November 2026
S M T W T F S
« Mar    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

BTT: Where’s the Symbolism?

btt2My husband is not an avid reader, and he used to get very frustrated in college when teachers would insist discussing symbolism in a literary work when there didn’t seem to him to be any. He felt that writers often just wrote the story for the story’s sake and other people read symbolism into it.

It does seem like modern fiction just “tells the story” without much symbolism. Is symbolism an older literary device, like excessive description, that is not used much any more? Do you think there was as much symbolism as English teachers seemed to think? What are some examples of symbolism from your reading?

When I was in college, everyone asked me this question.  Symbolism is alive and well in modern literary fiction and the authors aren’t subtle about it either.  I got symbolism out of Stephen King in high school and my teacher complimented me on seeing stuff that no one else saw.  I used It and Carrie and all I remember is that it had something to do with circles.  The Remains of the Day is practically dripping with symbolism, right down to the title of the book.  The great thing about studying literature is that you can find things that the author didn’t intend that imbues the work with meaning for you and for other people.  It can have a wider meaning that the author never saw, or maybe one they intended only specific people to see.  It’s a little like how everyone’s experience of a book is different.  The author puts the book out, but everyone comes to it with different life experiences and interprets it in ways relevant to themselves.  Obviously, we’re going to pick it apart in ways the author didn’t intend.

Let’s take an example of this.  I’m sure the author of Firefly Lane didn’t intend for me to develop a burning hatred towards it because one of the characters got cancer and it hit a little too close to home for me (yes, other things bugged me about it, but I was very unhappy with the author’s plot development).  On the other hand, she probably did intend for women who are older than me to relate to Tully and Kate as they grew up over the decades, and from the reviews, they did.  Women who could relate tended to love the book.  The author just wanted to tell a story, but how we feel about it is always going to be our own experience.  Similarly, the way we interpret literature in an academic sense is always going to be more than the author intended, unless it’s one of those ultra-literary books that you practically need a class in to dig out all of the meaning.

Or we could go with Twilight.  There are all sorts of alarming messages screaming out from the relationships in that book, but women still love Edward.  Did Stephenie Meyer intend for us to interpret the relationship between Bella and Edward as harmful and abusive?  Probably not, especially given how often she describes Edward as “perfect”.

See my point?  The author’s intentions don’t carry as much weight as you might think.  As a result, I’m not sure we can say that because the author didn’t intend it, an interpretation isn’t valid.  In fact, I outright don’t think we can.  I love to know what an author intended and I think it’s very important, but I still feel the way I feel.

In fact, I know a few authors out there who read this blog, so if you’re reading, what do you think?

What about readers?  Am I wrong, is the author all-important and my opinion falls to the wayside once I know theirs?  Or is every interpretation (with supporting evidence of course) valid?

Share

Review: Queen’s Cross, Lawrence Schoonover

Infanta Isabella of Castile and Leon is that priceless jewel in a failing country, a skilled leader, but when she is young, no one has a chance to find out.  She is exiled from court by her impotent half-brother the king, nearly married off to a much older, unappealing man, and even thrust in a dungeon to prevent her from gaining visibility.  Only when Isabella is officially named heir to the throne does she begin to take power for herself, starting with her choice of husband.  Ferdinand, heir to Aragon and king of Sicily, is not only handsome but her path towards the unification of Spain.  Together, Ferdinand and Isabella pursue this course, bringing Spain to the forefront of power in Europe in one short reign.

I’m going to start off by saying that since this is a reissue of an older historical novel, the history is outdated.  Knowing that, I managed to not get annoyed when an envoy from Richard, duke of Gloucester (with a withered arm, no less!) appeared offering his hand in marriage to Isabella, suggesting that he would be king someday.  At the time Richard would also have been a teenager and hardly convinced of his place in the English royal succession, much less in a position to negotiate his own marriages.  Sorry, I nitpick.  To contrast with a positive example, I was just thrilled when Schoonover mentioned that fifteenth-century people knew the world was round.

The novel also reflects certain 1950s values which I found alternately charming and strange in a historical novel.  Isabella is clearly a mighty monarch.  She is clever and at times ruthless.  She also, however, has a strange predilection for weeping and acknowledging that her husband needs to do manly things away from her occasionally, like lead armies, and she arranges little tasks behind his back so that he’ll feel useful, like a man should.  I felt almost as though Isabella had to be a housewife AND a queen to satisfy everyone’s ideal.  Ferdinand is constantly upset when she does something without him or has power that he does not share.  Maybe I’m reading too much into that – after all, how many kings really want their queens to be more powerful than them? – but it stuck out a little to me.

All that said, this novel had a wonderful sort of charm that I wouldn’t discount at all.  It feels old-fashioned, but in a lovely sit in an armchair and get absorbed in an enthralling story feel.  Everything has a slightly magical, ethereal edge to it.  This is a land long ago past and there is a tinge of nostalgia throughout the entire book that is eminently compelling.  Despite Isabella’s fluctuation between dominant and submissive, I really liked her and particularly her friend, Beatriz.  I liked this book.  It reminded me of the books I used to read when I was a kid, before I particularly cared who was who in the historical world.  It’s like a visit to my grandma’s house.  Everything there is familiar and comfortable but has a bit of an aged feel to it.  There is no computer, no DVD player, but a set of wedding china and pictures from when my parents were younger than I am now.  That is how this book feels.

In that sense, I would probably recommend it!  It was clearly fairly popular in its day, and while it does feel aged, it still has a lovely story to tell.  Maybe all the dots don’t add up anymore, but they still make a picture worth looking at.

Buy Queen’s Cross on Amazon.

Share

Review: Palace Circle, Rebecca Dean

Summary from the publisher:

Palace intrigue, romance, and illicit affairs—Rebecca Dean has written a glorious novel that will sweep Philippa Gregory fans off their feet.

Delia Chandler, an eighteen-year-old Southern girl, marries Viscount Ivor Conisborough just before World War II, becoming part of the Windsor court. It’s every girl’s dream come true. But Delia is jolted from her pleasant life when she realizes, after the birth of her two daughters, that Ivor chose her only to bear an heir to his estate. Shortly thereafter, she begins an affair with her husband’s handsome, titled, and frequently scandalous best friend.

When Conisborough is appointed as an adviser to King Fuad of Egypt, Delia exchanges one palace circle for another, far different one. While she sees Egypt as a place of exile, her two daughters regard Egypt as their home. Only when war comes to Cairo—and Delia finally reveals the secret she has kept for so long—can she begin to heal the divisions separating her from those she loves.

Rebecca Dean’s irresistible combination of real events and masterful storytelling will keep readers fascinated until the very last page.

This book didn’t capture me, I’ll start by saying that.  The category of “historical fiction lite” applies perfectly here.  There are historical characters, but only on the sidelines.  The actual main characters fell flat for me, particularly Delia, who frustrated me with her frivolity and total inability to relate or talk to her daughters.  The novel’s viewpoint rotates from Delia to Petronella to Davina, but I had the distinct feeling that the girl who was narrating seemed different from the girl who had been described before or after.  Character changes over time, but it wasn’t convincing.  Neither were the love stories, even though in retrospect it’s as though the entire novel is a rotating battle through romance.  Obviously, I read romance, and shouldn’t have a problem with such a focus, but the book felt too shallow for me.  This is the lead-up to World War II, after all!  Maybe the high society didn’t feel it but everyone else did.  The only concession to the times is one of the sisters’ charity work.  Even the move to Egypt isn’t explored the way it might have been and feels very much like the British court all over again rather than a different culture.  We are thrown a few bones in the way of revolution, but not many details or actions take place.

In the end, reading this book was little like watching a soap opera.  The characters are caricatures, the situations are ridiculous, and none of it seems to reflect on real life events in anything but a shallow way.  Moreover, literally everyone is having an affair, which may have been the case but was still repugnant to me.  The book is enjoyable in a light, frothy way that doesn’t appeal to me.  Had I approached it as a light read, in the vein of one of my romances, I may have been able to get more into it, but I tend to think of historical fiction as deeper, even when it focuses on a royal court.  This was not, and it disappointed me.

Check out Palace Circle on Amazon.

Share

How to Have Fun During a Siege

sot-180During a siege, knights would host tournaments (in this case, probably jousts) to amuse themselves, and sometimes they’d even invite some of the besieged knights to join them.  Sieges were boring and jousts were amusing.  By the later middle ages, very few knights died in jousts, so the risks were small and the excitement factor was high.

Okay, who knew that?  I know I didn’t.  Moreover, why don’t historical novelists feature some of these tournaments?  Personally, I see loads of potential for tension between enemies if they’re out jousting with each other, or even between romantic leads if the hero’s life is suddenly in danger, and the author could kill off characters from something much more exciting than dysentery.

Sound good to anyone else?

If you know an author who does have tournaments in depth besides Elizabeth Chadwick and Sharon Kay Penman, leave me a comment!  I’d love to read fictionalized tournaments, I think it would help me grasp this a little better.  I have plenty of academic work on the subject already.

Also, am I the only person out there who would just love to try on actual medieval armor?  It could be a replica, but I want to know what it really felt like.  I’ll skip riding a warhorse though.  The one time I did ride an actual horse and not a pony, I was terrified and the horse acted up on purpose because it mysteriously knew, and I would not like to repeat that experience!

Share

Review: Frenchman’s Creek, Daphne du Maurier

Lady Dona St. Columb leads a life in London with which she has grown tired.  After doing something that even she finds reprehensible, she takes her children and flees to her husband’s country estate, Navron, trying her best to get away from him, his friends, and her own scandalous reputation.  While walking at Navron, she discovers someone who helps her to completely reevaluate herself, her life, and learn to be a woman that she likes rather than a woman she despises.

My expectations for this book were about medium.  I loved Rebecca and really did not care for The House on the Strand. I really enjoyed this book, though.  I tend to always appreciate books about self-discovery, and Dona does a great deal of discovering.  She has a lot of hard looks at her life and what she’s doing with it and she figures she wants something else.  That something else is actually a lot more scandalous than her current life, but she definitely grows as a person, especially regarding the decisions she makes towards the end.

Du Maurier seems to have a thing for characters without real names.  The Frenchman has a name, Jean-Benoit, but almost never goes by it.  He exists as an entity, onto which we can place our expectations of a pirate, a Frenchman, a romantic hero, and he can fulfill them.  He’s got a personality, but it’s almost as though his lack of name and real characterization makes him less distinct and almost legendary in his exploits.  I think this is a really interesting device that du Maurier uses and it really adds something to Dona’s infatuation with him; most women have a thing for the mysterious and dangerous man.

I also just love the prose in this book.  It’s sparse but beautiful at the same time.  Let me give you an example that speaks for itself, the first few sentences:

When the east wind blows up Helford River the shining waters become troubled and disturbed and the little waves beat angrily upon the sandy shores.  The short seas break above the bar at ebb-tide, and the waders fly inland to the mud-flats, their wings skimming the surface, and calling to one another as they go.  Only the gulls remain, wheeling and crying above the foam, diving now and again in search of food, their grey feathers glistening with the salt spray.

– p. 1, Frenchman’s Creek.

For me, that evokes some gorgeous imagery and is a fantastic way to set up a book about a pirate and a lady, don’t you think?  Du Maurier’s prose is very distinctive and when the story is good, it works extremely well.  This is the case with Frenchman’s Creek. The story is intriguing and the book is an absolute pleasure to read.  I had a lovely time with this, and I think you would too.

Buy Frenchman’s Creek on Amazon. It’s just been re-released by Sourcebooks and this is a gorgeous edition. If you’ve been interested in reading more by Daphne du Maurier, or you’re looking for a great, well-written piece of fiction, I recommend this book.

Share

[TSS] Read-a-Thon Wrap-up post

deweys-readathonbutton

Number of Books 6 Books Read Old Man’s War
Pages Read 1792 Dead Until Dark
Time Spent Reading 12:31 The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever
Time Spent Blogging 3:27 Living Dead in Dallas
Oakleaf Bearers

That puts my participation at roughly 16 hours.  I was sleeping for 7.  I’m not sure how I lost an hour there!  I did start And Only to Deceive and let me tell you, I am loving it.  This is a fantastic book.  Despite the fact that I read for 12 1/2 hours out of the last 24, I’m definitely going to finish it today.

The Read-a-Thon was a LOT of fun.  I’m really sorry that I didn’t manage to stay up later.  I actually think I would have done better if I’d been at home in the US, because I think I would have stayed up later and read for longer if my start time was at 8 am rather than at 1 pm.  I wake up around then anyway, and I know I can stay up until 3 or so if I try, so I’d have only lost 5 hours rather than 7.

Anyway, on to the end survey:

1. Which hour was most daunting for you?

Definitely the last one at night, from 2-3 am. I always find it really difficult to get past 3 am. My best guess is that I made it to 3:15 before falling asleep with my book still in my hands.

2. Could you list a few high-interest books that you think could keep a Reader engaged for next year?

Old Man’s War, the Sookie Stackhouse series, Oakleaf Bearers, and finally And Only to Deceive were all fabulous choices. They were all fast-moving, interesting reads that kept me going even if I was tired. I’d recommend any of them.

3. Do you have any suggestions for how to improve the Read-a-thon next year?

I liked it! I had trouble participating in the mini-challenges because I thought they would take up too much time, though, I’ll be honest about that. I liked the surveys we could post during our own updates the best. I think that someone who was more interested in taking breaks and had trouble reading for longer would appreciate them more than me, though.  I just wanted to get back to my book after a few minutes.

4. What do you think worked really well in this year’s Read-a-thon?

To be honest, I thought everything worked really well. It seemed very well-run. I’m impressed by you three!

5. How many books did you read?

5 1/2 in total. Well, 216/310 of And Only to Deceive, which is more than halfway.

6. What were the names of the books you read?

Old Man’s War by John Scalzi, Dead Until Dark and Living Dead in Dallas by Charlaine Harris, The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever by Julia Quinn, Oakleaf Bearers by John Flanagan, and And Only to Deceive by Tasha Alexander.

7. Which book did you enjoy most?

This is an impossible question. It’s between Old Man’s War, the Sookie books, and And Only to Deceive. Don’t make me choose!

8. Which did you enjoy least?

The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever. Normally I love Julia Quinn. I think she writes believable, funny romance that also elucidates genuine human failings and emotions, which is something romance can do really well. This one I wanted to throw against the wall and I disliked the main characters by the end. Never happened before with a Quinn.  I decided not to read any more straight romance because I didn’t want to deal with that happening again while I was reading.

9. If you were a Cheerleader, do you have any advice for next year’s Cheerleaders?

I wasn’t a cheerleader!

10. How likely are you to participate in the Read-a-thon again? What role would you be likely to take next time?

Oh, extremely likely. Barring some unavoidable event next time, you’ll find me right here, reading once again. Well, I won’t be living here, but you will find me on this blog. I loved it!

I would once again like to thank everyone who dropped by and commented while I was reading and everyone who was extremely encouraging on twitter.  It would have been much less fun without you!

Share

Read-a-Thon Hour 23

deweys-readathonbuttonNo secret that I fell asleep there, and for a long time.  I only made it to about 3.  I got up at 10, and finished the book I was reading.  I tried to get up earlier, but it was hard. I admire everyone who has stayed up so long!

Number of Books 5 Books Read Old Man’s War
Pages Read 1576 Dead Until Dark
Time Spent Reading 10:43 The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever
Time Spent Blogging 3:08 Living Dead in Dallas
Oakleaf Bearers

I’m not sure what I will read next.  There are still a couple of hours left, though, so I will start something new!  I think I’ll go with And Only to Deceive by Tasha Alexander.  I know I won’t finish it before the 24 hours are up, but maybe later.  Yes, I still feel like reading – I didn’t when I first got up, but I sure do now!

Share

Read-a-Thon Hour 14 & Half-way Survey

deweys-readathonbutton

Number of Books 5 Books Read Old Man’s War
Pages Read 1399 Dead Until Dark
Time Spent Reading 9:21 The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever
Time Spent Blogging 2:53 Living Dead in Dallas

1. What are you reading right now?

Halfway through Oakleaf Bearers by John Flanagan.  I think this has a different name outside the UK.  It’s the fourth in the Ranger’s Apprentice series.

2. How many books have you read so far?

4 total.  This is my fifth.

3. What book are you most looking forward to for the second half of the Read-a-thon?

I’m not sure I’m going to get through another book!  I don’t know which one I’ll pick, either.  I just stood in front of my bookshelves for a while, having shunned my pile, before I chose this one.  I might go for the short stories in Tea and Other Ayama Na Tales next if I haven’t fallen asleep when I finish this book.  I’m sure I’ll be up before 1 tomorrow, though, and I’m not sure what I’ll choose then.

4. Did you have to make any special arrangements to free up your whole day?

Not really.  I just had to do extra work ahead of time.  Keith wasn’t meant to visit this weekend anyway.

5. Have you had many interruptions? How did you deal with those?

My parents called a couple of times, but that’s it.  I’ve been hiding in my room all day.

6. What surprises you most about the Read-a-thon, so far?

Hmm, I’m not sure.  It’s about how I’d expected it to be.  I think I was expecting to go on twitter more, and I’m finding myself too tired to focus on it.  I know, I’m a little wimpy, it’s only 2:30 am!

7. Do you have any suggestions for how to improve the Read-a-thon next year?

Nope, it’s going pretty well so far I think.

8. What would you do differently, as a Reader or a Cheerleader, if you were to do this again next year?

We’ll be married by the next time, if one is held in October, and I think what I will like is having someone else prepare and buy me food!  Assuming he is willing.

9. Are you getting tired yet?

Oh, you’d better believe it.  I’m not a late night person these days.

10. Do you have any tips for other Readers or Cheerleaders, something you think is working well for you that others may not have discovered?

Not really!  I’ve picked books that for the most part are very absorbing, so I’m not having all that much trouble focusing on them, just keeping my eyes open for it.

Thanks again for the support, everyone.  I’m too tired to check up on people at this stage, but I’ll either get a second wind or be back to see how everyone’s doing after a nap.

Share

Read-a-Thon, halfway through Hour 12

deweys-readathonbuttonOh, I am getting tired.  It’s nearly half past midnight.  I really want to finish Living Dead in Dallas, though.  I kept meaning to take a break, but it’s so addicting!  I really hope the library has number 3 so I can read it sometime next week.

My stats at this point, nearly halfway through:

Number of Books 4 Books Read Old Man’s War
Pages Read 1170 Dead Until Dark
Time Spent Reading 7:55 The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever
Time Spent Blogging 2:26

The first two were so far much better than the last.  Usually I love Julia Quinn, but I just kept being annoyed by that book.  The romance was unbelievable and I’m sure if I had been involved with the male character that I would have smacked him repeatedly rather than succumb to his advances.  I guess they can’t all be wonderful and funny and distracting!  At least Living Dead in Dallas is helping make up for it.

I want to thank everyone who has been commenting once again for all of your encouragement!  I have had so many new people visit today and I just want to let everyone know that I will be checking out your blogs tomorrow if I haven’t already.  You are all great cheerleaders, and those of you who are readers, I hope you are fulfilling all of your expectations!

Share

Read-a-Thon Hour 9 & Local Library Mini-Challenge

deweys-readathonbutton

Number of Books 3 Books Read Old Man’s War
Pages Read 789 Dead Until Dark
Time Spent Reading 6:14
Time Spent Blogging 1:44

So far I’m not liking The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever as much as Quinn’s other works. It’s going by very quickly, but it’s not as much fun as the best of her books.  In fact, I’m even noticing the bad writing, which is generally a bad sign.  Too many paragraphs starting with “and” or “but”.  Oh well.  It’s still decent, just not as good.

And for the mini-challenge:

  1. What is the name of your local library? What city is it located in?
  2. York Central Library and it’s right in the center of York, next to a museum and the medieval walls.

  3. How often do you go to the library? If you’re a regular, do the staff know you?
  4. Maybe once a week? The staff don’t know me, but I’ve applied for a job there, so they might in future.

  5. Do you browse while you’re there or just pick up items you have placed on reserve?
  6. I browse if I have time! I haven’t been too successful there lately though. I think more people are using it as a result of the recession.

  7. What is your favorite thing about your local library?
  8. Well, honestly, free books. I love that I can get lots of non-fiction and craft books there too, which are normally more expensive than fiction, and I can justify checking out books I wouldn’t necessarily want to buy.

And, back I go! Hope it’s going well for everyone else. I’m off to check!

Share