|
|
I think, this being a novel by Jane Austen, I wanted to like this book more than I actually did. I definitely found it entertaining and recognized the many ways in which Jane Austen poked fun at the gothic novel. It was very amusing watching Catherine expect horrible things to happen to her, only for her to be humiliated by her suppositions.
Plot-wise, the novel is very weak. I don’t believe the plot is the point of the book, but it is a very simple “love” story which really displays a pitifully small amount of the developing affection compared to other Austen novels. The satire of the Gothic novel, and the warning to readers to remain aware that they are not living in a novel, is prevalent. The characters are similarly weak, two of them being mean-spirited and greedy, while the main characters are simple and have no defining characteristics, except perhaps ignorance on Catherine’s part. They are also very clearly not the point, except perhaps to convince the reader to choose friends carefully. In the end, Austen even uses a deus ex machina to wrap up the story and provide a favorable resolution, definitely showing her disregard for the plot of this novel.
In the end, all it really has in its favor is the amusement factor as the reader watches Catherine’s suspicions build and deflate repeatedly. It is great in that, but basically fails in everything else. I’m hoping that Persuasion, the next novel by Austen that I plan to read, surpasses Northanger Abbey.
Satisfying conclusion to an absorbing and enjoyable trilogy. Everything wraps up, except for one small detail which Ms. Flewelling says we can learn more about in Luck in the Shadows. Excellent, I already own that book, and I love it when authors tie all of their works together in small minor ways. Not big ones that require me to read every book they have ever read, but small ones that add recognition to otherwise fresh stories.
I didn’t really enjoy the polarization of good and evil, though.
*spoilers*
Tamir (formerly Tobin) and Ki and all those on her side become visibly blessed by the gods and don’t really struggle all that much in the quest. The evil side is a little less defined; Niryn has been obviously vile from the beginning, and if anything this book confirms his ridiculous and unsympathetic ambition. We are given a glimpse into his childhood and can see why he wants to rise in power, but not really why that makes him so evil, although I expect the wizard who took him over may have had something to do with it.
Tamir becomes comfortable with her gender here and her doubts evaporate. She is never uncertain, like she was before. At times, she doesn’t even feel like Tobin, and I think the author may have lost the link between them. It also seems that the characters swear and make obscene gestures far more often here than ever before, which may be because they are growing older, but doesn’t fit with who they were before.
This is a trilogy where the side to root for is obvious, and everything is laid out before the reader. It’s engrossing and it’s easy to care for Tamir and all of her friends, particularly Ki. The ending is satisfying, if a bit too predictable. I would definitely reread these books.
Unlike most middle books of trilogies, Hidden Warrior keeps up the pace of The Bone Doll’s Twin and ensures reader interest throughout. Even though the reader knows throughout that Tobin is going to return to his female form eventually, it’s still a surprise when he does, and tension is present throughout the entire book.
While reading, I couldn’t find any faults. Tobin’s transformation is brilliant; his doubts beforehand are well executed. His awkwardness at so many things is uncomfortably true to life. Ki, Tobin’s squire, is very lovable. I have to say that many of the characters are probably too good to be true, but it’s easy to care about them, which is more important. Many of the characters have multiple sides to them, especially the “usurpers”. It’s easy to see their motives. The sense of rightness over Tobin, that she is the next in a long line of warrior queens, is consuming, and she has the reader cheering for her by the end.
The plot is very swift, and the book ends with an unexpected idea – for me at least – that I am looking forward to seeing Tobin overcome.
Not much else to say on this book, except that I can’t wait to read the last book of the trilogy!
After a slow start in Medalon, Jennifer Fallon reached her stride in Treason Keep, and with Harshini really shows that she can write. I have some minor plot qualms, but I really enjoyed this book.
The major qualm is something that I read in other reviews before I began the book, and I found it to be true; the gods are used often as a deus ex machina. In the previous two books, R’shiel could call on them and they sometimes listened to her, but here they obeyed her without question and allowed her an easy out most of the time. While this is bad, I think it’s also understandable. The gods need R’shiel to do what they cannot, and naturally they want to convince her to continue, so helping her is the obvious choice for them. Moreover, their power is definitely shown in the previous two books, so it isn’t as though the reader is unaware that they can perform these feats. It is more a problem that R’shiel uses them when she should be using her own intelligence to get herself out of a bad situation. If she was relying on herself, the book would have been better, because the heroine would have been stronger.
That said, R’shiel has become practically omnipotent in this book, and she has grown quite a bit. She is the demon child, after all, destined to destroy a god, and we get the idea that she has finally settled into and accepted her destiny. I like that she doesn’t always have the answer, even though she thinks she does. She’s much more human that way.
My favorite character is undoubtedly still Adrina, who is surprisingly lovable and obstinate and clever. She really shows her intelligence and doesn’t rely on anything but her mind and her will, which in contrast to R’shiel is very striking.
This is the first book of the trilogy with writing that didn’t make me cringe in parts. Treason Keep was undoubtedly better than Medalon, but Harshini swept me along so that I didn’t even notice if there was any awkwardness, a sure sign that Ms. Fallon has improved.
Overall, I found the book very engaging, the characters endearing if sometimes a bit flat (Mandah in particular), and the resolution satisfying. Jennifer Fallon is not a master of fantasy yet and I wouldn’t list these books among my favorites, but I liked them. Some reviewers declare that she is very good at balancing political entanglements, but I would ask them to read George R.R. Martin or Jacqueline Carey before making such a grandiose statement. There are politics, but not nearly on the level those authors can muster up. I would call the Demon Child trilogy an entertaining read, but not one that is likely to stick in the mind for very long.
This book is the second in the Temeraire series, which I believe will shortly reach four books. So far, I have found the books to be enjoyable, with a rather comforting feel, but not very deep or complex.
Throne of Jade opens with the Chinese embassy desperately trying to separate Temeraire, a rare Celestial dragon, only for the imperial family, from his captain, Laurence. In the previous book, Laurence and Temeraire found each other when the British captured Temeraire’s egg and later assisted in defeating Napoleon in various battles. In this one, it seems they must outwit the Chinese in order to stay together and to return to England.
The plot is very slow. Novik spends a great deal of time describing adventures on ship that have no real relevance to the plot. She is world-building, but it isn’t very interesting, and as a result the middle of this book drags on and on. They are on a ship for about half the book, and aside from two battles, not much else happens. When Laurence and Temeraire get to China, the plot finally catches up and starts to churn along as the characters make revelations about why they’ve been treated this way.
I think my favorite part is still the affection between dragons and their captains. Laurence and Temeraire are almost like father and child; while this subverts Novik’s attempt to make dragons appear intelligent, it is endearing, and definitely a selling point. Laurence’s friendships with other people are also remembered affectionately, though not fleshed out in this book.
Novik had to bring the book to China in order to make it interesting, but I think there should have been more time in China and less time aboard ship. A lot of the book rests on diplomatic negotiations, which doesn’t do much to enliven the story. Things do happen in this book, it’s just that they are few and far between, and the interactions otherwise don’t provide enough incentive to keep the reader interested. More large-scale battles would have helped. It was interesting to meet Temeraire’s biological family, but there wasn’t really enough focus on them to make that a selling point. Most of the interactions are later described by Temeraire; I think a better solution would have been for Laurence to witness some of the interactions himself, perhaps attending lessons like one of the characters suggested.
I’m hoping that Black Powder War, the next in the series, has more plot. Diplomatic issues do not really make for an interesting book here, even though they have in others. I think Novik needs to speed up the events and cut down on the filler, but keep the friendships and affections in place.
I read this book as part of a Green Dragon group read over on LibraryThing. I probably would not have read it on my own, and I certainly would not have finished it on my own.
The story begins with the fact that Princess Anja has fled, even though she was just about to be betrothed to a man that she loved very much. Thus, a search for her ensues, and focuses mostly on Mykkael, captain of the garrison, a man of a different race from everyone else, and the target of a great deal of prejudice. One other thing that the author, Janny Wurts, makes clear is the sacrifice of horses for men and women in such dangerous situations, but to reveal how would give away a great deal of the story.
One problem with this book is that the writing is almost impenetrable. Wurts likes to use words in strange ways not common to conversational English. I generally like books with very dense prose and lots of description, but this is not what happens in Chasm. The grammar is just awkward. In a conversation on the Green Dragon forums, the author said that she specifically chooses words and forms of words for their meanings, and everything is there for a reason. If this is the case, most of it was lost on me, and a great deal of the first half of the book went over my head because I just couldn’t keep my mind on the pages. Here’s an example:
“Mykkael sat on the settle. At home enough to push back his hood, he washed the suet and blood from his hands in the basin fetched by the poacher’s tongue-tied little daughter. He did not press with questions. A rare man for respect, he stifled his need and waited for Benj to order his thoughts” (p. 135).
Or:
“Mykkael took up the stained cloth in scalding distaste; pulled it over his head, not missing the artful subtlety” (p. 182).
It feels awkward and uncomfortable to read, and this phrasing goes on throughout the book.
That is really my main complaint though. The character of Mykkael is very charismatic, but at the same time very unrealistic. He’s literally perfect. He holds his honor above all and doesn’t much care if he dies, as long as he’s serving his oaths. He always comes up with a solution and he predicts everything that happens. He’s been through the same situation before, but I doubt any enemy is that predictable to begin with. He is virtually invincible. That just annoys me.
The story is okay though. It’s interesting, and the concept of going beyond racial prejudice to judge on merit is a prominent and important one that has presence in our society today. The characters in the book had other reasons to attempt to turn people against Mykkael, but his different race was a major factor. It was nice for that to be overcome. The magic system needed to be explained more, rather than just existing without any display of how precisely the system of sorcerers works. Basic magic is understandable, but not the underlying concepts.
There’s also a little bit of unnecessary romantic drama thrown in towards the end. It irritated me because it was unrealistic and served no purpose other than existing. I think it may have been intended to make the book more moving, but personally I’d have preferred Mykkael to stick with his first love.
There isn’t much I did like about this book. If I was reading on my own, I would probably have stopped after 100 pages, when I learned that the frustrating prose continued and the story didn’t go far. I was moved by the last 100 pages, but overall it wasn’t worth the slow, time-consuming experience of the rest of the book.
|
|
Recent Comments