|
|
I tried to suspend expectations for this new book by Guy Gavriel Kay. And I did like it. It just doesn’t approach the brilliance of his historical fantasy, unfortunately. It felt like a book by another author, and only occasionally did I feel glimpses of the Kay I know and adore.
That’s not to say it’s a bad book. The action gets moving, fast. It feels more like a YA novel, in that sense. The main character, Ned, is just as clueless as the reader, although I did guess one of the secrets well before Ned figured it out. It didn’t matter much except to take away some of the impact of the ending. Part of the novel is about his growth as a person, which is probably another reason it felt like a YA novel. Lots of magic involved. There is also a lot of relationship growth, which normally I enjoy, but not as much here. To be honest, I think it was the narrator that I wasn’t particularly fond of – I didn’t dislike Ned, I just found it difficult to relate to him. A lot of the modern speech just jarred, things like jpegs and hotmail seemed strangely out of place.
I did like it though. It definitely held my attention and I actively wanted to get back to it. I appreciated the integration of history in the narrative, including it in the fantasy. It’s just that this book is missing something, something like wider relevance or commentary on a universal condition, which Kay normally includes. Perhaps he’s trying to tell us something about growing up and understanding and family relationships, but it fell short for me, and the book feels like it was merely enjoyable, not significant. He could have done something better with all that history than throw out a never-ending love story capturing the eternal discord between Romans and Germans.
If I am missing it, someone please let me know! Otherwise, I almost definitely will be recommending Kay’s other work well before this one.
Margaret of York always plays a small role in historical fiction dealing with the Yorkist side of the Wars of the Roses. Sister to Edward IV and Richard III, she is often a figure in her childhood and young adulthood but vanishes from the picture once she marries Charles the Bold, duke of Burgundy. I was very happy to find a book which focused on her and covered her life in Burgundy.
The author acknowledges that much here is speculation. Little is known of Margaret outside of her itinerary. Kings are hard enough to trace in the middle ages, so it is not surprising that a princess and duchess would be similar. Regardless, Smith and I share the same view, that historical fiction is meant to fill in the bones of history, not change their shape. In that sense, she does an admirable job from what I know of, and nothing she introduces is implausible, except a scene at the end which probably would not have been acceptable. Margaret’s love for Anthony Woodville is certainly possible. Her duty as a royal princess was to ally with foreign powers, not to follow her heart, regardless of what her brothers did. They were men, after all — and Edward IV’s disadvantageous marriage continues to bring scorn upon his head more than five hundred years later.
Smith’s writing is not as polished as it could be, but neither does it detract from the story she tells. At times, that story does drag, especially in the beginning as Margaret is basically waiting to be married. Nothing much the author could have done to change that, and she does insert some extraneous events in an attempt to speed up the pace. It is by far most interesting when Margaret travels to Burgundy for her wedding.
I also approve of the author’s decision regarding the ending. It was the best choice.
All in all, certainly recommended for historical fiction readers, but may be a bit too lengthy for those of us who aren’t fascinated by the Middle Ages.
This sequel to CHOCOLAT is much darker and more intense. You should read that book before this one. Although enough hints are dropped that you may understand what’s going on, you will lose a lot of affection for the characters and important background. Vianne Rocher and her daughter Anouk have assumed new names and new, nondescript personalities in an effort to evade the Black Man, who is always chasing them. When Zozie, full of magic, enters their lives, it’s impossible for them to resist her appeal, and she quickly establishes herself with Vianne and Anouk. She is also a viewpoint character, which means the reader suspects her from the very beginning of being something much worse than the other characters can see.
The book starts slowly as we grow accustomed to the Rochers’ new life. Anouk attends a regular school and suffers as any pre-teen does. Vianne hides her vibrant personality as she romantically entangles herself with their landlord, a regular man. Their chocolaterie barely pays the rent. Zozie emerges as a helping hand, and the reader quickly sees that she is just as Vianne used to be, before Vianne became afraid. The plot escalates from there and remains very gripping throughout. It’s much stronger than CHOCOLAT in that sense, but also not nearly as endearing. There are no Armandes or Josephines and many of the chocolaterie’s customers remain a scanty character sketch. A few exceptions exist, like one of Anouk’s friends, but overall, there isn’t the same feeling of community.
It’s easy to feel frustrated with Anouk and Vianne for being blind, as well, as they remain ignorant to Zozie’s secrets long after she has revealed them to the reader in her sections. They are still the most likable characters in the book, particularly Anouk, and I grew even fonder of them than I was before.
This book has much to recommend it. The plot is suspenseful and tightly woven, the main characters elicit strong feelings from the reader, and the entire book is very satisfying by the end. I enjoyed the relationships between characters most of all as they grow and change. I’d definitely tell a friend to read it.
A young woman and her daughter come to a small French town to set up a small chocolate shop. They are not Christians in a town full of them, and they meet with a great deal of prejudice, but still manage to set the lives of the people in the town in a whirlwind.
The best description for me is that this book was cute. It was enjoyable, deftly written, with likable characters. I enjoyed the effect Vianne and Anouk had on the townspeople and particularly their interactions with Reynaud, the priest. I also liked his journal entries and the differences of perspective, although I didn’t at first, and I think it was a great way of introducing back story and motive without burdening the central narrative. There was a certain lack of substance, perhaps related to the transience of the two main characters since they are prevented from forming any relationships that feel lasting. Perhaps that stopped some of the emotional investment in the little town and its vulnerable inhabitants.
Regardless, I liked it. I would probably recommend it to my friends if they were looking for something light, perhaps like a piece of reading chocolate.
I tried hard to like this book. I really did. Everyone keeps telling me how wonderful Erikson is and how he’s breaking all this ground in fantasy, and everyone also said that this book was easier to understand than the first. Well, it is, I’m happy to say that, but it still doesn’t make it good. There is just too much going on, and ordinarily I love books with too much going on, but this one just doesn’t pull it off. It makes everything confusing and rushed and constantly leaves off characters after a few pages with a cliffhanger ending, forcing the reader to wait fifty pages for their next little scene, by which point I’ve already lost the feeling of suspense and just get irritated.
This is a book about war and not much else. Everything is a struggle. I suspect this is why Erikson is often compared to George R.R. Martin, because he does similar things, but Martin does it better, still managing to engage the reader in his story even as you know the viewpoint character is likely to be killed at any time. With Martin, the overall struggle is understood. Half the time it’s impossible to figure out why Erikson’s characters are at war, except that they are.
I do have MEMORIES OF ICE, so I will be reading that as I’m interested to see what happened to the characters in the first volume, but afterwards I really doubt I will be continuing with the series. What a shame, because I was really hoping to discover a new author to love.
This book’s two main characters are a courtesan and her dwarf, detailing their struggles to escape a captured Rome and re-establish themselves in Venice. There is a fair bit of mystery in it as well as they find it hard to trust those in their new home — at least, Bucino does.
I have to confess that I found this historical fiction on the mediocre side. I just didn’t see anything captivating about it. It was written lightly, the mystery was confusing, and there was no pull compelling me to read more. In the first few pages I thought it might be one of those books that I never finished. It recovered from there, luckily, but never amounted to anything except a sense that it was missing something. I did like the ending, which redeemed it a little; very poignant and suitable for the subject matter. Otherwise, though, not much exciting to read here. I’d probably recommend her first novel, THE BIRTH OF VENUS, instead, unless you are fascinated by Renaissance Venice and wouldn’t mind a bit of mystery and not much else.
Ian McEwan is such a frequently-mentioned author that I figured I had to read something by him eventually. I didn’t find the brilliance that everyone talks about in ON CHESIL BEACH, but that’s not to say it was bad.
I think its problem was mainly its length. McEwan attempts to interweave a snapshot of a couple’s honeymoon with memories of how they met and how their relationship progressed up until that point. In less than two hundred pages, though, it’s just very difficult to like the characters. McEwan didn’t manage to engage me in their lives. I was interested in what was happening to them, but I think the book never breaks the barrier and allows the reader to feel for them. Instead they just remain oddities, too foreign from my own experience to gain empathy. In fact, I didn’t feel anything until the last few pages of the book, which I don’t think was the idea.
I still liked it though. As a little snapshot of what could have happened to one couple in the age of inexperience and hushed proprieties, it was interesting. I just never felt like the characters could have existed. I think I’ll try Atonement at some point in the future and see if this author is worth reading again.
This is a story about three generations of Irish women, in the end coming full circle back to the island of their origin. Watching them repeat the mistakes of their forebears because of lack of communication is sad. Although each story is a little different, the connections between them are obvious even as they are intertwined. Cliona gives birth to her daughter, Grace, in America, knowing that she will be rejected if she returns to her Irish island. Grace rebels almost instantly against her mother, and it is her story that is the saddest as she never quite gets what she wants and loses everything in the end. Grace’s daughter, Grainne, is extremely close to her mother but has believed her grandmother dead since she was three. Instead, she finds herself returning to the island, facing a new life that she must adapt to.
I enjoyed this book. I thought there was little too much emphasis on sex, as there does tend to be, and the author frequently talked about how people smelled. I don’t know about anyone else, but I know very few people who have such a distinctive smell present around them all the time. In fact, I can only think of one. It threw me out of the story instead of bringing me in, which I don’t think was the author’s intention, just because she talked about people’s scents very frequently. Setting that aside, I found the book moving, especially the communication barriers that life constantly throws up around us. That is so true, especially between teenagers and their parents. Families can be brutal and I think that Lisa Carey shows how true that is, despite the love that is ever-present. I’m not sure I would recommend this book to someone else unless they suggested it first, but I did enjoy it.
I first read this book sophomore year of high school, about six years ago. I was surprised how much of it had stayed with me, but also how well it held up with someone who already knew the conclusion to all the mystery.
Du Maurier knows well how to spin an enthralling mystery. She builds the suspense slowly and steadily and creates an atmosphere that for me is rarely found elsewhere. Rebecca and Manderley are both palpable characters even though neither of them are actually alive. The narrator is eminently sympathetic, and even though she is a bit wimpy, it’s easy to understand why and how. She’s out of her league for the most part, and she copes the best she can. Each character feels like they could exist, except perhaps Rebecca, but that could just be because she is so different from me – even the cruel Mrs. Danvers has two sides and her cruelty is to some extent understood and explained to the reader. They all have motives for their actions. Everything is tight and well done.
Also, the first person narration is excellent – we really do see through the current Mrs de Winter’s eyes and she acts as a filter for our understanding.
This novel is excellent, and there’s a reason why my edition says it is the classic tale of romantic suspense. I also read recently that du Maurier was consciously evoking JANE EYRE, which may help to explain its similar everlasting appeal. There is nothing about this novel that isn’t five star, and I happily recommend it to everyone I know.
In TRAITOR’S MOON, Lynn Flewelling entangles her nightrunner characters Alec and Seregil in yet another dilemma. This time, the duo are required to go back to Seregil’s homeland, from which he had been exiled as a young boy, in an attempt to get the Aurenfaie on Skala’s side in the war against Plenimar. The war is still raging despite the victories of the last book and Skala is now desperate.
I liked this book better than the first two. For one, the relationship between Alec and Seregil became a bit more realistic. Watching Seregil deal with his status as Exile as moving and interesting, and I thought the mystery and what to do was well plotted and very well foreshadowed. I didn’t manage to figure out what was going to happen in the end. These books are getting better at being great fantasy, and with that you can tell that the author is improving with experience, which is obvious once you move on to the Tamir trilogy. In the meantime, I’m hoping she writes another Nightrunner book, because I’d like to read more of their adventures now that her writing and plotting has improved so much.
|
|
Recent Comments