t wait to read more by Bill Bryson.

In the US, this book is titled In a Sunburned Country. I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Review: The Boy Who Loved Books, John Sutherland

John Sutherland grew up fatherless after his father died in an aviation accident while training for combat in World War II.  (Did you know they allowed a 5% mortality rate in training for war?  No?  I didn’t either.)  He grew up virtually motherless as well, since his mother was determined to live her life as she saw fit, whether that involved living in Argentina, sleeping with American soldiers, or leaving John to relatives on a regular basis.  Throughout his childhood, John sought refuge in one thing, books.  He lived and breathed the classics, ignoring his assigned work for his own personal choices.  When he got older, John also found solace in alcohol, and the two remained standbys for much of his life.

I’m a bit torn about this one.  I think I liked the concept more than the execution.  I love the idea of a memoir about someone’s life in books, and this one promised that books saved Sutherland’s life twice.  I didn’t really get much of that from the book, though, and overall it was much more just a life story than a life story in books.  There are plenty of literary references, sure, and he does mention what he’s reading at times, but I think the entire book was hampered by the fact that I didn’t find John’s life particularly interesting otherwise and, more importantly, I didn’t really like John.

I can’t understand the pain of growing up without a parent, much less the pain of growing up pretty much without either of them, so I can’t speak on personal experience.  I do think it’s understandable that he would struggle emotionally as a result.  But some of his attitudes just failed to match mine so spectacularly that it made it hard for me to relate to him.  As an example, John rarely read books for school on purpose.  He hated assigned reading so, even though he was perfectly capable of understanding assigned texts and doing really well in school, he generally performed poorly on pretty much every exam he was ever given.  This attitude follows him throughout his childhood, even though he must see that his grandparents and even his mother struggle along on a rock bottom basic education.  He has opportunities – his mother pays for him to go to great schools – and he just throws them away.  I’ve never really understood people who do this.

The worst part about it is that he then goes on to become a professor, just because there are so many positions and so few takers!  It seemed wrong to me that someone who mostly disdained school throughout his life can then go on to have the best job in the whole system.  I shouldn’t be so harsh, though, as people can change, and his eventual university education does leave a mark on him.  I could more easily understand his willingness to bury himself in drink, but I was glad when he gave it up.

The other big problem I had was with John’s mother, who I think was the reason in large part he struggled through childhood.  She more or less completely ignores him, pawning him off on relatives and friends, especially when she has a man around.  She pays his way through life but seems hardly ever emotionally invested; it’s clear that John adores her but that seems mostly based around her beauty and her determination to have her own way, even at the expense of his own happiness.  I can see that up to a point, but abandoning your child for three years while you go to live in Argentina?  I don’t see that so much.

What I did enjoy was the historical background and the brilliant depiction of Britain throughout John’s younger years.  He talks about things that were already disappearing, like quiet times fishing with his grandfather, and the history of Colchester (the town he mostly grows up in) and its schools.  He’s undoubtedly a very good writer and I think he could pull off a novel if he tried, especially if he set it in the places he knows best.

The Boy Who Loved Books definitely had issues, but Sutherland is a good writer.  If you can ignore the aspects I had problems with, I think this would be a good choice.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Review: Empress Orchid, Anchee Min

Orchid’s family is of ancient Manchurian lineage, but they are dirt poor throughout her childhood.  When her father dies, things get even worse, and she is forced to move to Peking with her mother, brother, and sister to live in a small house with her uncle’s family.  Orchid starts work in a shoe shop and actually enjoys herself, mainly for the tales her boss tells her about the Forbidden City and the emperor’s many palaces.  When Orchid is told that she must marry her slovenly, stupid cousin, though, she seeks refuge from her fate in a contest to become one of the young emperor’s new favorite concubines.  Orchid finds herself chosen, but her world in the imperial palace is nothing like she’d imagined.

After the disappointment that was Katherine, I tempered my hopes for Empress Orchid.  I would probably have waited a bit longer before reading it, but it was due back at the library and I had no choice.  Besides that, I immediately wanted to read more about China, and particularly a book that was based on historical fact, after Under Heaven.  I needn’t have worried about starting it so soon, though, because I thoroughly enjoyed this book and was completely fascinated by not only the characters portrayed within but also the entire Chinese culture that Min effortlessly depicts.

Orchid’s life in the book goes through a series of phases (and is picked up in the next volume, The Last Empress, which I have yet to read).  She is first a pauper, a girl who would be beautiful if only she could actually eat once in a while or wear a pretty dress.  She’s devastated by her father’s death, but that doesn’t stop her from seizing the opportunity to become the emperor’s concubine.  Then she discovers life in the palace isn’t all it’s cracked up to be – after all, the emperor can have literally any woman he wants.  He’s a spoiled brat convinced that he has the mandate of heaven, so Orchid (then Lady Yehonala) ceases to matter to him as soon as his gaze has drifted elsewhere.

After a bit of research on the internet, I’ve discovered that Anchee Min is actually a lot more sympathetic to Orchid than history has been.  Here she’s depicted as a fairly wise woman who loves her son, loves her “husband”, and is much cleverer than anyone wants to give her credit for.  I loved the politics involved in the book and I was fascinated by the extreme protocol of the Chinese court.  It wasn’t as racy as I’d suspected either; the whole seduction part is a tiny fragment of the book.  It’s much more about China’s collision with the rest of the world, the attitudes of the royal family to Orchid and towards the world, and about Orchid herself.

Empress Orchid was incredibly engaging and I would whole-heartedly recommend it to anyone interested in historical fiction or China.  I am definitely going to read the sequel, The Last Empress, and seek out more books about this time period in the future.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Review: Shiver, Maggie Stiefvater

When she was a child, Grace was attacked and bitten by werewolves.  She was only saved by the intervention of a yellow-eyed wolf, who has continued to watch her progress throughout her life.  Now 17, Grace is making her way through high school but maintains a strange feeling of kinship with “her wolf”.  When she meets a boy, Sam, with those same yellow eyes, Grace immediately feels drawn to him, especially when she realizes that he truly is a werewolf.  As they fall in love, Grace and Sam struggle to find a way to be together before he turns into a wolf permanently.

I really, really wish I had liked this book more than I did!  I’ve had a number of comments already from people who just loved this book and I was really looking forward to it.  I think in this case, expectations really ruined the book for me.  With the use of the word “chilling” on the cover and the fact that it was a book about werewolves, and that was more or less all I knew, I guess I expected it to be creepier.  Or at least creepy somehow.  Instead, “chilling” referred to the fact that winter’s cold turns the werewolves into their wolf selves.  I felt a bit misled and perhaps if I’d paid more attention to reviews beforehand, I wouldn’t have been particularly annoyed.

As it was, this book is basically a teenage paranormal romance.  As I was reading it, I could tell that my sixteen year old self would have been head over heels for it.  But since I expected more, or at least something else, I wound up disappointed – I often do when I think I’m reading something and it turns into something else.  The romance was sweet enough but it was clearly predetermined from the beginning and the story didn’t really have any twists that set it apart from a regular romance novel.  I’m fine with all of these things when I know they’re happening, but for some reason this book and I didn’t click at all.  Many of the scenes were slow-moving, focusing on just Sam and Grace and their developing relationship.  There was a bit of drama focusing on Grace’s friends and a boy that goes after the wolves, but I was just reminded a little too much of what it was like to be a teenager.

I also really disliked how absent minded Grace’s parents were.  It really brought home to me how much this is a flaw in YA books; I found it hard to believe a father could just forget his small daughter in a car days after she’d been violently attacked by werewolves!  And what parents would miss the fact that their house was now inhabited by another person, sleeping in their daughter’s bed?  It’s hard to believe parents could claim to love their child and then completely ignore everything she does.  I’m sure they’re out there, but Grace’s parents just annoyed me every time they appeared in a scene.

Regardless of my disappointments, I still felt that the book was well-written, with Sam and Grace having distinct voices that made it easy for me to tell the difference between them.  Stiefvater’s prose is lovely, with a number of gorgeous descriptions – that special part of the woods comes to mind immediately and I wish I had the book with me to quote it.  I would certainly be interested in reading another book by her, but I think for once I’ll investigate a little more about the plot before I commit myself.

Would I recommend Shiver?  I don’t know; probably not to someone who expected a creepier book!  But I do think people who enjoy paranormal romance (or Twilight) would like it, as attested by its popularity.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.