|
|

What is reading, anyway? Novels, comics, graphic novels, manga, e-books, audiobooks — which of these is reading these days? Are they all reading? Only some of them? What are your personal qualifications for something to be “reading” — why? If something isn’t reading, why not? Does it matter? Does it impact your desire to sample a source if you find out a premise you liked the sound of is in a format you don’t consider to be reading? Share your personal definition of reading, and how you came to have that stance.
Fundamentally, reading is the act of seeing words and understanding their meaning. Deriving concepts from otherwise meaningless symbols. I learned to do this when I was five and I would say most children learn about the same time. In a wider sense, when I say that I am reading, I am usually reading a book. When you say you like to read, you don’t mean that you like the act of reading, interpreting symbols, but that you enjoy reading about something, like in a book or the newspaper. If you say you like to read, you generally don’t mean that you enjoy reading the sides of cereal boxes, although it is technically reading and we all do it. I don’t really consider listening to an audiobook “reading”, and if I had “read” a book in that format I’d probably say so when talking about it. I still think it’s valuable to do so, though, and if that’s the way you like to hear stories I’m all for it, it just isn’t actually reading.
So, I guess what I’m trying to say is that fundamentally reading is looking at words and understanding them. In a narrower sense, reading is understanding lots of those words in the context of a story or some wider meaning, like a news article. We all read a lot on the internet, but I wouldn’t consider someone who has never by choice cracked open a book a reader. Perhaps I would consider someone who reads a lot of magazines or newspapers one, but not someone who just reads out of necessity and not for pleasure. Would I consider someone who only listens to audiobooks a reader? Probably not, unless they were also a reader of books and circumstances forced them to listen only, such as eye problems.
These distinctions don’t matter too much in the great scheme of things, though – I wish everyone loved reading as much as I do, and whatever way you do it, I’m glad that you do!
I’m not sure why, but all the fantasy I have read lately has disappointed me, with the exception of Kushiel’s Justice. Black Sun Rising is also a disappointment, unfortunately. At the same time, however, I did like it and I would like to read the next book in the trilogy. Part of the problem with this book is that it jumped in without really showing me the relationships I was supposed to care about. I got a hint of a beginning relationship between Damian and Ciani, when all of a sudden he loves her and spends a lot of time regretting the path that she inevitably takes. I can see how relationships develop afterwards, but a large part of the emotional basis is missing and it just bugged me while I was reading. It probably didn’t help that Ciani annoyed me and I couldn’t figure out exactly what drew everyone to her
In terms of plot, the book moves very quickly and at times in unexpected ways. The novel is certainly fantasy, but it has a few hints of sci-fi – it’s clear that their civilization was once much more scientific than it is now. It remains interesting throughout and never drags, which is great in a book of fairly typical fantasy length. I enjoyed the story and I thought the world-building was fairly effective and interesting. Most of all, I liked the way the book ended. It wrapped up the main threads of the story but left a clever epilogue to show us that the story goes on and hook us in. So we don’t have to read more to find out what happens, but we want to.
In the end I’d probably call this fairly solid fantasy. It has potential to build on the relationships and the world to become something great, though. I’ll keep reading.
Robert Lacey fills us in on the snippets of English history from the late 14th century up to the early 18th. Only the amusing and entertaining and informative bits of history, which makes this a very pleasant and quick read. I can’t comment much on accuracy because a lot of the book goes beyond my time period (although he does give too much credit to Thomas More in his section on Richard III – why do people persist in doing this?), but I enjoyed it, particularly the bits I didn’t know. This is a book for people who only want a glance at the best tales, not an indepth history. It’s a great starting point, but that’s about it.
I’m still looking for volume 1, though, which covers my favorite period in English history!
In the final volume of the Grail Quest trilogy, Thomas of Hookton’s journey to find the holy grail takes him deeper into France, where he once again displays the great advantage of being an archer, faces down his cousin for the final time, and discovers that he must follow his heart despite the Church.
This book is really terrific. I liked it more than the first two – I felt that it absorbed me much more and carried me along the story better. This may be because it’s the least “tied” to actual history, but it also felt very plausible, except when Thomas risks excommunication for a woman. The only way I can accept that is if he didn’t really think he’d be excommunicated, which is probably the case. No medieval person would have risked his soul for someone he barely knew, sweet as the concept is. Otherwise, it fit right in with my own perceptions of the medieval mindset, right down to the shock of the Black Death, which we still can’t explain. I can’t say much about the Grail, considering it doesn’t actually exist, but the mechanisms of the quest, the corruption of the Church, and the warfare all really created an excellent view of the medieval world. Cornwell knows what he’s talking about.
I also really liked the characters at this point. They’re a bit difficult to like, considering he doesn’t spend much time delving into anyone’s soul except Thomas’s, but I didn’t want them to die and I was sad when the book ended because I enjoyed their company.
I think it’s also pretty important to say that this book isn’t typical medieval historical fiction. It doesn’t feel like all those trade paperbacks floating around with half-images of girls in fancy dress on the cover. I like those too, but this is grittier and much more realistic. Doesn’t focus on royalty, just on how life for regular people, for soldiers, might have been in the Hundred Years’ War. Lots of warfare – but no honor, no sex, just gritty battlefield realities as we know them. As such, it’s quite different from the sumptuous lives of royalty, which is what medieval historical fiction authors usually focus on, and I love it even more for that.
Would I recommend this book? Most certainly! I’ve got another friend hooked on Bernard Cornwell already. It could, however, be boring for those out there who don’t love medieval life or who find warfare boring, so I would judge a person’s individual reading taste before I recommended it.
How many books do you have cataloged in your LibraryThing account? How do you decide what to include- everything you have, everything you’ve read- and are there things you leave off?
I’ve got 1010 books in my LT account right now, with one on the way from Amazon. I have too many books for the room I still live in in my parents’ house. Luckily I am getting married and moving out next year, so I should be able to spread them out once I have my own place. Up until very recently, I only included books I physically owned. Then I decided that eventually LT was going to come out with a collections feature, so I added borrowed books as well. There are so few of them that it’s not worth having another account for them, honestly. I also keep books I’ve given away to preserve ratings and recommendations, but there are only a few of those as well. I do not include wishlist books that I haven’t read, I have a separate account for those. So basically the books in my library are those that I have read and those that I own.
This review may contain spoilers for Ishiguro’s work, which is best approached without any knowledge of the subject.
I only now realize how much of a disadvantage it was to read The Remains of the Day before the rest of Ishiguro’s work, although I had no choice since I read it for a class. This book feels very much like practice for Remains. Same type of unreliable narrator, an aging man who views his past differently from everyone else and only gradually realizes his mistakes. It isn’t perfect here. The emotional impact isn’t as jarring, even though Ono has wasted his life just as Stevens has. There is that same juxtaposition as the world changes and leaves the old men behind, and in both novels the older man runs into the younger generation, all of whom have a fiercely different view.
Ono is an artist who, it seems, painted propaganda and supported the Japanese war movement, which disastrously ended with the atomic bomb and the loss of World War II. When Japanese nationalism goes out of style, so too does Ono, but he only gradually realizes it, and he still finds himself worthy. This novel is really about his humanity, about the disjointed nature of the human mind and how we ponder things after the fact. Ono is unreliable in that everything is through his eyes. What’s interesting for me is the very stiff, formal nature of Japanese society contrasted so effectively with the personal style of Ono’s storytelling; things like the wedding dinner show this off quite well. I also enjoyed his relations with Ichiro, his attempts to read himself and his son into the little boy — sometimes even ignoring what Ichiro wanted while believing he was doing exactly as his grandson wished. How true to life the relations are. This is one of Ishiguro’s specialties.
Aside from Ono’s place as narrator and subject, the novel is contrasting “the floating world”, old Japan, with the modern Japan and its close ties to America. Was that old world useless? Are men like Ono useless? Is the whole of Japanese history now obsolete? It’s an interesting question, and one that the book doesn’t quite succeed in answering, but leaves open for the reader, and the future, to decide.
I still wish I had read it before Remains. That book is truly his masterpiece. This one, however, was enough for me to continue to seek out the rest of his work. Ishiguro’s style is so distinct and crisp and his technique so refined that reading even a half-way decent novel of his is better than most of the contemporary fiction I have read.

Books and films both tell stories, but what we want from a book can be different from what we want from a movie. Is this true for you? If so, what’s the difference between a book and a movie?
It’s definitely true for me. Books and movies convey things in very different ways. Movies can be more subtle – conveying emotion and expression through a glance or a touch, or using a beautiful landscape to convey location. Books have to be more descriptive and can thus be boring or fail to evoke a particular place. Books, however, also allow us to place our own stamp on a particular story and bring our own experiences to the table, more so because characters usually remain faceless. They allow us to go deeper and become friends in our minds with characters we love. There is no fourth wall, and there is in the movies just as there is on the stage. They also can give a much deeper view of character and how people’s minds work. In my opinion, there can be much more to a book than there is to a movie. Of course, I do love movies, but most of them by their very length and nature must omit my favorite qualities – deep complexity, deeper storytelling, and in-depth character insight. It’s much harder to get these things from a screen than it is from the written word.
Not surprisingly, when I’ve seen a movie derived from a book, I almost always enjoy the book more, even if I read the book after seeing the film. At the moment I can’t actually think of any exceptions, though there are some, I’m certain of it. I understand that things must be cut out and I do often enjoy seeing a favorite story enacted on screen, but nothing compares to sitting down and reading through a book.
Only a day late … this week’s topic:
Discussion groups. Do you belong to any (besides Early Reviewers)? Approximately how many? Are there any in particular that you participate in more avidly? How often do you check?
I belong to a lot of groups on LT – the count is 26. I participate most actively and almost exclusively in the Green Dragon, my favorite place on LT, but I also like the 50 book challenge group and What are You Reading Now? and I tend to read and lurk in Happy Heathens the most. I check multiple times a day – I am an LT addict! I am mostly a lurker though, being somewhat shy, but I do always feel more comfortable posting there than almost anywhere else on the internet. The atmosphere is wonderful and who could ask for more than a community that loves books?
Vantrease returns to the family of Kathryn and Finn with this sequel to The Illuminator, set in the early 15th century and opening with a book burning in Prague. Finn and his granddaughter Anna, the subject of the book, live in Bohemia and continue to carry on the heretic religion. Anna is forced to flee to France, where she meets a mercy seller, also known as a pardoner. They will change each other’s lives more than they would think possible at the moment of their meeting as they journey from France to England, the country where the Lollard movement began and remains very strong.
This book is better than The Illuminator without question. The characters are more fleshed out and their reactions are very believable. Vantrease’s writing has improved and so has her plotting. This is good historical fiction, filling in the gaps of history, as I have mentioned before. She plays a little with Sir John Oldham and the identity of a certain Master Fisher, but explains everything in the back of the book, which I always appreciate. The subject matter, similarly, is very interesting, especially seeing the divergence between “Roman Christians” and Lollards – I think most of us would now agree with the Lollards, and the book certainly tilts in their sympathy, but it is still an interesting viewpoint. Anna was my favorite character as she attempted to forge her own way forward without everyone she loved.
In conclusion, I enjoyed this work of historical fiction and I would certainly recommend it to someone else.
What a wonderful book. Imriel realizes he is devastatingly attracted to Sidonie, Queen Ysandre’s oldest daughter and heir. As the two begin a torrid affair, Imriel struggles with his identity yet further as he is forced to marry the Queen’s niece and comes to some realizations that develop his character much, much further.
This is a great book. I was never bored, and sometimes the Kushiel books do drag if not much is happening. Imriel’s development is believable and progresses exactly how I would have hoped. He’s turned into a great character and even better, Carey has given him his own voice, very distinct from Phedre’s. Imriel has become a very admirable man. Phedre and Joscelin remain on the sidelines of the book, yet still retain hints of their former greatness and splendor. Plot develops apace and even in unexpected ways. Carey’s writing remains beautiful and exactly to my taste, although I do admit that some people would call it on the purple side of things.
All in all, a terrific absorbing book, so good that I’ve already preordered Kushiel’s Mercy.
|
|
Recent Comments