|
|
I’ve been looking forward to this book for a long time. I love the original Kushiel trilogy, and reread it in preparation for beginning this second trilogy (which is not yet completed, with two books published). When I came to this book, I have to admit that it disappointed me.
For one thing, I just don’t love Imriel as much as I love Phedre. This book is indeed a coming of age tale, and I really enjoy the developments in Imriel’s character, but I don’t like him nearly as much or find his story nearly as interesting. I think the fact that he grew up so much meant that less happened, plot-wise, although certainly things do happen, especially in the second half. More of the book was spent discovering himself, rather than discovering any part of the world, which normally I enjoy but I didn’t as much here, perhaps because there isn’t a sense of destiny about Imriel. He is in control, whereas things happened to Phedre and she dealt with them as she could. I suppose that is just my taste and doesn’t necessarily reflect as much on the book – just that it is definitely different.
I would also have loved to hear more about Melisande, rather than the tantalizing hints that we are given.
Otherwise, Carey’s style and prose are up to par. There’s nothing wrong with the plot, but the book is very long for the events within it. Overall, she just needs to convince me that I should care about Imriel!
Margaret Lea has little interest in living people, so when Vida Winter contacts her requesting her to write the famous author’s biography, she is perplexed. Luckily for her, and us, she goes to meet Ms. Winter, and before her unfolds a story that draws her in and consumes her every waking moment.
There are several really great things about this book. The first is its plot. I for one did not guess at all what was to happen, unless Margaret made a guess at it. There were several points where I was completely surprised at the turn of events. I was also very absorbed into the story, though it was layers deep. It is very compelling. The book is well-written and perfect for book lovers like me. Setterfield weaves in many 19th century classics, as apparently they are both Margaret’s and Ms. Winter’s favorites (as they are mine).
I have to admit that as much as I was interesting in the story Vida Winter was telling, and the plot relating to Aurelius, Margaret herself did not interest me. I can’t admit to understanding what she went through, but at times I did feel like she was far too melodramatic about everything. I suppose it was appropriate to the tone of the novel, but I wished she’d stop complaining so we could get back to the main mystery. This minor qualm is really my only problem with it, and perhaps someone who was more like Margaret or had a similar experience would feel that her behavior was perfectly appropriate – I can’t judge, but I personally was impatient with her character.
I’d recommend this, especially to someone who loves books or mysteries.
The Birth of Venus is about a young girl, Alessandra, in Renaissance Florence that is quickly spiraling out of control. She is a bit ahead of her time, as this novel is definitely done from a feminist perspective, but I liked her spirit and her curiosity and her relentlessness. The novel grabs you quickly with a suspenseful and then leaves you wondering how the prologue happened for most of the text. Luckily, there are answers to that, and other questions as well.
I enjoyed the book quite a bit. The setting was well-drawn and I felt very true to the Renaissance. Alessandra was a sympathetic character. Also, this is somewhat strange to comment on, but for a novel that involves romance, it wasn’t stereotypical at all. It is to me fairly original in its plot, which I always appreciate. I enjoyed the author’s prose style, especially in comparison to the last book I read, because I felt that I could get close to the characters and understand them, particularly Alessandra, and at times the density of her emotion struck me, too.
I did find the book historically improbable, but for once I don’t think this detracted from it. I wasn’t terribly surprised by one particular aspect of the ending, although to be honest I can’t remember why I guessed it, but I didn’t see some of the other events coming. Overall, I think it passes in the history department, as it doesn’t commit any blatant inaccuracies, only might-have-beens.
All in all, The Birth of Venus is an immersing historical experience that I would certainly recommend to someone else.
Abundance is the tale of Marie Antoinette, France’s doomed queen, slandered by many, but lately attempts to rescue her reputation have been made. Abundance is not an exception, portrayed Marie Antoinette as a naive girl, even when she is a woman, determined to do her duty but ultimately failing to understand what the populace needs from her.
It’s a challenge to get into this book. Marie Antoinette’s narration is strange and distant, which means it takes a good few pages to get used to and feel that you like her. She is her own impediment to reader’s affection, given that she is so distant from the real world throughout the novel. I don’t know that this is a fault of the novel, but she expresses her care for the people and how she does not wish to live extravagantly when she is surrounded by opulence. She’s almost too naive to care about, until the end.
The prose is well done other than this odd distant feel, and the other characters are portrayed fairly reasonably. I just find the entire situation hard to believe; luckily, I have Marie Antoinette: The Journey, on which this book was based, waiting to be read, so that I will be better able to justify the novel’s historical judgment. The plot moves along quickly, skipping years where nothing much happened, focusing only on the events. It is interesting to see the French Revolution from the perspective of the royal family, as I feel we are more typically given the history from the revolutionaries’ view.
In short, I found Marie Antoinette too saintly to be real, though I doubt she committed all the crimes that the populace claimed, but I did find the other characters and the relationships in the novel to be genuine. I would say that Abundance is a fairly typical historical fiction, not bad but not great either.
This book is a terrific end to an amazing trilogy. Now that most character relations have been established, Carey can really play with their relationships and make us feel for them even more than we could before. Except for a very uncomfortable section of the story, the necessity of which is obvious but still disturbs me, the novel is well plotted and engaging, moving quickly. Even though this was my second read-through, I was still surprised by certain things and had forgotten a great deal of the plot in four years.
I think most of all I love the relationship between Phedre and Joscelin. I wouldn’t go so far as to say it feels real, because I don’t think real people could endure what they do, but that’s part of what makes it amazing and touching. Their strength is unrealistic, but also admirable and makes us care for them even more. Watching them with another person in their family dynamic is interesting and does make them more human despite their many super-human qualities. I think their relationship is, to be honest, one of Carey’s triumphs. But then, I love the first Kushiel’s Legacy trilogy, and this book is probably just as good as the first – it dips a bit in the middle, slowing down, but overall, it’s all amazing, and I’d recommend these books to almost anyone, not just those who read fantasy. They are long, but in return they have almost every quality of an amazing, epic tale.
This entertaining YA book is about Nathaniel, a young apprentice magician, and Bartimaeus, the djinni he summons in an attempt at revenge on a man who has embarrassed him. Of course, Bartimaeus does his bidding, which gets both of them in a great deal more trouble than they’d bargained for.
I love Nathaniel, he’s very noble and very clever and very understandable. I think he’s perfect to relate to, as everyone can remember childish feelings of loyalty and embarrassment, though most of us don’t live out those feelings quite like he does. Bartimaeus is very amusing, and the footnotes that pepper his section really add to the story by giving him and his history a lot more depth. He lightens Nathaniel’s intense moods, which was really well done by Stroud, preventing the book from being depressing, which otherwise could have been possible. The book is also carefully plotted, with no dull moments, and the reader is left almost constantly wondering what will happen next as the plot escalates. It’s great. I love how the magicians are interwoven with regular society, similar to in Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell, always a plus.
I really liked it, and I am looking forward to reading the next two in the trilogy.
In this book, a subtly tyrannical, though hugely popular, woman named Freddie runs a theater school for young talents, although some of them turn out not-so-talented. The characters are enigmatic and interesting; they don’t quite reflect real life, it seems to me, although they try. My personal favorite is Jonathan, an extremely talented 9-year-old who only acts when it suits him to do so.
The book was okay, not one of my favorites. I didn’t feel connected to any of the characters in particular, and the story is not very interesting, to be honest; the theater school is poor, but that’s nothing new, though there is someone new thinking about investing; one of the teachers falls in love with the other; the children occasionally compete with each other, particularly Mattie with Jonathan, though not the other way around. The end feels unresolved to me, sort of as if the book was a snapshot of this particular school and these particular lives, but only the love affair really was interesting and went somewhere. I think I’ll get more out of this book once it’s discussed in class this week, but for now it’s left me somewhat discontented.
I don’t know how to classify this book – it’s a mix between memoirs and fiction, or so it seems to me. The book says it’s literature, but it certainly reads like at least some of the story might be true, or perhaps Sebald just crafted memoirs around various old pictures.
In any case, this is a book about people who have emigrated from Germany, and the aftermath of WWII and the Holocaust on their lives. Even if it is fiction, the story is deeply moving as these people try to understand and content themselves with their lives now. There are several common themes throughout the story that link each of these characters together, all of which would spoil the story, except perhaps the very frequent intrusion of images of Nabokov throughout the book.
I liked it; I found the beginning a bit slow, but as it went on I could see the connections and found the book very engaging and touching. I loved the inclusion of old photographs; even if they were not genuinely connected to the characters in the book, it adds an element of reality and immersion. I think that Sebald does his hardest to draw his reader in and make him feel for these people, and he succeeded with me.
This collection of short stories (and they are short, only 3-4 pages long) is described as showing us familiar cities through an outsider’s view. Had they not told me that, I never would have guessed. There is very little of the “luminosity” of the title and more sex and depression than I would have ever wanted.
The first third of the novel is essentially full of orgies, including one which involves a 14-year-old girl, and in general I found it offensive the entire way through. It seems every woman can be won through a few sleek words. I don’t really see what this has to do with the title, either – I didn’t see any of the cities portrayed through these explicit scenes and images.
The second third of the collection is entirely depressing. Every story focuses on slime, poverty, or murder, sometimes all three with other depressing aspects of city life tossed in. I find it hard to believe that on visiting these cities I would be witness to a shooting every time, especially considering I have before. Again, did not find meaning in this, and the book seems to lack all luminosity at this point.
Luckily, the last third does manage to improve. A few of the stories pick up on the same horrible themes as the first two parts, but for the most part we finally see beauty juxtaposed with depression, which I can easily imagine and see in every city. ‘Stendhal and Flaubert in the Stomach’ was my favorite of the collection, followed by a couple others in which Aguilar alludes to Gabriel Garcia Marquez. I think that if the whole book had been more like the last third, the title would have made a lot more sense and I would have gotten more out of it.
Maybe I’m missing something, I honestly could not tell you, but I did not derive any potent message from this book, and I almost completely failed to see the “cities from an outsider’s point of view” like the back of the book promised. I hope that Aliform Publishing has better books, because this one certainly isn’t going to do very well. I received the book through the LibraryThing Early Reviewers program, and otherwise I really would not have got past the first story – I’m still wondering how I ended up with this book to begin with, as I can’t think what it would match in my library. I’m very grateful for the book, but hoping for one I can actually enjoy next time.
In Harold the King, Helen Hollick deals with the seldom-fictionalized Anglo-Saxons, which I enjoyed very much. She is very historically accurate throughout, creating well-fleshed-out characters that I can believe existed and had motives for the occasionally horrendous things that they did. The story moved at a fair pace, considering the book covers approximately 20 years, and I was never bored. For readers who know little of English history beyond the famous Battle of Hastings, this book provides a painless recounting of how such a conflict came to be.
The characters even suffer internal conflict, and one can trace the development of, for example, Edith, from a spoiled young girl to a twisted, selfish queen. It is fairly easy to see where the characters are coming from. This is one of the things that I’m always looking for; are characters believable? Do I understand their doubts and fears? This book pulls that off nicely.
The prose, however, is a bit awkward. Hollick is a great storyteller, but she could do with a better editor. She seem to omit subjects from sentences when two or more sentences have the same subject, which is something I’ve never noticed elsewhere. Her transitions can be strange and her dialogue occasionally unrealistic. In general, the novel’s prose doesn’t have that polished feel which most books published by major publishing houses do. Her grammar is not incorrect, it just doesn’t flow perfectly.
I wouldn’t let that keep me from enjoying the story, though, because Hollick really does have something going here. It’s easy to get emotionally attached to her characters and to really feel for them; she also has the ability to create suspense when the conclusion of the book is already known. I’m looking forward to reading more of her Anglo-Saxon historical fiction, not only because it’s good but because there isn’t enough of it out there.
|
|
Recent Comments