November 2026
S M T W T F S
« Mar    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

Never Let Me Go, Kazuo Ishiguro

I hesitate to write much in this review, as this story unveils itself slowly and to some effect.  I will eliminate any plot summary and simply get to what I felt about the book.

I was disappointed.  I felt it was building up to a big revelation that I saw coming while the characters didn’t, and while the resolution did resonate with me, there was still an element of detachment.  Perhaps this is significant regarding the subject matter, as detachment is obvious, but it prevented me from feeling connected to the characters or caring much about their situation, even when their situation was one I should have cared about deeply.  I think this book is more a tale of “look what could happen” rather than “feel how horrible this could be”.  I’d be interested to discuss it, but I’m disappointed, having hoped for something similar to The Remains of the Day – my favorite book of 2007.

Share

Passion: a novel of the Romantic poets, Jude Morgan

This historical fiction novel focuses on the women who loved Shelley, Byron, and Keats, and how these three poets had a profound effect on their lives and loves.

It was certainly interesting. I knew little about these poets’ lives and I feel somewhat enlightened, at least as much as I can verify as truth, and I think Morgan managed to capture the attitude of the time very well and the inspiration for these poets’ greatest works. Some of the women were sympathetic characters, especially Mary and Fanny, but the novel spent far too much time on Caroline Lamb, who was the least interesting and had the least influence on any of the poets. I felt sorry for her in a strange sort of way, but during her parts it felt as though the plot wasn’t moving and I was far more interested in getting back to the other women. Fanny disappears for about 200 pages, which is a shame because I liked her.

Except for the fact that the plot is loose and doesn’t move much, it’s a good book. There is certainly a plot there, but the tension is occasionally ruined by a focus on other, less interesting characters. I understand that real life is not like a novel, but a novelist should structure the work to keep the reader interested, not focus on characters whose importance to the book faded halfway through.

I liked the variety of prose styles; occasionally Morgan tosses in a first person perspective or a play, which seems like it could be too clever but worked well. I liked her writing in general and I liked some of the characters. Another good historical fiction, but not great.

Share

Revenge of the Rose, Nicole Galland

I really liked this book! I enjoyed Galland’s last effort, The Fool’s Tale, but this one definitely improves on it. The story begins with Willem and Lienor of Dole, brother and sister whose friend, the minstrel Jouglet, has great plans for them, involving a trip for Willem to the emperor to become a knight. The tale is very loosely based on the medieval poem “The Romance of the Rose”, and I mean loosely – the author admits herself that she changed and embellished freely. She also lays no claim to historical accuracy, so I will not be commenting on that here. Any author who excuses him or herself in order to prevent readers from claiming the book’s fiction as truth has gained my appreciation.

The book was amazingly well plotted. I couldn’t imagine all the twists and turns the author had going. I struggled with guessing what was going to happen and worried over the characters’ fates, particularly towards the end. I could hardly believe how clever it was. In addition, the wit is perfectly suited to the tradition of medieval courtly love, while subtly showing us what may have gone on behind the scenes. I laughed often. I think Galland did a wonderful job of getting across the teasing nature of such interchanges; we now can hardly imagine that this devotion would be false, but she shows that it wasn’t necessarily the case.

Jouglet was a great character and worked very well as a center for the novel. The rest of the characters almost felt like supporting cast to Jouglet, but I liked almost all of them, and Galland includes one character with an extreme moral dilemma. Watching him shows off her talent for getting so close to reality and human emotion.

Also, the ending was amazing. It made me very happy.

Something else I enjoyed about this book was how different it was from The Fool’s Tale; even its tone was different and I’d hardly have been able to tell that it was written by the same woman. I think Galland is a talent to watch for. I’ll certainly be buying her next book. Honesty, compelling characters, and brilliant writing – I couldn’t ask for that much more. It’s probably not accurate middle ages, but as I’m not expecting that, I’m very happy to recommend this as great historical fiction.

Share

Luck in the Shadows, Lynn Flewelling

I don’t think that I’m ever going to say that this author is my favorite of all time, but she does write solid, interesting fantasy. Luck in the Shadows is about a boy, Alec, who is unexpectedly rescued by a slightly older man, Seregil, who goes on to change Alec’s life completely.

There isn’t much to review here. I don’t have anything negative to say, exactly. The book managed to hold my attention throughout and I was interested in what was happening. The ending is somewhat resolved and somewhat of a cliffhanger, which I think is always the best ending for a first book in a series, because it leaves me wanting more without torturing me. Still, there was something missing – maybe because I didn’t particularly care for either Alec or Seregil, and characterization is one of my favorite points. I think I’d rate this book to be decent, but not great. I will be reading the next two in the series though.

Share

The First Princess of Wales, Karen Harper

I think that this was largely a mediocre book, to start off with, mostly due to the fact that it was a romance novel in unlikely historical trappings.
Ostensibly, this novel is about Joan, the “Fair Maid of Kent”, who we all know from the history and the title of the novel is going to marry Edward the Black Prince (of Wales). I was hoping for a more detailed fictional take on her life. Instead, I got a romance novel. I did expect some romance, because it is obviously about how she and Edward fall in love in part, but Joan’s life had a lot going on otherwise and I felt that was de-emphasized in favor of the fact that she is constantly pining for Edward.

Okay, historical inaccuracies: namely, neither Joan nor Edward were known by their nicknames during their lifetime, and anyone who has done any research will notice that there is no contemporary record of their names. Moreover, the chronology of Joan’s life is inaccurate. Some unlikely elements were added in favor of the plot, but it’s mostly the blatant inaccuracies, which are so frequently used.

Secondly, this is basically a romance novel. When Joan’s life doesn’t have much to do with Edward, it is skipped over, except when one particular exciting event happens. And (spoilers here) the novel ends with the marriage of Joan and Edward. What about afterwards? I would have been far more interested to learn how Joan thought while Edward was off winning victories and how she acted with her children and what happened after Edward died. I thought the novel would be more of a fictionalized biography, because that’s how it comes off by reading the back. It isn’t, it’s just a romance novel.

In the end, I would call this mediocre, and probably recommend it to someone who reads romance novels, not historical fiction. It doesn’t do badly as a romance, but it pretends to be something that it isn’t.

Share

Kushiel’s Scion, Jacqueline Carey

I’ve been looking forward to this book for a long time. I love the original Kushiel trilogy, and reread it in preparation for beginning this second trilogy (which is not yet completed, with two books published). When I came to this book, I have to admit that it disappointed me.

For one thing, I just don’t love Imriel as much as I love Phedre. This book is indeed a coming of age tale, and I really enjoy the developments in Imriel’s character, but I don’t like him nearly as much or find his story nearly as interesting. I think the fact that he grew up so much meant that less happened, plot-wise, although certainly things do happen, especially in the second half. More of the book was spent discovering himself, rather than discovering any part of the world, which normally I enjoy but I didn’t as much here, perhaps because there isn’t a sense of destiny about Imriel. He is in control, whereas things happened to Phedre and she dealt with them as she could. I suppose that is just my taste and doesn’t necessarily reflect as much on the book – just that it is definitely different.

I would also have loved to hear more about Melisande, rather than the tantalizing hints that we are given.

Otherwise, Carey’s style and prose are up to par. There’s nothing wrong with the plot, but the book is very long for the events within it. Overall, she just needs to convince me that I should care about Imriel!

Share

The Thirteenth Tale, Diane Setterfield

Margaret Lea has little interest in living people, so when Vida Winter contacts her requesting her to write the famous author’s biography, she is perplexed. Luckily for her, and us, she goes to meet Ms. Winter, and before her unfolds a story that draws her in and consumes her every waking moment.

There are several really great things about this book. The first is its plot. I for one did not guess at all what was to happen, unless Margaret made a guess at it. There were several points where I was completely surprised at the turn of events. I was also very absorbed into the story, though it was layers deep. It is very compelling. The book is well-written and perfect for book lovers like me. Setterfield weaves in many 19th century classics, as apparently they are both Margaret’s and Ms. Winter’s favorites (as they are mine).

I have to admit that as much as I was interesting in the story Vida Winter was telling, and the plot relating to Aurelius, Margaret herself did not interest me. I can’t admit to understanding what she went through, but at times I did feel like she was far too melodramatic about everything. I suppose it was appropriate to the tone of the novel, but I wished she’d stop complaining so we could get back to the main mystery. This minor qualm is really my only problem with it, and perhaps someone who was more like Margaret or had a similar experience would feel that her behavior was perfectly appropriate – I can’t judge, but I personally was impatient with her character.

I’d recommend this, especially to someone who loves books or mysteries.

Share

The Birth of Venus, Sarah Dunant

The Birth of Venus is about a young girl, Alessandra, in Renaissance Florence that is quickly spiraling out of control. She is a bit ahead of her time, as this novel is definitely done from a feminist perspective, but I liked her spirit and her curiosity and her relentlessness. The novel grabs you quickly with a suspenseful and then leaves you wondering how the prologue happened for most of the text. Luckily, there are answers to that, and other questions as well.

I enjoyed the book quite a bit. The setting was well-drawn and I felt very true to the Renaissance. Alessandra was a sympathetic character. Also, this is somewhat strange to comment on, but for a novel that involves romance, it wasn’t stereotypical at all. It is to me fairly original in its plot, which I always appreciate. I enjoyed the author’s prose style, especially in comparison to the last book I read, because I felt that I could get close to the characters and understand them, particularly Alessandra, and at times the density of her emotion struck me, too.

I did find the book historically improbable, but for once I don’t think this detracted from it. I wasn’t terribly surprised by one particular aspect of the ending, although to be honest I can’t remember why I guessed it, but I didn’t see some of the other events coming. Overall, I think it passes in the history department, as it doesn’t commit any blatant inaccuracies, only might-have-beens.

All in all, The Birth of Venus is an immersing historical experience that I would certainly recommend to someone else.

Share

Abundance: a novel of Marie Antoinette, Sena Jeter Naslund

Abundance is the tale of Marie Antoinette, France’s doomed queen, slandered by many, but lately attempts to rescue her reputation have been made. Abundance is not an exception, portrayed Marie Antoinette as a naive girl, even when she is a woman, determined to do her duty but ultimately failing to understand what the populace needs from her.

It’s a challenge to get into this book. Marie Antoinette’s narration is strange and distant, which means it takes a good few pages to get used to and feel that you like her. She is her own impediment to reader’s affection, given that she is so distant from the real world throughout the novel. I don’t know that this is a fault of the novel, but she expresses her care for the people and how she does not wish to live extravagantly when she is surrounded by opulence. She’s almost too naive to care about, until the end.

The prose is well done other than this odd distant feel, and the other characters are portrayed fairly reasonably. I just find the entire situation hard to believe; luckily, I have Marie Antoinette: The Journey, on which this book was based, waiting to be read, so that I will be better able to justify the novel’s historical judgment. The plot moves along quickly, skipping years where nothing much happened, focusing only on the events. It is interesting to see the French Revolution from the perspective of the royal family, as I feel we are more typically given the history from the revolutionaries’ view.

In short, I found Marie Antoinette too saintly to be real, though I doubt she committed all the crimes that the populace claimed, but I did find the other characters and the relationships in the novel to be genuine. I would say that Abundance is a fairly typical historical fiction, not bad but not great either.

Share

Kushiel’s Avatar, Jacqueline Carey

This book is a terrific end to an amazing trilogy. Now that most character relations have been established, Carey can really play with their relationships and make us feel for them even more than we could before. Except for a very uncomfortable section of the story, the necessity of which is obvious but still disturbs me, the novel is well plotted and engaging, moving quickly. Even though this was my second read-through, I was still surprised by certain things and had forgotten a great deal of the plot in four years.

I think most of all I love the relationship between Phedre and Joscelin. I wouldn’t go so far as to say it feels real, because I don’t think real people could endure what they do, but that’s part of what makes it amazing and touching. Their strength is unrealistic, but also admirable and makes us care for them even more. Watching them with another person in their family dynamic is interesting and does make them more human despite their many super-human qualities. I think their relationship is, to be honest, one of Carey’s triumphs. But then, I love the first Kushiel’s Legacy trilogy, and this book is probably just as good as the first – it dips a bit in the middle, slowing down, but overall, it’s all amazing, and I’d recommend these books to almost anyone, not just those who read fantasy. They are long, but in return they have almost every quality of an amazing, epic tale.

Share