June 2008
S M T W T F S
« May   Jul »
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

The Pale Horseman, Bernard Cornwell

I love Bernard Cornwell.  There is no better way to put it!  I have really, really enjoyed every book of his that I’ve read so far.  He just captures what I imagine to be the medieval atmosphere so well, and beyond that his books are engaging and engrossing.  It’s not a surprise that I’ve basically fallen in love with what I’ve read of the Saxon Chronicles then because I am already fascinated by Anglo-Saxon culture, especially the clashes with Vikings, and that is what this series is all about, featuring some of my favorite historical figures.

This book, the second in the Saxon Chronicles, documents Alfred’s flight into the marshes and his difficult struggle out of it.  Uhtred, the Northumbrian lord, finds himself bound to assist Alfred even though he’d rather be a Dane, and thus plays a pivotal (though fictional) role in taking England back for the “English”.  In the meantime, he falls out of love with his wife and in love with someone else, explores more of the British Isles, and begins to grow up a little.

Amusingly enough, after that, I don’t know what to say!  I always find it harder to review books that I really like. When reading this, I just get swept up in the battle passion of it, perhaps my only glimpse of what it’s like to be a “warrior”, and it’s not all glorious, and maybe that’s what I like best about these books.  Cornwell doesn’t bother with romanticizing much of anything, certainly not compared to other historical fiction authors out there.  His plot moves along swiftly and the climax of it in this book is terrific and left me so engrossed that I immediately rushed out and bought the next at my first opportunity.  I love how his characters are growing and changing, particularly Uhtred, the main character – he grows up right before the reader’s eyes and his experiences change him.  Even Alfred changes and learns.

One pitfall remains – the Christians among us may find Cornwell’s derogatory attitude towards early Christians offensive, but I find it useful to remember that Christianity has changed vastly since the 9th century and nothing he says can really apply to today’s Christians.

I definitely recommend this book!  There is nothing better, aside from reading period literature, to put you right in the shoes of an Anglo-Saxon. Buy this book from Amazon.

Share

The Aviary Gate, Katie Hickman

Elizabeth Staveley is a graduate student working on escape narratives when she comes across mention of Celia Lamprey, who may have been the first known English girl to be sold into a Turkish harem.  After her discovery, the story intertwines the narrative of Elizabeth, who struggles with modern day love, with Celia’s, who longs to escape the harem and be reunited with her love, Paul Pindar.

I really enjoyed Celia’s story.  I found the environment of the harem fascinating and the political machinations inside of it were intriguing and added to the mystery.  I didn’t expect at all what would happen and remained just as clueless as Celia, if not more so, which I always like.  It was clear that this was an intricate, self-contained world; I even more enjoyed the backstory of some of the girls, particulary the Valide Sultan’s.  I found it to be very good historical fiction.

I did not enjoy Elizabeth’s story as much.  I think the author, Katie Hickman, was going for something like The Secret History of the Pink Carnation, but it doesn’t work here.  For one thing, Elizabeth’s life is too melodramatic and that takes away from the story.  She seems barely interested in Celia and makes discoveries only after the reader has encountered them, so as a result her chapters drag as we wait for her to make some discovery or feel sensual or sleep with someone (although having a romantic interest named Mehmet made the crusades historian inside me very happy for purely silly reasons).  I don’t think they added to the book, and in all honesty it would have worked a lot better without them at all.  I liked Hickman’s message, that history speaks to us even now, but overall, not worth it.

I’d wait for this one in paperback.  I enjoyed it, but there is better out there.  Still interested?  Check out The Aviary Gate: A Novel on Amazon now.

Share