|
|
When she was in college, Comfort Shields met another student named Ben, a man who’d been in the navy and only returned to school at age 24. They began a relationship and fell in love. Eighteen months later, Ben killed himself. This memoir details their relationship alongside Comfort’s struggle to survive herself, to grow and learn from the experience, and forgive herself, with which she still struggles.
I wasn’t sure I was going to like this book when I heard about it. My brother passed away when I was nineteen, and I avoid the subject of death far more than the average person my age. It’s still too close to me. I took a chance, and I’m glad I did. Comfort’s struggle is oddly empowering for her and for the reader, whom she has chosen to allow into her world. This beautiful memoir succeeds as both a story of her grief and her recovery and as a tribute to Ben, who struggled so much himself. Shields writes well and clearly, telling us her story in a way that makes her sympathetic while making it clear that she doesn’t expect any. Despite the difficult subject, the book isn’t hard at all to read and is in fact engrossing. Her struggle and the situation is clearly sad, but it is focused on the positive, not the negative. It is a book full of hope and memories.
The reader watches as the relationship between Ben and Comfort is strained by his mental illness, even though they so obviously love each other and she tries so hard to keep them together. The parts when they were falling in love were extremely touching, knowing the outcome of the relationship, experiencing this dual journey.
I found the most poignant and important lesson that Comfort learned is that she could not control the life of anyone else. She could not have saved Ben; it was out of her hands and she did the best she could. She discovers this over and over again throughout the course of her life, and not only is it true for her, it’s true for us all. Her journey is inspiring and I can imagine it giving hope and help to not only people whose loved ones have killed themselves, but to anyone who has lost someone and does not know where to go next.
—-
I have one copy of Surviving Ben’s Suicide to give away. It’s a bit of a strange book to get excited about a contest for, considering the subject matter, but this book is so wonderful and touching that I want to spread it around and get it known! There are only two copies of this book on LibraryThing, and there should be many more. This book could be so helpful, and people are missing out. Help me share Comfort’s story, and the memory of Ben, with the world.
So. It’s easy to be entered. All you have to do is leave a comment here. If you post about this on your blog, I’ll give you an extra entry. This is actually my first giveaway, so please, enter away! You have until Sunday, July 13th to enter, and I will mail the book on Monday, July 14th. Good luck!
Arthurian legend is a favorite subject of mine. I took a class on it close to three years ago and having the history has made all subsequent reading much more enjoyable. This book is the first in a trilogy which I think is about Merlin. This book certainly is. It goes into his childhood and his background as the bastard of a Welsh princess, Niniane, who will tell no one who his father is. Merlin discovers that he has some magical skills as well as foresight occasionally, and for these reasons he is almost never afraid because he knows that it is not yet his time to die. Eventually, he is ostracized from his home and joins the Roman king of Britain, Ambrosius, as he goes to conquer the proud tyrant Vortigern.
I like that Stewart tried vaguely to fit this into the confines of history while making it fantasy. Makes it a bit more interesting, although if anyone actually believes that the Saxons could muster an army of thirty thousand, I’m sorry, it just didn’t happen. I didn’t let that affect me too much, though, as I tried to consider this primarily a work of fantasy, which it really is. Magic happens and often around Merlin, and sometimes he prophesizes without knowing what he’s saying, which adds some small amounts of mystery. The plot is interesting and keeps moving, no dull moments that I noticed. Stewart’s writing is serviceable for the tale she’s telling. You can also see the beginnings of the proper Arthurian legend by the end, which makes me look forward to the next book so that I can continue the story.
After reading this book, I definitely wanted to read the next one, and I’ve grown very attached to Merlin. Even though he is a bit detached as a person from most of the other characters, watching him grow up has fostered that feeling in me at least. I’ll be looking for the rest of the trilogy. Buy this book on Amazon.
In this installment, Uhtred finally manages to journey north in an attempt to take his home, Bebbanburg, back from his uncle, and to kill the murderers of his adopted Danish family. He also goes through some more adventures, most of which he hasn’t expected, but in the end returns to Alfred as it seems he will always do.
This one dragged a little at the beginning, and especially during Uhtred’s time as a slave. It was interesting to see how slaves were used at the time, but mostly it was just depressing and uncomfortable to read. I’ve never liked to read about slavery, although I know how important it is to be aware of its atrocities, it’s just one of my things. On the other hand, this lasted about 100 pages, then Uhtred is reunited with his friends and the story really takes off again.
It was nice to see Uhtred in the north again. I have a particular fondness for the north of England, York in particular, which may be why I’m going to grad school there in the fall, so I’m always happy when it turns up in fiction. Cornwell remains a great writer, his battle scenes especially leaping off the page and feeling real. I enjoyed this book, and when it was over I immediately wanted the next in the series. Unfortunately it’s only available in hardcover, so I’ll be waiting for the paperback. I definitely recommend this entire series!
Interested in this series? Start with The Last Kingdom. If you’re interested in this book, why not check it out on Amazon?
This was a wonderful book. Ren is a little boy who has spent his life so far at Saint Anthony’s with other orphaned or abandoned boys. Sometimes they’re adopted, sometimes they’re not, and when they aren’t, they are recruited into the army. Ren is different, though, because he is missing one of his hands, and that makes it a challenge for him to be adopted. After a rejection, Ren is “lucky” enough to be adopted by a man who declares himself Ren’s brother. The monks don’t ask many questions and off they go, only for Ren’s happy bubble to evaporate when Benjamin Nab turns out to not be his brother, but a thief who intends to use Ren as bait in his schemes. It’s up to Ren to make the best of his new situation as he searches for his past and a family that will love him the way he deserves.
I really loved this book. Compelling narrative, great characters, interesting and varied settings. This is a little boy’s search to belong, and Ren is a truly wonderful and adaptable boy, with just enough naughty boy in him to make him interesting! I enjoyed watching him interact with everyone else, like the entertaining landlady and Benjamin’s drunken partner Tom. Benjamin Nab is another fascinating character, and only at the end do you realize what a marvelous web the author has been spinning around you the entire time. The plot is well-paced and it’s hard to imagine the outcome, and although parts of it seem like they should have been obvious from the start, they aren’t at all. It’s easy to keep on reading and forget that time has passed because the author’s narrative is so engaging.
In my opinion, this is a book to fall in love with, and I can easily imagine myself reading it over and over again. For once, all the reviews plastered on the cover are entirely correct – this book is enchanting, sweet, clever, absorbing, and haunting. I highly recommend it!
The Good Thief will be released on August 26th. Pre-order this book from Amazon today!
I’ve had a very good reading month, I’ve liked nearly everything that I’ve read! This is very unusual. Well, not that unusual, since I tend to know what I like, but I’ve started acquiring ARCs, which makes everything a bit more uncertain since I normally read less about these before I get them. See links for reviews!
Literary Fiction
The White Mary, Kira Salak
The House on the Strand, Daphne du Maurier
Aberrations, Penelope Przekop
Historical Fiction
Roma, Steven Saylor
Year of Wonders, Geraldine Brooks
The Firemaster’s Mistress, Christie Dickason
A Bloody Field by Shrewsbury, Edith Pargeter
The Aviary Gate, Katie Hickman
The Pale Horseman, Bernard Cornwell
The Good Thief, Hannah Tinti
The Lords of the North, Bernard Cornwell
Fantasy
Kushiel’s Mercy, Jacqueline Carey
The Crystal Cave, Mary Stewart
Romance
Castaway Hearts, Nancy Butler
Outlander, Diana Gabaldon
History
John Adams, David McCullough
The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher, Kate Summerscale
Definitely a good reading month, in other words! I’m surprised by how much my taste is turning into historical fiction these days. I feel that I was reading a lot more fantasy at the beginning of the year, but now that I’ve graduated university, I need some semblance of history to keep me going until grad school in the fall.
My favorite book of the month … difficult choice! I’ll have to pick one fiction, one non-fiction, both of which were five-star books for me:
Kushiel’s Mercy, Jacqueline Carey
I just loved this book. I have now noticed from other people’s reviews that my feelings are not universally shared, and while I can sometimes see their point, in all honesty, I was thrilled with it and I could not put it down. I have to see if my opinion stands through a reread, but that probably won’t be for quite some time. In any case, definitely my favorite fiction choice of the month. Buy this book from Amazon.

John Adams, David McCullough
This is exactly, in my opinion, what a biography should be. Brings a man perfectly, almost effortlessly, to life, providing us with his virtues and his vices in equal measure, all the while with engaging, clear text. I’d really recommend it for anyone interested in history, even those who don’t read history normally, because it’s easy to read, informative, and utterly fascinating. Buy this book from Amazon.
Review
Aberrations by Penelope Przekop traces a pivotal period in the life of Angel Duet, a narcoleptic twenty-one-year old with an extremely dysfunctional family and a non-existent social life. Enter Tim and Kimmy, Angel’s co-workers with their own oddities, who together propel Angel into a new and confusing world that changes her outlook forever and for good.
I didn’t know much about narcolepsy on starting this book and I was surprised by how deteriorating and upsetting it can be. No one seems to understand Angel’s condition and her desire to escape it is so great that she turns to drugs as a refuge. The illness drives people away from her and causes them to think that she is lazy, stupid, or retarded, when really she is a clever girl who longs to be normal. I really felt for Angel throughout the book and I wanted her to get that normal life, or at least a semblence of it. Her search for family, particularly mother, was extremely moving. The book also deals with the side issue of homosexuality in the 1980’s South – Tim is gay, as are two of his cousins. We get an interesting glimpse into their underworld as well as their struggle with “ordinary” people who attempt to suppress all that is different.
Another thing this book handles well is relationships. Angel has few relationships at the start of the book – her adulterous liason with Mac, a married doctor, and her confused relationship with her father. She develops friendships with Kimmy and Tim, sexual relations with one of Tim’s cousins, and her relationships with her father and especially his girlfriend Carla progress in believable ways.
For a short book, under 300 pages, this book packs in a lot! I really enjoyed it and I found myself deeply involved in the characters’ lives. Przekop brings up many sensitive issues, but in a way that causes the reader to think and consider them in a new light. I’d highly recommend this book to anyone who would like to read a deeply affecting, well-written, engrossing novel.
Interview
Q. Why narcolepsy? The characters each had their own flaws and I was wondering why narcolepsy was your focus, rather than, say, sexual orientation.
A. A focus on sexual orientation as opposed to narcolepsy would have resulted in quite a different book, I think. They are both important topics that many people have trouble relating to; however, when planning the book, my initial interest in narcolepsy led me to focus on it due to its unique metaphorical capabilities. Lots of books have been written about sexual orientation. Perhaps the BIG one that breaks a glass ceiling and remaining barriers has yet to be written, which is certainly an interesting challenge. It just seemed to me that the time was ripe for narcolepsy and I felt compelled to tackle it. Narcolepsy continues to be commonly used as comedic relief. I suspected that it wasn’t actually funny for those who suffered from it, and thought it might be rewarding to tell their story. I do think there are a lot of similarities between how Angel and Tim felt, which also speaks to the universal emotions we all have regarding whatever it is we must deal with as individuals. When other people fail to understand us, or when we fail to embrace ourselves, it touches a common place. I hope readers will take that away from the novel, and that it will making a lasting positive impression.
Q. Your characters seem as though I could meet them on the street tomorrow, particularly Angel. Do you ever draw them from people you know, or are they entirely products of your own imagination?
A. There is a bit of myself in each character that I create. Aside from that, I toss in bits and pieces of people I’ve known or currently know. Then on top of all that, I make things up. It’s like putting in all in a pot, swirling it around, (cooking it up) and then seeing what results once you’re ready to eat. Of course, I do this in the context of the overall point of the book. I create the types of characters that will propel the story I have in mind.
Q. Why did you choose to have the characters speak with Southern accents? I really appreciated this choice, by the way, because it helped a lot to keep me grounded in the setting.
A. Well, you would not believe how many times I went back and forth with this. I think I went through the entire book three or four times, adding it in and taking it out. I’m actually adding it back into my first, unpublished novel now. So I’m glad you liked it! I like it for the very reason you’ve noted. My goal was to include just a touch of it to help convey the setting. I think too much of that sort of thing can distract readers. When I’m writing, it also helps me to keep focused in that setting as well. It also has helped me write more realistic dialogue, I think, because having grown up in the South, it’s closer to how I actually speak. I conjure up conversations in my head and that’s how they comes out on paper. The new novel that I’m planning will likely have only one southern character so there will be much less of it.
Q. This may be a bit naive to ask, but did many places like The Blue Flower exist? Do you know of any real ones that I could research, just out of curiosity?
A. I did go to a similar place in Shreveport a couple of times when I was in college but it wasn’t called The Blue Flower. I can’t recall the name of it but part of my description was based on my experience there. I made up all the stuff about the flowers. Other than that, most of the places in the book are real places. The other clubs mentioned were real although I don’t know if they’re still open for business now. The Kon Tiki is still open in Shreveport. And of course, Louisiana State University in Shreveport is thriving.
Q. I’m not a doctor, but there was a lot in the book about Angel’s narcolepsy as well as about another character’s mental condition. Do you do much research before starting to write a novel, or only as you go along?
A. I did the majority of the research prior to writing the book. However, I continued to learn as much as I could as I was writing. I wanted to learn about narcolepsy from people who suffered from it rather than medical textbooks so I read a lot of Internet message boards. At the time, the Internet was just taking off so there wasn’t as much information available as there is now. I emailed with several college students who had narcolepsy to ask questions. One girl in particular read passages I wrote to tell me if they were realistic. That was extremely helpful.
Q. Betty Lou’s cloud photography is extremely important to the narrative and to Angel’s life. What would you say these clouds
symbolize for her?
A. They essentially symbolized mother to her. Mother found everywhere, if you think about it, because each cloud was shaped like something ordinary or familiar. And they were soft, beautiful, and overshadowing. Lastly, they were always there.
Q. And a purely personal interest question – are you working on another novel? I really enjoyed this one and I’d love to have another to look forward to!
A. Yes! I’m so excited about it and can’t wait to get further into it. Right now I’m doing a little editing on my first, unpublished novel currently titled, Jesus Wept. (Publishers often change titles.) If all goes well, Jesus Wept will be the next one on the shelves. Like Aberrations, it also includes numerous themes. It delves into the intense conflicts that can result from growing up in the Bible Belt while trying to relate to the tough realities of life. It’s not a religious novel but rather one that takes a realistic look at the complex role that fundamentalist religion, in particular, can play as we struggle to find a reality we can believe in and embrace as young adults–which is what we all go through in some form or another. So, my third novel is the brand new one that I’m currently planning. I don’t have a title yet but I’ve completed the majority of the research and will soon be at it full speed ahead. I don’t want to say too much about it since it’s in such an early stage. I can tell you that there will be a southern character in New York City, and it will compare and contrast current corporate politics with the ideals of Ellis Island while packing in numerous universal themes. I’m excited about blending my southern background and my own corporate experience to tackle this one.
Thanks so much, Penelope, for answering my questions, and thanks also to T.J. Dietderich for arranging this! For more information, see Penelope’s website and her blog. Aberrations comes out tomorrow, but you can buy this book from Amazon today!
I love Bernard Cornwell. There is no better way to put it! I have really, really enjoyed every book of his that I’ve read so far. He just captures what I imagine to be the medieval atmosphere so well, and beyond that his books are engaging and engrossing. It’s not a surprise that I’ve basically fallen in love with what I’ve read of the Saxon Chronicles then because I am already fascinated by Anglo-Saxon culture, especially the clashes with Vikings, and that is what this series is all about, featuring some of my favorite historical figures.
This book, the second in the Saxon Chronicles, documents Alfred’s flight into the marshes and his difficult struggle out of it. Uhtred, the Northumbrian lord, finds himself bound to assist Alfred even though he’d rather be a Dane, and thus plays a pivotal (though fictional) role in taking England back for the “English”. In the meantime, he falls out of love with his wife and in love with someone else, explores more of the British Isles, and begins to grow up a little.
Amusingly enough, after that, I don’t know what to say! I always find it harder to review books that I really like. When reading this, I just get swept up in the battle passion of it, perhaps my only glimpse of what it’s like to be a “warrior”, and it’s not all glorious, and maybe that’s what I like best about these books. Cornwell doesn’t bother with romanticizing much of anything, certainly not compared to other historical fiction authors out there. His plot moves along swiftly and the climax of it in this book is terrific and left me so engrossed that I immediately rushed out and bought the next at my first opportunity. I love how his characters are growing and changing, particularly Uhtred, the main character – he grows up right before the reader’s eyes and his experiences change him. Even Alfred changes and learns.
One pitfall remains – the Christians among us may find Cornwell’s derogatory attitude towards early Christians offensive, but I find it useful to remember that Christianity has changed vastly since the 9th century and nothing he says can really apply to today’s Christians.
I definitely recommend this book! There is nothing better, aside from reading period literature, to put you right in the shoes of an Anglo-Saxon. Buy this book from Amazon.
Elizabeth Staveley is a graduate student working on escape narratives when she comes across mention of Celia Lamprey, who may have been the first known English girl to be sold into a Turkish harem. After her discovery, the story intertwines the narrative of Elizabeth, who struggles with modern day love, with Celia’s, who longs to escape the harem and be reunited with her love, Paul Pindar.
I really enjoyed Celia’s story. I found the environment of the harem fascinating and the political machinations inside of it were intriguing and added to the mystery. I didn’t expect at all what would happen and remained just as clueless as Celia, if not more so, which I always like. It was clear that this was an intricate, self-contained world; I even more enjoyed the backstory of some of the girls, particulary the Valide Sultan’s. I found it to be very good historical fiction.
I did not enjoy Elizabeth’s story as much. I think the author, Katie Hickman, was going for something like The Secret History of the Pink Carnation, but it doesn’t work here. For one thing, Elizabeth’s life is too melodramatic and that takes away from the story. She seems barely interested in Celia and makes discoveries only after the reader has encountered them, so as a result her chapters drag as we wait for her to make some discovery or feel sensual or sleep with someone (although having a romantic interest named Mehmet made the crusades historian inside me very happy for purely silly reasons). I don’t think they added to the book, and in all honesty it would have worked a lot better without them at all. I liked Hickman’s message, that history speaks to us even now, but overall, not worth it.
I’d wait for this one in paperback. I enjoyed it, but there is better out there. Still interested? Check out The Aviary Gate: A Novel on Amazon now.
Richard Young, a man who finds himself strangely adrift without a job and spending the summer at his friend’s country house, makes trips through time to the fourteenth century with the aid of a drug supplied by said friend Magnus, a professor who dabbles on the side in strange experiments. While in the fourteenth century, he cannot tell what is happening in the real world although he wanders around it following Roger and is witness to a series of intrigues among the old families of the town, with which he becomes obsessed while his wife and stepsons are summarily ignored.
I picked up this book because I loved Rebecca and because it was two dollars. I figured it was time I read more of du Maurier’s work, and that desire has not dimmed, but I doubt this is a book I will be revisiting. It simply wasn’t that good. The plot was slow to take off and once it did, it didn’t bring any revelations. All of the characters remain strangely detached from the reader, which makes it extremely hard to care if Dick gets hit by a car while he’s wandering around seeing things in a different time. Now, I love medieval England, so that should probably tell you that it’s sad that this book didn’t interest me. There just wasn’t much to the time travelling. There are some intrigues, illnesses, and murders, but nothing special and nothing to really explain why Dick (or we) should be so enthralled by his travels, perhaps because we never actually care about the people he seems to care so much about. The contrasting landscapes are really interesting, considering that type of thing exists all across England and other places, but are only mentioned a few times when they’re relevant to the plot.
Eventually, du Maurier does pick up the pace and it gets much more interesting once Dick’s real life starts to get a bit chaotic, and I think the end was actually brilliant, but it’s very hard to get into and it’s very hard to stay attached to it. It’s entirely possible that it may have had too much science fiction type discussion revolving around the drug and its effects involved for me, and someone who actually enjoys science fiction wouldn’t mind as much. Maybe someone can tell me. In the meantime, I would recommend someone to give this book a try if he or she mentioned it, but not wholeheartedly, unless they liked science fiction.
A shocking murder occurred at Road in 1860. A little boy, Francis Saville Kent, was whisked from his bed in the middle of the night, and only found the next day with his throat cut, shoved down a privy and wrapped in a blanket from his bed. At the same time, a fever for investigation and detection has swept the country and every man and woman is intent on solving the crime, blaming everyone from Saville’s father to the nursemaid to the neighbors. When the local police fail to turn up anything, Jonathan Whicher is called in, a detective from London. His conclusions shock Victorian sensibilities, however, and he falls from grace, though the book continues to unravel the mystery in his absence.
In addition to solving the crime and proposing some final solutions to the mysteries involved, Summerscale also provides us with a very interesting cultural and social study of the mid to late nineteenth century. In detail, she describes the detective fervor, early crime cases, their influence on literature, and how the great Whicher himself inspired such literary figures as Sergeant Cuff in The Moonstone. This is easily the most interesting part of the book. The mystery feels solved one third of the way in, although the public isn’t convinced and it isn’t fully unravelled yet, but the interesting effect it has on the English view of detectives is certainly the best part of the book and worth reading just for that. In addition, Summerscale puts forth the new view of the middle-class home as a place of privacy and demonstrates how this case tore it wide open, making us realize just why Whicher’s conclusions were so objectionable. The effect of newspapers on all of this is striking and detailed.
The narrative flows along smoothly for the most part and doesn’t get boring or drag. There are some parts that don’t fit, in particular details of William’s biological work are simply dull and don’t reflect any of the book’s greater qualities, but they are few and mostly towards the conclusion of the book. The conclusion itself gets very interesting as Summerscale enters into her most interesting speculations about the true nature of the crime and the Kent family, so it is most certainly worth going through.
In the end, this was a really interesting read. Very informative and entertaining. I’m glad I read it and I’d recommend it to someone else, particularly someone interested in Victorian literature or history.
|
|
Recent Comments