November 2008
S M T W T F S
« Oct   Dec »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

Review: The Greatest Knight, Elizabeth Chadwick

I think many of us who read a lot of historical fiction hear about Elizabeth Chadwick.  Her books are not available to Americans except through imports, which is a shame, and quite strange considering how popular historical fiction is these days.  Anyway, usually the one we hear about most is The Greatest Knight, the fictionalized life story of William the Marshal, one of medieval England’s most fascinating knights. I saw it at the library and just couldn’t resist despite my staggering TBR piles.

As a small child held hostage by King Stephen, William nearly loses his life when his father breaks his agreement with the king and switches allegiances.  After all, William is only his fourth son.  Stephen, not a strong king nor a hard man, chooses not to kill William and lets him go, but impresses on him the importance of loyalty and honor.  At first, an adult William struggles to make himself known, but his extraordinary talent and aforementioned loyalty speak for him and he earns a place in the Plantagenet household, eventually training and serving Henry the Young King, eldest surviving son of Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine.  As his star rises, William’s life and fortunes are shaped by this most powerful family.

William the Marshal is a fascinating historical character and I think Elizabeth Chadwick has done him justice here.  He certainly stuck with his loyalties in an age where many men switched allegiance to suit themselves; his father is a very good example, as are the sons of Henry II.  As such, William truly stands out from the crowd, and he lived an extraordinary life in the shadow of five kings.  As a result, in most places Chadwick doesn’t need to embellish the history, it’s a great tale as the chroniclers tell it.  So for the most part, she sticks to it.  She adds mainly a mistress, as we can assume that most well off knights had mistresses, and some story continuity, which works fairly well.  You can still tell a little bit that she got her start in romance when William develops love interests, but this book is clearly beyond that and stands as a really good work of historical fiction.  It isn’t the best I’ve ever read, but it is a worthy read.

I’m definitely looking forward to reading the sequel, The Scarlet Lion, which I conveniently enough have on my bookshelf.  I would recommend this to other historical fiction lovers, it is a very solid and compelling work.  Buy it on Amazon UK.

Share

Tuesday Thingers: Multiples

ttToday’s question: Work multiples. Do you own multiple copies of any books? Which ones? Why? Can you share your list?

I don’t own many multiples, at least not listed in LT. Here are the ones under my statistics:

  1. Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy (Norton Critical Edition (2004), Paperback)
    Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy (Penguin (Non-Classics) (2004), Paperback, 864 pages)
    Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy (Signet Classics (2002), Paperback, 960 pages)
  2. Abhorsen by Garth Nix (Eos (2004), Paperback, 528 pages)
    Abhorsen by Garth Nix (HarperCollinsChildren’sBooks (2005), Paperback, 400 pages)

I have my original paperback copy of Anna Karenina, a copy in Russian (which is hardcover and not catalogued properly), and a Norton critical edition because the professor required that one and my original copy was at home anyway.  I thought that was my only multiple, but I see that I also have two copies of Abhorsen.  I bought one on my own, and my boyfriend bought me the second one because he thought I’d like it without realizing that I already had it.  The days before LT, of course.

I also have two versions of Harry Potter and the Sorceror’s Stone that I haven’t catalogued.  I’ve listed one, of course, my original paperback.  My mom gave me that in my beat-books-up days and thus it has been bent, stained, and dog-eared beyond belief, so I got a new hardcover sometime last year.  I think between us my fiance and I have at least one duplicate, but he doesn’t have many books and he’s not buying at all now that he has my collection to read from, so I don’t foresee that becoming a problem.

I keep all copies of the books I own. I remember which ones I have eerily well, so I don’t have any accidental duplicates. Mainly I keep the few I have for sentimental value. If I was going to buy duplicates on purpose, it would most likely be to acquire a better translation of foreign language books or if a special edition was released.

Do you own any book duplicates?

Share

The Sunday Salon on Monday

This weekend has been a good example of my blog rolling right along without me.  For those who were wondering why I didn’t leave any comments anywhere, why I didn’t announce a winner for my Paul of Dune giveaway, or why no Sunday Salon post appeared, it’s because I was at my fiance’s.  We were busy Saturday and I intended to get back on Sunday in time to do my giveaway post and report on what I’d been reading on the train.  Well, I got on the very crowded standing room only train Sunday evening, but it had gone about half an hour out of the station when it stopped.  And stood.  For an hour.  Then we heard the news; the train in front of us had struck and killed a person, so we would not be continuing on our route.  We went back to our originating station, which took another 45 minutes, and I decided that it wasn’t worth it to continue on to York.  I didn’t know how late the buses ran, nor what route I’d take to get there, and my ticket was still valid for the next day (today).  The train was still packed and I couldn’t imagine the new route taking any less than the four hours it was going to take in the first place, so now that we were two hours behind, I chose to head back to my fiance’s for the night.  I’m back in York now; today’s journey only took me three hours (not counting bus rides), although I have missed a class and my volunteering slot.  I think I’m forgiven after that, though.

Anyway, I am now a couple of days overdue for announcing the winner of the Paul of Dune contest.  The winner is lucky number one, Amanda at Life and Times of a “New” New Yorker!  I’ll be sending you an email shortly to get your address.  Congratulations!

On the train today I finally finished The Principessa by Christie Dickason.  Quite an exciting read; I’m glad Francis met his match, just like Christie promised in her interview!  Expect a review soon; in the meantime, I liked it.

The rest of today will be spent preparing for the rest of the week rather than reading; hopefully I can get enough done to accomplish some goals this week and catch up on all the blog posts I missed.  I failed miserably last week, so at this point it will be all I can do just to keep the reviews coming.  Have a good week, everyone!

Share

Review: Victory of Eagles, Naomi Novik

temeraire5On his fifth adventure, Temeraire and his captain, Will Laurence, have been separated.  Laurence has been convicted of treason and is due to hang, while Temeraire is in a breeding ground to sire more Celestials for the English cause.  Both are in despair, but as the situation grows dire with regards to France, they are once again called upon to serve their country – together – by fighting the French.I still really love the relationship between Temeraire and Laurence.  I think it’s my favorite part of these books.  They are so fond of each other, but their relationship feels very 18th century English to me; it’s a restrained affection, obviously there but subdued in the public eye.  In any case, I like it and I think their devotion to each other raises their appeal as characters.

The last couple of Temeraire books were not as enchanting as the first two, especially the first one, and I considered giving up on the series; I got this one from the library, mostly because I saw it and I thought that it would be nice to find out what was happening without having to buy it.  So I was pleased to find that some of the spark is back; this book has a greater emotional depth to it as Laurence is constantly struggling with his honor and what “the right thing” is.  He’s disgraced and shamed and it’s a difficult time for him.  In addition, his lost love Edith emerges again in this story, so it feels like his character is filling out as the series goes on.  The return of the setting to Britain helps as well.  Many of Temeraire and Laurence’s friends are back and can play a greater role in their lives, and besides that they seem to fit better in this setting.  Perhaps that’s just my own affection for England speaking, but I do enjoy the story more here rather than the exotic locations.  That’s unfortunate as I believe they’re moving once again in the next of the series.

I’m not sure I’d recommend starting out with the series; it’s certainly enchanting, but there is no sign of its ending and a few of the books are difficult to get through with no reward as yet.  I think, however, that Novik is getting better as a writer and if you’ve read this far already, you might as well continue. Check it out on Amazon.

Share

Review: Her Only Desire, Gaelen Foley

For a while, Gaelen Foley was my number one favorite romance novelist.  The first book of hers that I read was Prince Charming and I immediately fell in love with it.  I believe I’ve read it about 8 times now, which might just be my record.  It’s a comfort read at this point, but when I read it the first time it was new and exciting and I felt for the characters in a way I hadn’t experienced before.  Lady Daniela Chiaramonte was a heroine unlike most of the ones I had read about and the plot and the romance were both very exciting.  I can still see some of the scenes from the book in my head.  I’m not sure if I’d feel this way if I read it again – it’s been several years now – but Gaelen Foley has never matched that level for me again.  She doesn’t do it with Her Only Desire, either, but it’s easily as good as many of the historical romances out there.

Miss Georgiana Knight, raised in India, is wary of men.  She has spent too much time reading her aunt’s little book on men and marriage.  Her aunt, however, was the Hawkscliffe Harlot, the most infamous member of the Hawkscliffe family, giving birth to a number of illegitimate children; so it’s difficult to imagine that her views on matrimony should be trusted.  Georgiana thinks they are, until she meets Ian Prescott, the marquess of Griffith, who despite being anti-marriage himself, convinces her to give romance a try.

I enjoyed this book, but I would say it’s about average for a romance.  The characters are spunky, but at least Georgiana is anachronistic and has very modern viewpoints.  It’s very hard to imagine that a girl raised in India, surrounded by Islamic best friends, does not understand how these Muslim girls feel about their religion.  Perhaps she does not approve of their decisions, but the way she behaves is unrealistic.  She is an engaging girl, but I don’t see her as fitting in with the period.  Nor does the language fit in, though, as she constantly calls Ian a “bad boy” and every so often the prose would slip and I’d be jolted out of the story.  I liked Ian a bit better, as he at least fits in with his time period and is properly ashamed of unorthodox behavior.

I didn’t really believe in the love story, but as so often in these books, it happens too fast for me to believe it’s anything but lust.  The couple goes through a lot together, but I didn’t see a compelling reason that I should root for them to remain together.

That’s not to say I didn’t enjoy the book, because I did.  I found the plot moderately interesting and I liked the appearance of characters I recognized from the rest of the Knight Miscellany books.  I never wanted to put the book down.  I do feel, however, that there is a reason people say the Spice Trilogy (of which this is the first book) is not as good as Foley’s previous efforts, because this is not.  If you’re looking for a good place to start, go with the Ascension Trilogy or The Duke, both of which I really enjoyed.

Check it out on Amazon.

Share