November 2026
S M T W T F S
« Mar    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

Duchess: a novel of Sarah Churchill, Susan Holloway Scott

Duchess covers much of the life of Sarah Churchill, Duchess of Marlborough. The book chronicles her friendship and influence with Anne Stuart from childhood to middle age, her relationship with her husband, and eventually their fall from grace.

Miss Sarah Jennings, thirteen, has very little money to her name thanks to her father’s gambling debts. She accepts a position in the Duchess of York’s household in order to earn money and get away from her mother. Through this position she meets Princess Anne and John Churchill, the two figures who are to have massive influence on the rest of her life.

I enjoyed that this book stayed extremely close to the actual recorded history. Wherever there is history, Ms. Scott does not mess with it and instead keeps to the books. Sarah’s life is well documented, so any errors would be blatantly obvious. She does an excellent job of portraying Sarah’s stubborn character. She is ambitious and she has plenty of flaws; she’s really out for no one but herself and her family, and in that she’s matched well by her husband. The fact that they rose from very minor players at court to have such great influence is astounding, and Scott shows this ambition and drive. I’m very satisfied by her Sarah Churchill, as I think she matches excellently the woman I’ve read about in various other sources.

I did think the idea that Sarah and Princess Anne were physically intimate a bit strange. I’d not seen that suggestion elsewhere, and considering the book mentions how hard it is to keep secrets in court, it doesn’t seem to fit. I am able to accept the theory though, since no one can ever know what happened between them when they were alone. It just seems off. It is true that they were very close, I just am not entirely comfortable with the idea that it led to sexual activity.

Overall I suspect Queen Anne may have suffered a bit, but I don’t really know much about her reign so I can’t comment. If anything, she was certainly very dependent on Sarah and later on Abigail Masham, as well as all her advisors, so perhaps this image of her is not entirely unfair.

The writing is good, no cultural errors or colloqualisms, everything is in line. It is fairly obvious at times that the author is a romance novelist, considering how she writes the romance between Sarah and John. Not that I mind much, considering their love was a huge part of Sarah’s life, and a romance novelist is well qualified to cover that. I think it’s a great achievement for Scott (also known as Miranda Jarrett) to step out of her genre and try this, and she does an excellent job. Sarah’s resistance to John’s wooing is expertly done.

The real Sarah Churchill was a phenomenal woman, seizing power for herself and her family in a time when no woman besides a sole reigning queen ever had any. I’m glad that she has a good fiction novel based on her life so she can become more accessible to the world at large.

Share

Josephine, A Life of the Empress, Carolly Erickson

This biography is probably among the worst that I have read. It reads like a novel, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but in this case, it fails to provide a convincing portrait of Josephine.

Carolly Erickson covers Josephine’s life from the great storm of her childhood in Martinique to her death. At times, her portrayal of Josephine as sweet, generous, grateful, and natural is at odds with the calculating promiscuous woman she also attempts to show. She doesn’t debate either view, but instead attempts to combine them and it comes out a bit strange. The book reads like a tabloid at times, not using Josephine’s own words but those of her observers. Josephine’s letters are occasionally used, but not often enough, especially when Erickson boldly states what Josephine was thinking or how she felt. As ostensibly history, I feel that a biography should state where these impressions are coming from, or if they’re the biographer’s imagining, since they are not fact. The sources are largely in French, which does make sense, but prevents me from researching further in order to discover the truth.

I found I didn’t like Erickson’s Josephine; despite protestations of strength she comes across as weak-willed, jealous, and whiny. That may well be how she was, but overall I didn’t like her much. I preferred Sandra Gulland’s Josephine, since while her trilogy is historical fiction, it uses more source material and provides a view of a Josephine harassed in every way but still true to herself, jealous but attempting to deal with her husband’s infidelity. That isn’t necessarily the truth either, but I preferred it. Also of note is the fact that Gulland maintains that Josephine never had the numerous affairs that Erickson ascribes to her. The evidence for these affairs is in fact scanty, and until more is found we’ll probably never know whether or not Josephine was loyal to Napoleon.

In addition, this book is only 350 pages long and doesn’t delve into any of the issues of the time, merely grazes over them in an attempt for a summary.

I think I will seek out a more scholarly account of Josephine since I don’t trust this one. I prefer a biography to be written more as a history, dealing with conflicting viewpoints and attempting to discern the truth, rather than a popular account that reads like a novel and challenges nothing. Very disappointing.

Share

The Bristling Wood, Katharine Kerr

This is the third book in the Deverry series, which I believe has 11 or 12 books now. In short, not precisely a series to get involved with if you aren’t prepared for the long haul. As a big fan of Robert Jordan etc., it never bothers me when a series is long. It does bother me when the series seems to deteriorate in quality, because at that point I’m invested in the story and feel a need for completion, but don’t feel a desire to read the book.

Rhodry and Jill, my favorite characters, spend most of the book apart. Perryn drives me mad, and overall the story progresses but in a frustrating, bleak way. Nothing is going in a positive direction. There are no light moments, nothing to break the tension, something I’m getting increasingly tired of. There should be a balance to prevent a book from being too depressing, if you ask me, particularly if it’s fantasy, a genre (imo) not meant to be thoroughly depressing. Even the time interlude, a constant staple of the last two books, drifted off without any conclusion. The entire book was nothing but a relentless narrative with no cheer; everyone is always leaving everyone else, being frustrated, and going off to war.

To be honest, I’ve liked other negative books, but usually they’ll have some other quality to recommend them, such as excellent writing or compelling characters. I believed this series had potential in the first book, which I unexpectedly loved. The second was not as good, but still okay. This one was not. The writing was conventional and bland and the characters used the same absurd curses every few pages. The story has some potential, I have to say. It is interesting, but it’s mired down in bad writing and poor plotting. It is as though Katharine Kerr’s editor really went through the first book and made it excellent, and by now has simply given up and let her continue without any assistance.

At this point I’m not sure it’s worth it to continue with the series. I don’t like the cliffhanger, but I also don’t want to read 400 more pages of poor writing, plus however many volumes are left in the entire series.

Share

Kushiel’s Dart, Jacqueline Carey

I have to start off by saying that I adore this book. It is one of my all-time favorite books, and reading it again has only confirmed its status in my mind.

Phedre no Delauney (accents are included in her name, but I’m not sure how to write them here) is the only anguissette in living memory, doomed to experience pleasure and pain as one, marked by the god, Kushiel, with a dart in one of her eyes. Her world is a complex one, where everyone is playing a high-stakes political game. She is raised in the Night Court, where all Naamah’s servants – courtesans – are trained, but later learns how to use her patrons to the utmost from Anafiel Delauney, who owns her marque. There is also a great deal of adventure, war, love, and sex throughout this amazing long novel.

Phedre is a phenomenal character; a whore with a heart full of love, ready to give at any opportunity. She sacrifices, and sacrifices again. I have to say, though, that Joscelin has always stolen the show for me. The conflicts inside him and the way he develops are fascinating, and I love the end result. I could easily fall in love with almost all of Carey’s characters, but it isn’t as though they are perfect. They all have flaws, and they all feel real, which makes me love them even more. Except for Melisande, who I despise, with good reason, but at the same time, she is admirably intelligent. Read the book, and you can see what I mean.

That’s not to mention the complex, sweeping plot that encompasses the novel. It’s a bit slow in the beginning, while Phedre is learning and explaining much of her backstory, but once it picks up, it doesn’t stop, and draws the reader in. There isn’t anything I can say that isn’t spoiler-filled, and I would hate to spoil this book for anyone. It is over 900 pages long, but I wouldn’t cut out one word, especially because Carey’s prose is stunning and a sincere pleasure to read. I love the way this woman writes.

One warning, though. This book includes graphic, sexual scenes, often including violence. That said, it isn’t as though the encounters are described in excessive detail, and they are far from the center of the book, though important information is learned through them. If that puts you off at all, you should probably stay away.

This book is the first in a trilogy, and the next two are just as excellent as this one. I would recommend this to anyone and everyone who enjoys a deep, compelling, emotional read.

Share

Persuasion, Jane Austen

Surprisingly, I don’t have much to say about Persuasion. I liked it, but it didn’t bring out any deep feelings of any kind. It’s about Anne Elliot and her love for Captain Frederick Wentworth; they were engaged, but the engagement was broken on the advice of Anne’s mentor, Lady Russell. Some eight years later, Captain Wentworth returns and Anne finds that her feelings really haven’t changed much … and so it goes.

I was still somewhat entertained by Austen’s satire of the gentry, particularly Anne’s horrendous family. Her father and sisters are incredibly vain, and as such are obvious caricatures. I think what’s lacking here is the banter between the hero and heroine. I recall few affectionate exchanges between them, and those that were didn’t have the same sort of wit found in P&P, though it is elsewhere in the novel.

I did, however, really enjoy the look into Anne’s head. She is a wonderful character, with so many feelings, and very good-hearted. She was excellent. When the characters professed their feelings, I really enjoyed it, but for the most part I just found this a pleasant book to read, not brilliant.

Share

Richard the Third, Paul Murray Kendall

Paul Murray Kendall, the author of this biography of Richard III, one of the most controversial English kings, carefully and painstakingly constructs Richard’s life and times through contemporary fifteenth-century sources, resolutely attempting to thrust away the “Tudor tradition” once and for all.

Necessarily, it takes a long while to get through a volume so heavy with facts and references, especially considering Kendall backs up nearly all of his points with lengthy endnotes. These are welcome and flesh out every aspect of Kendall’s thought processes as he attempts to show us the man who has been so maligned. What emerges is a picture of an honest, well-intentioned man, perhaps too eager to seize a throne, let down by nearly all of his contemporaries. As Duke of Gloucester, Richard won the allegiance of the North, a task which no one had yet managed since William the Conqueror, if not before. He stood by his brother and his brother’s children, for the most part. As King, Richard forgave many of his enemies, bestowed annuities on helpless people, and passed laws entirely for the betterment of society. He did not ask Parliament for a tax despite facing two rebellions, and in general focused largely on increasing the well-being of the poor. He even compares Richard to Henry VII, and Henry comes out the worse for it.

The matter of the Princes in the Tower also comes into play, as do Richard’s motives for dethroning his nephew Edward V. In each case, Kendall addresses the matter logically and with plenty of evidence from the sources he has consulted. Richard comes out of all this possibly guilty, but understandably so, especially in the latter case. Kendall doesn’t believe that Richard killed the princes, and neither do I, though my opinion has been formed for some time now.

Kendall’s writing is at times overly flowery and it’s fairly obvious that this book is over fifty years old. That doesn’t negate its virtues, but it does make for occasionally slow reading, especially compared to current popular biographies. This is very easy to read compared to the original sources, of course. One must also keep in mind that other evidence has been discovered in the years since Kendall’s biography; nevertheless this one remains a cornerstone in the case for Richard III and should be read as such.

I particularly enjoyed the excerpts from Richard’s letters displaying characteristics of his that Kendall wanted to show. I’ve read several medieval biographies at this point and the glimpse into the subjects’ minds is fascinating. Richard’s mind is no less, and it is in these letters that we can feel closest to the king who was betrayed by so many people and even by his own generous policies.

With this biography, Kendall tries, and succeeds, at building a picture of Richard III that is not marred by Tudor legend, a picture of a man and not a monster. He goes through each source and attempts to extract what is true and what is false. I can’t say if he has the whole truth, because I don’t think anyone ever will, but he does a remarkably convincing job.

Share

Black Powder War, Naomi Novik

Temeraire and his crew finally leave China, on an unexpected mission to take three much-desired dragon eggs back to Britain. Along the way, they face starvation, feral dragons, deaths, and Napoleon Bonaparte’s legendary army.

Again, Novik seems to struggle with an escalating plot. Battles happen and at first glance the book may seem action-packed and fast-paced, but the problem is, the reader is never quite sure where the plot is going. It does not begin to build to a conclusion until Temeraire gets involved in the war once again, and I think that’s where the failing in these books lie. There is action, but the book does not compel the reader to discover what happens next – it simply plods along. We’re aware of the mission, but I at least am not driven to discover what happens next. There are few moments of humor to break the tense nature of a war narrative; the reader grows fond of Temeraire, Laurence, Granby, and so on, but the book lacks any sort of human figure that is not either strait-laced and honorable or consumed with vengeance and evil. There is one ambiguous character, but he quickly resolved into one of these two categories.

As for the dragons, I have been hoping that they would seem less like children and more like the intelligent beings they supposedly are. For all Temeraire’s intelligence, he is surprisingly naive about the world, despite Laurence’s frequent attempts to teach him. He reacts like a child in many ways, and though he is a young dragon, the more experienced dragons have never seemed any more mature, except for several of the Chinese dragons. With this in mind, I find Temeraire’s ideas for the betterment of dragon-kind almost silly. Undoubtedly they are not treated as well as they could be, but Novik does not portray them on the same level as her human characters, and how could dragons be truly independent if they are so reliant on their captains anyway? Think of Levitas, who remained loyal to Rankin until the end, despite Rankin’s poor treatment of him; he’d never have gone away from his captain even if he could. It is, apparently, against dragon nature, so how could they be as independent as Temeraire wishes? Naturally, the British society Novik portrays could do with a great deal of improvement, but I find that she tells a lot more about the dragons’ intelligence than she shows. Doesn’t happen in this book.

As with the others, I find this a cozy read; it feels comforting, what with the relationships between dragons and captains and between the humans. Virtually everyone is friendly, as long as they are on Laurence’s side. As a contrast to this, the book is depressing, as even the one “victory” our heroes can claim is marred with grief. There are barely any light moments, which makes the stolid narrative hard to bear. Perhaps this is the way war goes, but it isn’t quite the way to write an enthralling fantasy novel. It also ends on a cliffhanger with basically only negative resolution to the little plot Novik has going. I think these stories have great potential, but they could use some improving; more comic relief, more character development, steadier plot. Perhaps we’ll see that in Empire of Ivory. I’m sure it doesn’t help that I’m not fascinated by military history, but I’ve read plenty of books with battles in them, and this one just doesn’t dwell on the personalities involved to make me really feel the risks.

Share

Middlesex, Jeffrey Eugenides

This review includes spoilers, but does not really do more than state the obvious.

This book begins with the rather startling fact that the narrator, Cal, also known as Calliope, is a hermaphrodite, raised as a girl, and discovers that he is really a boy in his teenage years. It then goes on to trace two generations of Cal’s Greek family in order to trace the gene which made him the way he is, and how his family dealt with it.

I really liked this book. I loved the multi-generational aspect, seeing family traits come down, getting really involved with the characters. Most of the characters were very multi-faceted and believable, except perhaps Desdemona, who seems to me a rather stereotypical Greek woman. I liked how they reflected the times as the years passed. I really liked the combination of omniscient and third-person narration; Cal knows and tells all, but in such a way that when he’s not talking about his own life, he doesn’t really get in the way and lets the tale tell itself. I found it strange how omniscient he is; very unrealistic, but I allowed him to know everything and just accepted it.

Middlesex is fundamentally about being different, about awkwardness, and about being a teenager and wanting to be the same. Calliope/Cal struggles to fit in, wishes desperately that she could, and then decides not to. She becomes he and the ending is magnificent in the he finds peace and accepts who he is. Gender identity is the prevailing theme, but I think this goes much deeper, an extreme case of a teenager longing to be normal. Jeffrey Eugenides provides a perspective that will resonate with all readers who can remember that longing, wrapped in a riveting, enjoyable story of a Greek family caught between their home country and their adopted one.

Share

Child of the Prophecy, Juliet Marillier

This book is the last in the Sevenwaters trilogy and features an entirely different sort of heroine than the first two did. Both Sorcha and Liadan were quiet, efficient, almost ethereal, healers, with extraordinary resolve and capabilities. In contrast, this book’s heroine is Fainne, a sorceress who has yet to develop such strengths, and spends much of the book confused and conflicted. In another change, this book does not revolve around romance, but around friendship and family instead. The romance is there, but very subdued and with no positive moments. It is Fainne’s love for her father and for her new family which inspires her, as well as her potential romantic partner, who is for the most part her friend.

In this book, the focus is on completing the prophecy largely introduced in Son of the Shadows. Fainne is an essential part of the story, as it is in her power to maintain or destroy the child of the prophecy, Johnny. She is watched at every moment to make sure that she does not fail in her task.

As a result, this book is depressing, with no light moments from beginning to end. Fainne is constantly struggling due to various circumstances around her, but worst of all, it’s hard to care for her. She is strong, but she does commit some horrible crimes, without receiving much blame for them. She pushes away those she loves, frustrating the reader because she never gets a break and never lets anyone in.

The entire trilogy is very well-written, but I think this is actually the weakest link. The fairy tale sense is completely gone, as is the feel of destiny; even though everything is still governed by the prophecy, it can be changed by human interaction. Perhaps this is because Fainne herself is a sorceress and thus has more control over these things. Moreover, there is even less sense of a right, true love in the romance department; Sorcha and Red felt destined to be together, and Liadan and Bran were similarly fated. Fainne’s love is less constant and much less moving, even though she denies it every step of the way. It is easy to see where it has come from, but it just didn’t touch me.

What I did like is the surprise at the end, which ensures that the book’s conclusion is not one that the reader is looking for. It was a welcome plot twist and I didn’t see it coming, which I always appreciate.

Overall, Daughter of the Forest is by far the best in Juliet Marillier’s Sevenwaters trilogy. This book is also a decent read, if only to finish the story, but do not expect it, or the one before it, to match the wonderful, fairy-tale feel of the first.

Share

Son of the Shadows, Juliet Marillier

Son of the Shadows focuses on Liadan, the daughter of Sorcha (the heroine of Daughter of the Forest), and her life and love as she struggles to reconcile her feelings for a man who is viewed as an enemy by everyone she holds dear. It reveals more of the overarching plot of the trilogy, but doesn’t have the same magical, heart-wrenching quality as Daughter of the Forest. It seems more a love story than a fairy tale, maybe because Liadan is not destined for Bran, while Sorcha and Red were obviously meant to be together. I did like, though, that it was obvious why everyone liked Liadan. Juliet Marillier does an excellent job of showing and not telling when it comes to her characters, and even backs up her description of enchanting Niamh with her behavior. I really enjoyed the return of many of the characters from Daughter of the Forest and their continuing roles in this tale. Marillier’s writing is also excellent and extremely absorbing.

For some reason, though, I just didn’t feel as moved in this story as I did in the first, but perhaps the last, Child of the Prophecy, will return to that fairy tale, surreal quality.

Share