November 2026
S M T W T F S
« Mar    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

TT: Ratings

ttToday’s question: Do you use a rating system on your blog? How do you feel about using the rating system provided on sites like Library Thing and Amazon? When looking up information on a book you are interested in, do you use the ratings provided by these sites (or similar sites) to help you make the decision on purchasing the book?

This is a very good question for me because I’ve always wondered if I should institute some sort of rating system around here.  I’ve seen number ratings, letter ratings, and star ratings around the blogosphere.  Something in me, however, has always resisted just giving a book a number or a letter.  They are complex and I think almost all of them have bits that are good and bits that are bad.  It’s very hard to categorize, especially after I’ve given my review, and sometimes I’m not sure the star rating I’d give a book matches what I’m trying to get across.  This is why I don’t use them here.

That said, I do use star ratings on LT.  Half the time, it’s a month or more before my review gets over there, and I know that I’m always a bit irritated by people who write reviews and then don’t put a star rating in.  Maybe that’s hypocritical of me given my policy here, and given that I never miss it on other blogs if they lack a rating system, but since the mechanism is there, I like to see both, and I like to add my opinion to the little graph on the side so that it is the most accurate possible.  I have a system for these.  5-star books are perfect, 4-star books I really liked, 3-star books are okay, 2-star books I disliked, and 1-star books I either didn’t finish or I hated the whole way through.

I hate the star system on Amazon, though.  It seems there is something wrong with you there if you use anything less than 4 or 5 stars for a book that perhaps deserves only 3 stars.  3 stars is not bad, in fact, it usually means that the book is fine but it’s not really my cup of tea or didn’t draw me in for some reason.  On Amazon, however, it seems that if you like a book, you must give it a 5 star rating.  As such, it has lost its meaning.  I’ve more or less stopped posting reviews there and only do so for review copies and books that have no reviews but mine.

I’d say I use the star ratings on LT to help me evaluate eventual books to be purchased, but most of my choices are spur-of-the-moment, buying a book I’ve heard of before.  Since I don’t read reviews before I read a book myself (or I put sufficient time between the review and the reading to forget what the plot is about), I don’t have many other choices.

Share

Review: Our Longest Days, Sandra Koa Wing

ourlongestdaysThis is a compilation of several diaries from World War II collected by the Mass Observations project.  This project was designed in 1937 to see what the people of Britain were really thinking.  In the beginning, the writers responded to prompts, but by the start of the war they were asked to keep diaries of their thoughts, feelings, and actions for posterity.  These diarists are surprisingly intimate, giving details of their own lives in far more detail than those of the war, and this collection aims to give us a closer look into how the public really dealt with the war.

I found these diaries to be absolutely riveting.  The book is filled with the everyday life of people going about in war for five years of their lives.  Their lives all change in ways they probably didn’t imagine – some of them say so, like Muriel Green who becomes a gardener for the cause – and it’s absorbing to watch it happen.  I thought the most striking thing about the diaries was that they were not overly dramatic and the people in them did not seem very dismayed by the thought that a bomb could kill them at any time.  Sometimes nearby houses are destroyed with people in them but the diarist in question always remains remarkably calm.  They’ll remark on the bombing of another town, but never seem worried that their own is next, although I’m sure they must have been.  The only outpouring of emotion was from a man who lost his brother in the war, which results in some of the saddest and somehow most beautiful passages conveyed in the book.

Mostly, though, this book is a story full of the little things, improvising meals, shopping for clothes, trying to see sweethearts, job-hunting, dealing with the blackout, a robbery, births, deaths, dances, and kisses.  All the ordinary bits of life go on amidst a country struck by war.  People are people even when the Germans threaten to invade and sirens rush them into bomb shelters multiple times a day.  Even more interesting is considering what these reactions say about the British public at large during World War II.  It would be truly fascinating to compare these diaries with newpapers and other media produced at the time in order to see the differences in reaction to the war.

I was a little disappointed to discover that most of the diarists were given pen names since their families could not be contacted for permission, but it’s understandable.  Apparently the Mass Observation project was viewed in some circles as spying, since diarists gave details of not only their own lives but their neighbors’ as well without permission.  So in this book, names are shortened to a single letter if permission has not been given and summaries of diarists’ lives are reduced to a few lines regarding what they were doing in the war.

Overall I’m delighted to see a historical archive like this published and I can only imagine how amazing it would be to work in such an archive as is still going on now.  I have another book of theirs on my shelf; it is the post-war diaries of Nella Last, one of the most prolific diarists and one whose family has given permission for her real name to be used.  It’s called Nella Last’s Peace.  I’m very much looking forward to it; I’ll be reviewing it in March.

And a final note, I discovered after completing the compilation that the editor, Sandra Koa Wing, passed away aged only 28 in 2007 after a battle with cancer.  I think this wonderful book is a tribute to her since her future career in history was cut so tragically short.

Buy Our Longest Days: A People’s History of the Second World War on Amazon.

Share

Review: The Help, Kathryn Stockett

In Jackson, Mississippi, three women meet and do their best to make an unforgettable mark on their town’s history.  Aibileen is a black maid who in part, raises white children for a living, always leaving before the children get too old.  Skeeter is a recent graduate from college, has scandalously not come home with a husband, and is determined to write but not sure how to go about doing it or even what to write about.  Minny is Aibileen’s best friend and also a maid, but far too out-spoken to get an ordinary job at this stage.  All these women put their lives and futures at risk so their voices can be heard; they just can’t put up with it any longer.

I was surprised by how much I loved this book.  Each character is given individual sections of the novel and together they form a powerful narrative voice that is touching and significant at once.  The difference between Skeeter’s life and those of Aibileen and Minny is immense and appalling, particularly how white people had blinders on and did ridiculous things like installing a second toilet just for the black servants to use.  Perhaps the most affecting part of the novel, however, was the feeling between the black servants and some of the white families they served, particularly with the children.  There was affection in some cases amidst the degradations and I never imagined it to be like that.  That said, this is fiction and none of these women have spoken up in real life (to my knowledge) so maybe it wasn’t so, but it still made the book immensely powerful emotionally.  It astounds me that all this was happening just 50-60 years ago.

This read comes highly recommended from me.  The Help is a wonderful, well-paced, stunning novel from a new writer that I suspect will go far, and a brilliant beginning for a new literary imprint.

Buy The Help on Amazon.

Share

TSS: Well, that was an event!

For those of you who weren’t on Twitter yesterday and noticed that my blog brought up an error screen, we had an incident with our host and it seems that the site was hacked and reported for phishing.  And it has happened before.  So!  We made a switch to a new host, and after about a day of uncertainty and having my blog completely unavailable intermittently, things have been resolved!  I may have lost some comments if you made them yesterday, so please repost if you can.  And of course I have to thank Keith for fixing everything and engineering and paying for the move.  I’m a lucky girl.  =)

So, here we are with the same URL and the same RSS feed, but I’ve taken this opportunity to make some changes around here.  First of all, I have a shiny new install of wordpress, which you can’t see but trust me, the whole admin part of my site is completely different and I have a lot to play around with.  I didn’t realize how old my last wordpress install was.  I also took this opportunity to change my theme and upload some of my own images.  A few things might be changing over the next few days.  I have to add some blog awards and links to the sidebar mainly, but this is what I have time for now.  If you’re linking to me and I’m not linking to you, please let me know.  I’ll be trying to add my favorite google reader blogs, but I missed so many before and want to avoid that happening again.

While you’re here, refresh a few times.  The header changes!  How cool is that?  I’m thrilled that I can use my own pictures for my header now.

In the midst of my frustration yesterday, I endeavored to avoid the computer and finished two books.  The first was Drood by Dan Simmons, which will be touring here and elsewhere in the book blog world on February 27th.  I don’t want to give too much away, but it’s historical fiction featuring Wilkie Collins and Charles Dickens.  Not much can go wrong there!  Then I was annoyed with my inability to write the reviews I had planned on, so I read Romancing Mister Bridgerton by Julia Quinn.  Not as fantastic as the first three Bridgertons, but a good distraction.  I haven’t had time to start American Rust yet, but that will be for a bit later today, after I get some work out of the way.  I need to come up with some dissertation and essay ideas, which is a bit too much for my little exasperated brain, but I will give it my best shot.

Share

Site Maintenance

Please bear with us while we move the site to a more efficient server. Normal service should be resumed shortly.

The ever-overloaded-with-books fiancé,

Keith

Share

Review: The Ruins of Gorlan, John Flanagan

When the day comes for masters to choose apprentices, Will is nervous.  He wants to go to Battle School and become a warrior like he believes his father was, but he is small and comparatively weak, unlike his friend Horace who is an immediate choice for a future as a knight.  Instead, he is chosen by Ranger Halt.  Will doesn’t know what to expect from his new future as Ranger’s apprentice, but he quickly realizes that it isn’t as easy as he thought.

I have heard a lot about the Ranger’s Apprentice series, so I was excited when I found a box set of the first three.  Seemed like an ideal time to jump in, and I didn’t doubt that I’d like it since so many others had.  Of course, I loved it, and quickly grew to care for Will and Halt and Horace in the space of one short book.  It certainly reads like a YA book with certain lessons that can be gleaned, but is enchanting enough for adults too, as it’s good solid fantasy.  The world is interesting and I want to learn more about it, the characters are endearing, the action and plot are great, and the writing is the perfect tone and level for this type of young adult book.  I can’t wait for number two!

Buy The Ruins of Gorlan on Amazon.

Share

Review: Something Like Beautiful, asha bandele

When in college, asha meets and marries a prisoner in a jail she visits for one of her classes.  She is stunned by how intelligent, compassionate, and loveable Rashid is and believes he regrets his crime.  She also believes that he will get out on his first opportunity, but she doesn’t want to have a baby while he’s in prison.  When she finds herself pregnant for the first time, she has an abortion.  The second time, she can’t bring herself to do so again, and has the baby, convinced that Rashid will be released soon.  She never sees herself as a single mother, until Rashid gets in more trouble that he doesn’t deserve and asha leaves him, unable to continue on with a husband she may not have a future with.  This is the story of asha’s struggle to cope as a single mother and her all-consuming love for her daughter, Risa.

I’m not a mother and my parents are still happily married, but I know single moms have it hard.  Many of the people closest to me have just their mom and it’s always rough even if the father stays involved and pays child support.  Despite that, I felt asha focused just a little too much on herself despite this love for her daughter.  She develops alcoholism and tells her daughter that she needs “mommy time” on a very frequent basis; it’s hard to see how devoted she is when she keeps finding other things to spend her time with.  She also sets a bad example with abusive relationships.  This is all despite a good upbringing, a job, and a college education.  I found significant, though, her candid admission of how difficult it is for a black woman alone and in general the stereotypes that surround her despite what she does to buck them.  Seeing why an intelligent, beautiful woman would stay with an abusive man was a revelation to me; I still think I’d leave, especially if I had a young daughter who might be influenced by my actions.

I guess in the end I couldn’t really relate to this book, perhaps because asha’s experience is so outside of my own and because I don’t believe I’d make the choices she did.  I also found it very depressing.  That said, perhaps it’s important for me to read books like this in order to get a greater picture of the world outside of my own little bubble.  I still don’t think anything could compel me to marry a prisoner, though, and from that perspective it’s very hard to understand asha or feel true sympathy for her despite all that suffering.

Check out Something Like Beautiful: One Single Mother’s Story on Amazon.

Share

BTT: Too Much Information

btt2Have you ever been put off an author’s books after reading a biography of them? Or the reverse – a biography has made you love an author more?

Actually, no to both.  I don’t normally read biographies of authors, for one thing. I suppose I would if I was interested in reading more non-fiction, but at the moment I’m getting plenty of that.  I do find their lives interesting, but in general I’m not a huge fan of history after the 15th century, which is before the development of the novel (and before a comprehensive biography of almost any author could be composed anyway).  So that puts me off right to start.  Secondly, I commented on this at Maw Books Blog a while ago, and I firmly believe we should separate the art from the artist.  Just because an author has horrible beliefs or has done horrible things doesn’t make his/her work bad, and it goes the other way around too, because you can be a fabulous person but incapable of writing valuable works.    I’m sure a number of authors had opinions we’d all be firmly against now because it was commonplace then.  So we’d have to eliminate whole swathes of literature.  Honestly, just think about what Chaucer must have believed; many of us have discovered that the medieval period was a whole different world, but that doesn’t make The Canterbury Tales less valuable.

So, learning that an author has horrible beliefs would definitely put me off the person and I wouldn’t want to meet them, but if they kept that belief out of their work and it was still interesting and entertaining, I would read it.  Normally, I won’t even know, so this is not a big issue for me.  I can’t ever recall a time when I liked an author’s work more for knowing something about them.

Share

Things I Like That Start With ‘Y’

This meme has been going around the blog world for a bit, so I decided to jump in when I saw Alyce’s post at At Home With Books.  Somewhat unluckily for me, her randomizer gave me ‘Y’.  I’m up for a challenge though!  I decided to go for it.  When I got stuck, my programmer husband-to-be used his crazy skills to give me a list of words that started with ‘y’.  It’s like cheating.  Except not because, well, Y is a hard letter and I came up with most of them on my own.  Anyway, on with the list.

  1. Yellow – this one was easy!  Yellow has been my favorite color for as long as I can remember.  I like bright, sunny yellow or pastel yellow, nothing dark or greenish.
  2. York – Well, I’m currently living here, I’m not sure much else needs to be said!  They say this is the best preserved medieval city in England and I love walking through history each and every day.
  3. Yankees – I’d be a little remiss if I didn’t mention my family’s favorite baseball team.  I’m not a fan of baseball myself but if I was I’d be a Yankees fan.
  4. Yorkists – You know which side I’d be on if I was fighting in the Wars of the Roses.  Historians shouldn’t be biased like this, but I’m taking a year off so I’m allowed for now!
  5. Yoda – I love Star Wars.  In recent years I’ve come to realize that the original trilogy consists of my favorite movies of all time; I never get tired of them.  I have a quote from Yoda on my bedroom wall at my parents’ house about how size doesn’t matter.  I always thought it was relevant as I’m a rather tiny 5 feet and slender on top of that.
  6. Yarn -I enjoy crocheting and recently I’ve been thinking about taking up knitting as well.  Looking at the yarn selection and picking just what I’m going to use to make my next project is one of my favorite parts of crafting.
  7. Yogurt – A great healthy snack and even better with fruit mixed in.
  8. Yeast – Okay, this is stretching it, but I love bread and bread products in general and they’re all made with yeast, so I think it works!  Also, I bake and am looking forward to the day I can afford a breadmaker.
  9. Yule – I’m aware this isn’t technically Christmas, but for my purposes it’s close enough!  As much as I hate Christmas music and mushy Christmas stories, I do like the season and picking gifts out for people (as long as I can afford them) and I’ll always remember being an excited child on Christmas morning.
  10. Yeoman warders – I’m getting a little desperate with this last one, but you have to admit the guys and girls at the Tower of London are very cool.  I think it would be pretty cool to be one, but I wouldn’t like to stay in the Tower of London overnight.  I don’t think I’d fancy meeting headless Anne Boleyn at 2 am, but maybe that’s just me!

Well, there’s my 10.  Whew!  I’m just glad I didn’t get x.  Even my fiance’s super word finding tool doesn’t have much there.  I thought about cheating a little and using Yorkshire, given that it’s gorgeous and historic on its own, but I decided to try a little harder than words that just start with “York”.

If you want to play along, leave me a comment and I’ll give you a letter!

Share

Review: The Tales of Beedle the Bard, J.K. Rowling

In the seventh Harry Potter book, Hermione receives this book and one of the fairy tales serves as an essential plot point in it.  So, what better idea than to write out all the fairy tales and sell them, too?  Clearly, good idea.  Each of these fairy tales is different and has its own little objective.  There are five of them and at the end, Dumbledore comments on each, with some footnotes added by Hermione Granger.  I won’t go into what each of them are, because I think we’ve seen a lot of reviews and it’s actually been a while since I read the book.  I did want to put out a short review, though, just because I like to review everything I read.

My favorite story was the one featured in the actual Harry Potter books, incidentally.  I liked the message about cheating death, and I liked that it reminded me of the Harry Potter series.  Otherwise, I found these to be short, whimsical reads that fit in reasonably well with the universe but don’t really add all that much to it.  Nice for completionists, and nice that a donation is made, but otherwise, nothing special, and not at all compared to the series itself.

Buy The Tales of Beedle the Bard on Amazon.

Share