Boy Novak is the daughter of an abusive rat catcher, a man she longs to escape. One day, finally, she goes; she gets on a bus and finds herself somewhere new. In her new home, Boy meets a few friends and Arturo Whitman, father of a beautiful little girl called Snow. Boy and Arturo marry and only when Boy gives birth to her own daughter, Bird, does she discover that Arturo’s family has a secret – one that has a great deal of resonance in 1950’s America.
This book is somewhat obviously modeled on Snow White, but twists and turns that fairy tale to become almost entirely different, with the evil stepmother actively trying her best not to be an evil stepmother. It struck me as a novel primarily about how people appear and how a little change can make a lot of difference. There are several characters in this book whose appearances don’t match the way their “true” selves would be perceived in society, which is both good and bad for them. It’s about prejudice and how we apply it based on something so shallow which actually resonates a lot with current events. And that’s all I’ll say about that, to avoid overtly spoiling a crucial plot point.
Though it’s a twisty book with a lot of surprises and a mystical feel, I actually didn’t enjoy Boy, Snow, Bird very much. I often struggle with books where I don’t connect to or empathise with any of the characters and this was the case here. The three title women are the only characters who are fleshed out to any degree, with the rat catcher, Arturo, Boy’s first love, and Arturo’s family mostly glossed over. The letters between Bird and Snow towards the second half of the book were easily my favorite part; two sisters getting to know each other again, understanding how they are alike and how they are different. But overall I just found myself feeling sort of underwhelmed. I felt like I’d seen a lot of other bloggers heap praise on Oyeyemi’s works and I just felt cold towards this, never really involved or that interested in what was happening to the characters or why. It’s been a few days since I finished it and I already feel like it’s left my consciousness, rather than causing me to dwell on some of the powerful messages it contained.
I’d be very interested to know if any of you would recommend any other Oyeyemi works to try, but in the meantime I probably wouldn’t recommend this one.
All external book links are affiliate links. I received this book for free for review.
I love the premise of this book so I’m disappointed it didn’t really work for you.
BermudaOnion(Kathy)´s last post …Review: A Good Marriage
For me, what works so well about Oyeyemi’s work is her writing: She inevitably says at least one thing, and usually she says dozens, that resonate with me utterly. If you didn’t like it in this book, she may not be the writer for you. But if it matters, my favorite of her books is her third, White Is for Witching. It’s spooky and wonderful.
Jenny @ Reading the End´s last post …Review: Station Eleven, Emily St. John Mandel
I plan to read this after having read many positive reviews, but I’m glad for your mixed one. I’ll definitely keep what you’ve said about characterisation in mind.
Like Kathy, I like the premise of the book, but for some reason I haven’t been drawn to read it.
Beth F´s last post …Weekend Cooking: Pumpkin Pie
This sounds like an intriguing premise to me, too, but I know what you mean about feeling underwhelmed with a book that sounded like it would be really good. So disappointing.
Belle Wong´s last post …Adventures in Kefir-Making