|
|
When in college, asha meets and marries a prisoner in a jail she visits for one of her classes. She is stunned by how intelligent, compassionate, and loveable Rashid is and believes he regrets his crime. She also believes that he will get out on his first opportunity, but she doesn’t want to have a baby while he’s in prison. When she finds herself pregnant for the first time, she has an abortion. The second time, she can’t bring herself to do so again, and has the baby, convinced that Rashid will be released soon. She never sees herself as a single mother, until Rashid gets in more trouble that he doesn’t deserve and asha leaves him, unable to continue on with a husband she may not have a future with. This is the story of asha’s struggle to cope as a single mother and her all-consuming love for her daughter, Risa.
I’m not a mother and my parents are still happily married, but I know single moms have it hard. Many of the people closest to me have just their mom and it’s always rough even if the father stays involved and pays child support. Despite that, I felt asha focused just a little too much on herself despite this love for her daughter. She develops alcoholism and tells her daughter that she needs “mommy time” on a very frequent basis; it’s hard to see how devoted she is when she keeps finding other things to spend her time with. She also sets a bad example with abusive relationships. This is all despite a good upbringing, a job, and a college education. I found significant, though, her candid admission of how difficult it is for a black woman alone and in general the stereotypes that surround her despite what she does to buck them. Seeing why an intelligent, beautiful woman would stay with an abusive man was a revelation to me; I still think I’d leave, especially if I had a young daughter who might be influenced by my actions.
I guess in the end I couldn’t really relate to this book, perhaps because asha’s experience is so outside of my own and because I don’t believe I’d make the choices she did. I also found it very depressing. That said, perhaps it’s important for me to read books like this in order to get a greater picture of the world outside of my own little bubble. I still don’t think anything could compel me to marry a prisoner, though, and from that perspective it’s very hard to understand asha or feel true sympathy for her despite all that suffering.
Check out Something Like Beautiful: One Single Mother’s Story on Amazon.
In the seventh Harry Potter book, Hermione receives this book and one of the fairy tales serves as an essential plot point in it. So, what better idea than to write out all the fairy tales and sell them, too? Clearly, good idea. Each of these fairy tales is different and has its own little objective. There are five of them and at the end, Dumbledore comments on each, with some footnotes added by Hermione Granger. I won’t go into what each of them are, because I think we’ve seen a lot of reviews and it’s actually been a while since I read the book. I did want to put out a short review, though, just because I like to review everything I read.
My favorite story was the one featured in the actual Harry Potter books, incidentally. I liked the message about cheating death, and I liked that it reminded me of the Harry Potter series. Otherwise, I found these to be short, whimsical reads that fit in reasonably well with the universe but don’t really add all that much to it. Nice for completionists, and nice that a donation is made, but otherwise, nothing special, and not at all compared to the series itself.
Buy The Tales of Beedle the Bard on Amazon.
As these books are essentially two halves of the same story, I thought it would make the most sense if I reviewed them together. Thomas, duke of Wyndham, has been raised to power and privilege, knowing from birth what it was to be, essentially, Wyndham. He’s been engaged to Lady Amelia since they were babies. His grandmother, however, is a stodgy old dowager determined to make everyone’s life miserable, particularly that of her companion, Grace Eversleigh, a girl whose parents were country nobility but on their death found nothing for herself but this position. Into this established little picture comes Jack Audley, a former soldier turned highwayman with a disturbing resemblance to Thomas’s dead uncle – his father’s older brother. If Jack is proven legitimate, their whole world will be turned upside down.
In the first book, the central characters are Jack and Grace, and everything is seen through their point of view. In the second, we see things through the eyes of Thomas and Amelia. These books get a lot of criticism for being mostly the same story, but I think when you know that going in – as you should if you’ve read any summary or even heard of the books – you can’t really complain, because why did you bother reading the second one in the first place if you didn’t want to hear the same story told a bit differently? That’s my main gripe with most of the reviews I’ve read. I found the second book intriguing enough even with the same plot, because the characters are different and that’s really why I was interested in it. The search for legitimacy and what it means to each person is explored through all four of them and I think it’s a different way of looking at romance. I particularly like that the first one focuses on the lower class (although none of them are low class, they’re all of gentle birth) who are about to experience a lift in status, while the second explores the issues of identity that Thomas has, realizing he’s not the duke after all and how much of his identity rests on that – and how much doesn’t. Amelia has these issues to a much lesser extent given that she seems to have less attachment to her future as duchess and instead wants to marry a man she actually likes.
Now, I did feel like these didn’t quite live up to the first few I read by Julia Quinn, I must admit. I didn’t feel qu ite that same spark with the characters – they just weren’t as lively, there wasn’t as much chemistry, and I didn’t have that smile on my face at their interactions. She still does deal with a real life issue here though – identity crisis and how we define ourselves – and there’s also Jack, who reflects, in a small way, our terrible habit of letting those who fight for our countries languish and struggle because once their duty is done we’re not interested. So I wouldn’t say Quinn has lost it, because I still enjoyed these books. I think they’re great for romance. I just don’t think they’re quite up to her standard, and I think that before you read them, you should know that they consist of the same basic plot told through the eyes of two different couples.
Whew! That was a lengthy review for me. If you’re interested in these books, check out The Lost Duke of Wyndham and Mr. Cavendish, I Presume on Amazon.
And so the time has come for me to discuss Twilight. I’m posting this during the Sunday Salon because I want to hear what others think. I’ve read about this book everywhere, but I’d like one spot for you to give me your opinion. So please, do so here, or link me to your review so I can get a more complete view of the range of opinions. If not, well, I want to rant a little bit too.
Allow me to skip plot summary here, I’m sure we’ve all heard it before: Bella moves to rainy Forks, Bella meets perfect vampire boy Edward, love ensues. Allow me also to state that I fully, reluctantly intended to love this book. I like romance, I like fantasy type settings in general, I was a silly teenager that fell in love with every boy who ever smiled at me, and I really was in the mood for young adult books at the time.
So the surprise was that I didn’t love Twilight. I liked it. It did bring back those silly teenage years that I normally try to shove away into the corner of my brain marked “recycle bin”. Like I said, I was boy-crazy in the worst way. I think I missed something essential, here, because even that bit of me still ecstatic over cute boys did not like Edward Cullen. I don’t understand why every girl who has read this adores him – even intelligent, grown women that should probably know better. He is a stalker. He watches Bella while she sleeps! He always shows up when she’s in trouble and he gets her in danger. He doesn’t want her hanging around with the friends she made before him. He drives too fast even when it makes Bella nervous. He reacts violently when they kiss and makes her feel like she’s crazy. At first, he is utterly cruel to her. Okay, he is attractive and sparkly, but I do not see the meant-to-be going on in this book. I don’t see why he’s perfect except when Stephenie Meyer explicitly says that he is perfect. Maybe it’s because I never liked the dangerous guys, but I don’t get it even when I channel teenage Meghan.
I did find the book to be a fairly entertaining story, but I guess having one of the two central characters fall flat damaged it for me. I also didn’t particularly like the writing and hope it gets better as I go on in the series. Every detail of Bella’s life is delineated, like what she eats for breakfast and when she throws on some clothes. I don’t like the prose, either. I’m not a perfect writer, but I can’t stand seeing ellipses and dashes used incorrectly in professionally published work. I do it myself here but whenever I am writing for a professional audience I take all that out and correct it when I read other people’s writing.
Before you ask, yes, I got the next two. Like I said, I was convinced I’d like this even if I didn’t want to. Now I’m going to read them eventually and maybe I’ll understand why people love it by the end. I’ve got Breaking Dawn on my hold list at the library. I’m not shelling out money for that one, unless I find it for $1 like I did with the others.
Lastly, I want to stick out my opinion on comparisons of this to Harry Potter. Simply put, they have nothing in common except popularity and age group. I think of Harry Potter as more of a fantastical, wholesome kids’ series that promotes good stuff like family love, sacrifice, and loyalty. J.K. Rowling is perhaps not the best writer, but she is a terrific storyteller, and I love the HP books. When you get relationships, they are the awkward ones when you don’t know how kisses go but you think they might be nice, and for the most part they are built on solid foundations of friendship. This one? Well, Bella ditches and disobeys her father pretty quickly, she ignores her mother’s emails if she doesn’t feel like answering them, and she is happy to ignore all of the friends who welcomed her in favor of the creepy vampire family. Her relationship with Edward is similarly creepy and I think borderline abusive. I know that if I had a kid, I’d be thrilled that she/he read Harry Potter and would be happy to discuss it, but we’d have to have a long talk about Twilight because I think there are some issues there.
Do you love Twilight? Want to set me in my place about how wrong I am? Please, do so! If you’ve heard it all before, please feel free to ignore this post and read some of my other posts.
Over a span of ten years in Hong Kong, Will Truesdale falls in love with one woman before World War II and has an affair with another one after. When he arrives in society, he meets Trudi Canavan, an enigmatic, enchanting woman who somehow chooses him to take under her wing and they begin a passionate love affair. At the other end of the scale we have Claire Pendleton, a married piano teacher who generally reminded me of a mouse, and who can’t get enough of Will. It seems that Claire is merely a foil to get us to what happened with Will and Trudi during the war, which is where this story really lies.
I’ll be honest, I didn’t really enjoy this book much. It’s written in a spare style which I like very much and I thought the story was intriguing. I even grew to like Trudi over the period of the novel, though I didn’t at the beginning. I think the problem, however, was that Claire bothered me. Despite the fact that she steals from her employers and carries on an affair behind her husband’s back, she seemed spineless to me. To be honest, I didn’t like post-war Will either. They seemed empty, going through the motions to get the author’s plot where it was going by that point. The best parts were certainly those featured after the start of the war and the occupation of Hong Kong, at which point the novel develops into a very moving, human story about the unfortunate power of war.
Is it worth reading? Yes, but I really wish that the author had not chosen the dual narratives. They allow us to see the effects of the war, but it could have been done with someone more interesting than Claire, characters who had personality, or at least someone I could relate to in some way. Personal preference, and I’m sorry that such a thing marred my enjoyment of what could otherwise have been a stunning book.
Buy The Piano Teacher: A Novel on Amazon.
Colin has invited Eloise to his country estate for a week away together, and for a chance to look at the Selwick papers. She finds the letters of Lady Charlotte Lansdowne, an extremely romantic girl who has spent most of her life at her country estate, Girdings, reading books. Charlotte has been infatuated with the duke of Dovedale, Robert, ever since her father grew ill and his father arrived to take up the dukedom. She is thrilled at his return. Robert, on the other hand, views himself as a “rotten apple” and is only in England to catch the man who killed his commanding officer and father figure under the guise of war. His mission is too important for him to fall in love with his distant cousin, but Charlotte has no such resolutions.
At first, I couldn’t figure out how on earth this book was connected to the other Pink Carnation books, except for that Charlotte is Henrietta’s best friend. It appears, however, that the man Robert is after is yet another in the series of flower spies, although we learn very little about the actual Pink Carnation in this book. After The Seduction of the Crimson Rose, this story begins as almost unbearably sweet and I was actually pleased when reality hit and the romantic delusions ended. It feels inevitable anyway, and the book got much better afterwards. Both Charlotte and Robert had to figure out who the other person was outside of their own romantic misconceptions. They both fell off the pedestal, so to speak, and I think that’s a problem rarely dealt with in romance; too often both characters are flawless. Also, I really enjoyed the way both characters had their own “bad guy” to deal with and the way the stories neatly combined. And once again, I can tell this will be a frustration for those who treat this as an ordinary romance, but there is no love scene here either! I find it refreshing and I think trying to fit one in would have ruined the plot, so good judgment on Willig’s part. Furthermore, some interesting revelations about Colin in this one, and it’s nice to see Eloise without her obsession about being boyfriendless.
I’m looking forward to the next one! As I said in my last review of this series, it’s not ending any time soon and I’m still enjoying it. I just hope we learn more about the Pink Carnation soon. I’m anxiously awaiting Jane’s story!
Buy The Temptation of the Night Jasmine on Amazon.
Eloise has finally scored a date with Colin, but more importantly, she’s found the Vaughn archives and is digging into Lord Sebastian Vaughn’s life. Miss Mary Alsworthy, essentially jilted by Lord Geoffrey Pinchingdale and her sister Letty, is at a loss. She’s older now and has no reliable husband prospects on the horizon. In a bid to gain more independence, she agrees to help Lord Vaughn by becoming one of the petals of the Black Tulip. After all, she has just the right coloring and she definitely needs more excitement in her life. Needless to say, she gets much more excitement than she bargained for.
This is my favorite Pink Carnation book so far. I found both characters to be stiff at first, but watching them soften – if only to each other – was possibly the best moment of the series. Mary went, believably, from self-serving to really caring about this man, and I could see how it happened. Best of all, this book is very much a meeting of the minds. Mary and Vaughn have the best snarky conversations of any characters and it seems as though their personalities just fit together perfectly. They are the cynics among a flock of impressionable romantics and it’s hard not to love them for it. As for the plot, I figured out who the Black Tulip was maybe halfway through the book, so the big reveal wasn’t all that much of a surprise, but that was okay with me; there were other exciting events going on. I also, contrary to popular opinion it seems, enjoyed that Willig left out the customary love scene in this one. It isn’t necessary and never really has been. There’s a spark between these two, but no need to follow it through when we all know how that goes. I think it works much better this way because it’s more about who they are as people.
Again, I think this is the best in the series. I have begun to accept that the series isn’t actually going to end any time soon, though, so if that bothers you, it may be worth staying away. Personally, I love these books, they’re perfect candy fare and I very much enjoy the history worked in and even the frame story of Colin and Eloise. Buy The Seduction of the Crimson Rose on Amazon.
While walking one day, Henry Lee spies a crowd of people around a closed down hotel, marveling at the artifacts discovered within – remnants of those who were rounded up and sequestered in concentration camps during World War II. Henry, sore from losing his wife, Ethel, can hardly contain his hope as these belongings may just provide a link with his past, when he loved a beautiful Japanese girl and was convinced that everything would work out.
I loved this book. It’s always fun to start a review with that sentence, isn’t it? I can’t say I was hooked from the first page, but somewhere around when Henry meets Keiko, I fell in love and couldn’t wait to read more. I really didn’t, I finished it in only two days. Ford’s writing is lovely and he gives us a lot of history to think about. The Japanese internment during World War II is one of those murky areas of American history that, to be honest, was skipped over throughout my education. I only knew about it because a friend’s grandmother was imprisoned at first and have since come across it in other novels. It’s always appalled me; rounding up American citizens just because of their ancestry is disgusting. I was very interested in the exploration of it here, particularly the concerned Chinese citizens trying not to get arrested themselves.
Anyway, enough with the history! I really loved this book because it had a wonderful mix of sadness and hope, perfectly capturing bittersweet. It made me feel nostalgic for a past so distant from my own life that it’s like they lived in another country, even though I’m sure I wouldn’t want to have lived it. The title is so appropriate. Watching the story unfold is like listening to beautiful music, but with that edge of tension in it. I wanted to know what happened and I raced through it. I can’t wait to read this one again and savor it.
Highly recommended. Beautiful, bittersweet story and fascinating, important history.
Buy Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet on Amazon today.
Beautiful, smart, but a little too determined, Fatima Shihabi flees Iraq when she learns that she is a target for Saddam Hussein’s secret police. Once she finally gets out, she realizes that no one will grant her asylum, and that she is trapped. Her brother, a college professor working in the United States, is desperate to save her and calls up a law firm in New York City. That’s how Fatima’s case ends up in the hands of Charles Sherman, and together they fight to free her and find a way out from underneath the power of tyrants – and veils – of all kinds.
I enjoyed this book. While the prose is occasionally awkward, for the most part the writing disappears into the page as the reader gets swept into this passionate, compelling story. It would be difficult not to feel for Charles and Fatima – here they are, fully fleshed out, determined, flawed human beings. I particularly liked Charles, who seemed very like a person I would know on the street. I also liked that since the characters were drawn together by crisis, it was easier to imagine them loving each other than otherwise. When you are that close to dying, things and priorities change, something I think Murphy expressed well. The plot was never predictable until just before the end, and I have to say that I didn’t see that ending coming, although perhaps I should have given that it fits the tone of the book very well.
I will admit that I skipped the poetry, but I almost always do that, and at least there wasn’t much for me to skip here. It didn’t seem to matter, either, as the story functioned well without such props. I also really liked how the veils were woven into the story and how we don’t face the truth of ourselves very often. Very cleverly done.
Overall, I recommend it. This book is a very compelling tale of what’s happening in Iraq and how hard it is for the citizens there, not to mention the characters and their struggle. I’m glad I read it. More, I sincerely hope that if Mr. Murphy chooses to write another book that he is picked up by a mainstream publisher. I think he deserves it – he has that talent.
Buy A Thousand Veils on Amazon today.
It is the duty of Arcturus, physician to the governor Agricola, to discover who killed the mysterious Maecenas, a man with a message for Agricola. Maecenas is found draped unceremoniously over a sacred altar with his throat cut open, but the blood around him is not his own and the throat wound didn’t kill him. Who did kill him, and why? What is the future for Agricola – and for Arcturus?
This book is marketed as “Roman noir” and I think that suits it very well. Setting a mystery in Roman Britain is a great idea and surprisingly, the noir genre works very well in the context of Londinium. At times I felt like I was watching a classic film even though I was clearly reading a book set in a place distant from any of them. The problem is, though, that I didn’t really like the book much. It took me days to read and I just wasn’t interested in the resolution of the mystery. I was generally confused and I felt as though the main character was making connections without letting me know. This is very common for me and mysteries though, so it’s probably just me. I was hoping that since it was historical fiction, it might have a little more for me to grasp, but I didn’t find that to be the case.
Worse, Arcturus falls in love in the course of the book. He meets her, she warns him about Maecenas, and then he’s in love, without any conversation or idea of who she is, and then all of a sudden he wants to marry her. I really, really hate unbelievable love stories and I think that biased me against the book before it really got going. I think there may have been some backstory involved between the two, but it is not described here. Maybe in future books. I tried to be objective, but if the love is not even slightly plausible, I find it difficult to follow the rest of the book. It wrapped up nicely, but I didn’t think reading the ending was worth the rest of the book.
I feel somewhat guilty writing this review because I can see that the author put a great deal of effort into the book, particularly with research, and I honestly think that this is just me not liking mysteries. I thought it would feel more like historical fiction, but it’s definitely mystery. I should have known better, but I do owe a review and I can only give my own opinion.
So, in conclusion, I think if you like mysteries, you may like this one as well. I don’t, and I didn’t like this one, but among reviewers, I seem to be the odd one out. So, you can still check it out on Amazon . And I found this review, which summarizes how I felt but with a writer who enjoys mysteries, so you can see the difference! You can also check out this review at The Tome Traveller. If you’ve reviewed this book, please let me know so I can link to your blog as well.
|
|
Recent Comments