November 2007
S M T W T F S
« Oct   Dec »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

The Amulet of Samarkand, Jonathan Stroud

This entertaining YA book is about Nathaniel, a young apprentice magician, and Bartimaeus, the djinni he summons in an attempt at revenge on a man who has embarrassed him. Of course, Bartimaeus does his bidding, which gets both of them in a great deal more trouble than they’d bargained for.

I love Nathaniel, he’s very noble and very clever and very understandable. I think he’s perfect to relate to, as everyone can remember childish feelings of loyalty and embarrassment, though most of us don’t live out those feelings quite like he does. Bartimaeus is very amusing, and the footnotes that pepper his section really add to the story by giving him and his history a lot more depth. He lightens Nathaniel’s intense moods, which was really well done by Stroud, preventing the book from being depressing, which otherwise could have been possible. The book is also carefully plotted, with no dull moments, and the reader is left almost constantly wondering what will happen next as the plot escalates. It’s great. I love how the magicians are interwoven with regular society, similar to in Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell, always a plus.

I really liked it, and I am looking forward to reading the next two in the trilogy.

Share

At Freddie’s by Penelope Fitzgerald

In this book, a subtly tyrannical, though hugely popular, woman named Freddie runs a theater school for young talents, although some of them turn out not-so-talented. The characters are enigmatic and interesting; they don’t quite reflect real life, it seems to me, although they try. My personal favorite is Jonathan, an extremely talented 9-year-old who only acts when it suits him to do so.

The book was okay, not one of my favorites. I didn’t feel connected to any of the characters in particular, and the story is not very interesting, to be honest; the theater school is poor, but that’s nothing new, though there is someone new thinking about investing; one of the teachers falls in love with the other; the children occasionally compete with each other, particularly Mattie with Jonathan, though not the other way around. The end feels unresolved to me, sort of as if the book was a snapshot of this particular school and these particular lives, but only the love affair really was interesting and went somewhere. I think I’ll get more out of this book once it’s discussed in class this week, but for now it’s left me somewhat discontented.

Share