|
|
It’s difficult to give a summary of this book, because a lot happens and very little of it seems to matter by the end. I’m not really sure what Sarah Monette thought as she wrote this. She probably intends to expand on a lot of the themes and hidden references in the next book. There is a lot that feels just tossed in, with no explanation, and definitions of words like septad definitely would have helped. I don’t mind if a book tosses me straight into a world if explanations are forthcoming, and here they’re not. In that way it reminded me of Gardens of the Moon by Steven Erikson; not in any other way though.
I spent about the first half of the book hating it. I hated Felix, everything was depressing, and I kept wondering when Mildmay and Felix were finally going to meet each other. It was driving me crazy, I felt like the book was going nowhere. I’m generally patient, but I can’t stand when the back of a book promises me something that isn’t forthcoming quickly, because to me that makes it a spoiler and ruins the experience. This book does that, and I kept wondering when the torture was going to end for various characters.
When Mildmay and Felix do meet, the book gets vastly better. The plot starts to move, things start happening, and more importantly, I get a sense of the characters’ feelings for the first time. Both had involved themselves in emotional entanglements beforehand, but only here did I feel like they were real people and start to care about them. We get to see more of the world – I didn’t like Melusine the city very much – and some resolution finally shows up, although nowhere near enough. I don’t know why the book doesn’t state that it is the first of a trilogy anywhere.
Also, there’s a lot of modern swearing and slang that doesn’t really fit in a pseudo-European world for me. I like when she makes up her own slang and I think it may have been better if she’d done more of that, or at least used fewer four-letter words. Mildmay’s sections got jarring at times because he swears so often.
Other than that, I actually liked the last hundred pages. I liked them a lot. They were really emotionally successful and finally got me into the story. Almost enough for me to get the next in the trilogy, but probably not for quite a while.
Ender’s Game is the story of essentially one child, Andrew “Ender” Wiggin. Ender has two older siblings, but they are too polarized for his important task. In a very simple sense, one is vicious, the other peaceful, and only Ender strikes the right balance. Only he is recruited into battle school, and only he has a monumental task set before him.
I am not a science fiction person. The only science fiction stories I have ever managed to like are Star Wars and Firefly, both not books. Books get too technical, and in general I don’t like stories with aliens. Just personal preference.
With that out of the way, I had a shocking revelation. I liked Ender’s Game! I didn’t love it as everyone else on the planet seems to, but I genuinely liked it. Card’s clever children captivated me, and even though I found their abilities somewhat impossible for six-year-olds, I grew interested in their characters. I knew what it was to be isolated when young, how it makes character stronger, and so I could empathize with Ender, although I have no claims to his brilliance. I read a review that claimed he didn’t have any depth, Card never goes into his mind — I found the opposite to be true. I certainly saw into Ender’s mind, as he was manipulated into doing things he’d never have done otherwise, and especially in the phenomenal ending when he sets everything to rights.
I found the manipulation slightly horrifying, and was utterly relieved when “the twist” occurred. I enjoyed the fact that the story was simple and never got too complicated despite getting across several complex themes. I don’t really understand why it won two awards, I wouldn’t have rated it so highly myself, but then I don’t generally like science fiction so I’m probably not a fair judge.
It was the ending messages about culture and continuity that really got to me, and I think that therein lies a message we should all remember when we’re trying desperately to exterminate enemies that we don’t understand. When is any war any different from that?
Inkspell is a strange book. While Cornelia Funke has created a very enchanting Inkworld, she is perhaps too verbose. The book is very long, and while plenty of things happen, it seems too long. It doesn’t have as much appeal as Harry Potter to keep kids reading, in my opinion. I still really like the concept, and I also like the idea that the story can be changed while the characters are inside it, but my attention was not as captivated. The book is just too long – and I like long books!
The characters have grown on me, though. I really like reading about their further exploits, and I just love Dustfinger. He’s complex, in some ways, with his relationships with Resa and Roxane, and his affection for his children. He comes across as the most real of all the characters; the rest of them are sugar-coated.
*big spoiler*
It is true, though, that when Farid died, I nearly cried, and even more so when Dustfinger gave his life to bring Farid back. Utterly heartwrenching scene.
*end spoiler*
I also didn’t like how the book can’t really stand alone and the cliffhanger ending. I’m not a very big fan of cliffhanger endings even though I really enjoy series. I am definitely looking forward to Inkdeath, so I guess Cornelia Funke has drawn me in after all.
In Mistborn, Brandon Sanderson creates a dismal, dark world, peopled mostly with oppressed, down-trodden skaa slaves and a handful of high nobility. Main character Vin has a desperately hard life, but it doesn’t take long for her to learn that she has much more power than she expected, and become involved with a crew that threatens to overthrow the government and free the skaa.
This book is the first in a trilogy, which I’m happy to discover has actually been completed, though not entirely published. It serves as a complete story in itself and also a tantalizing introduction into the world. Sanderson’s characters are easy to care about and often playful despite their generally dire circumstances. The world is a fairly dark and depressing place, but the book’s message springs free of these constraints and lightens the entire story. Vin is a great character. Her personal transformation is very well done and very believable, which is always one of my favorite aspects of any book. I adore good character development, and Sanderson is good at it.
I also really liked the way the book was plotted. The hook is very successful and even the slower bits in the beginning about Allomancy all feel educational and not drawn out at all. Sanderson notes in his annotations that it may have been a bit slow, but I didn’t feel that at all. I was interested, because some of the scenes beforehand really made me wonder how the system worked.
Speaking of the magic system, it’s very original, logical AND creative. It made a lot of sense to me once it was explained and really enlivened the battle scenes.
Great book, I’m looking forward to the next.
I’m on the fence about this book. I liked the story it told, that of an obedient Bangladeshi wife discovering herself and what she, and not her husband or male family, wanted. There were aspects of it that I didn’t like, though.
I definitely disliked the grammatically incorrect letters that Hasina, Nazneem’s sister, sent her. I liked and was interested in Hasina, as she comes across as very strong despite her many setbacks in life, but did her letters really have to be so grating? It made her sound provincial, which may have been the point, but I don’t think much would have been lost if they could have been written in plain English like the rest of the book. Perhaps this is a flaw only I could balk at, since I can’t stand so many errors in one place, but I genuinely was irritated, especially when there was an entire chapter of them.
Monica Ali liberally sprinkles the book with symbolism. Everything means something. I can’t say whether this is good or bad, only that I did get tired of having to work out what everything meant just to understand the impact of the book. I suppose it depends what kind of reader you are. If I was to study this book, I could write essays on it and I’m sure I’d appreciate it much more if I analyzed it to the hilt, but that doesn’t make it pleasurable, precisely. I think this may be part of the reason the book has been universally lauded.
I also am not a huge fan of Ali’s writing. I can’t pinpoint where this bothered me, but it felt sloppy at times, hard to follow, in other words, not suitably absorbing or moving. Particularly when the love affair came along. I knew that she did not love him, and that he did not love her. It just felt wrong for them to be together, not at all the way that Nazneen was describing. I felt that their affair was unrealistic.
I did enjoy the peeks into Islam. I’ve forgotten what little I ever learned, and I really liked learning a bit more. I’m inspired to read further.
Take this review with a grain of salt; I am not a Muslim, I do not understand the attitudes and feelings of Muslim women. I can only speak of how I feel as a woman in general, and try to understand from that perspective. Nazneen becomes an admirable woman in the end, and for that her transformation is real and endearing, which is the true reason this book should be praised.
Andrew Bridgeford takes a deep look at the Bayeux Tapestry, its history, and potential interpretations of its content. He is extremely thorough in his assessment, laying it out in a logical sequence that makes his arguments very persuasive. It’s fairly obvious that he is a lawyer, since he spares no time for fanciful ideas and sticks to interpretations straight from the facts.
The part that I liked most about this was Bridgeford’s extensive use of primary sources. He pulls in plenty of Anglo-Saxon, Norman, and French chronicles, as well as various records and writing of other types. He does occasionally use the work of other historians, but I was very impressed with the depth of his research into the original chronicles. He links the tapestry with various contemporary accounts in an attempt to separate out the true thread of events as well as who may have created or paid for the tapestry and why. He takes an indepth look at various misunderstood aspects of the tapestry and postulates why they are they and what they could possibly mean. He even makes a suggestion as to the author of the Song of Roland.
Bridgeford’s strict use of facts and logic assists the reader in understanding his ideas and are a great support to him. His suggestions never seem implausible, even if they occasionally diverge from orthodox opinion. His footnotes and bibliography are extensive. Definitely a recommended book for anyone interested in 11th century medieval history.
Ephemera is a fragmented, strange world, each landscape different, and each person with the ability to travel to the landscape where his or her heart most resonates. In this world resides Sebastian, a half-incubus who feeds on sex, but who also longs for something more. Meanwhile, at the Landscapers’ School, a girl whose heart is tempted by the dark unleashes an ancient evil. Glorianna Belladonna, a “rogue” landscaper cast out by the school, is Ephemera’s only hope.
I liked this book. No one is ever going to call Anne Bishop an amazing writer, but her books are addicting and absorbing. This classifies as “dark” fantasy, probably because of the sexual themes, but I honestly didn’t find much dark in it, and instead embraced many heartwarming scenes and really wonderful characters. It’s slightly erotic, but not as much as the Black Jewels trilogy. I did find some characters’ transformations a little too abrupt, Lynnea’s in particular. I suppose that can be attributed to her inner personality finally emerging, but I think in real life it would have taken more than a day. I really did like her character, though, even if she was on the “too good to be true” side. I can forgive a few of those since the book embraces characters with both a light and a dark side, like Belladonna and Sebastian.
I liked very much that despite being half of a duology, this book had a definite climax and conclusion. The battle is not yet won, but there is a satisfaction to the ending that means I want to read the next book, but I don’t have to do it immediately. Convenient, since Belladonna is still only out in hardcover. This is something that I really enjoy in series books because it makes each feel both like an entire book and a part of a whole.
This is a book that I would highly recommend to fantasy fans, but not really to anyone else. It does show that the “light” is better, but there aren’t many merits beyond that a non-fantasy reader would enjoy, in my opinion. It is definitely very enjoyable in general though, a book that could easily become a comfort book.
Duchess covers much of the life of Sarah Churchill, Duchess of Marlborough. The book chronicles her friendship and influence with Anne Stuart from childhood to middle age, her relationship with her husband, and eventually their fall from grace.
Miss Sarah Jennings, thirteen, has very little money to her name thanks to her father’s gambling debts. She accepts a position in the Duchess of York’s household in order to earn money and get away from her mother. Through this position she meets Princess Anne and John Churchill, the two figures who are to have massive influence on the rest of her life.
I enjoyed that this book stayed extremely close to the actual recorded history. Wherever there is history, Ms. Scott does not mess with it and instead keeps to the books. Sarah’s life is well documented, so any errors would be blatantly obvious. She does an excellent job of portraying Sarah’s stubborn character. She is ambitious and she has plenty of flaws; she’s really out for no one but herself and her family, and in that she’s matched well by her husband. The fact that they rose from very minor players at court to have such great influence is astounding, and Scott shows this ambition and drive. I’m very satisfied by her Sarah Churchill, as I think she matches excellently the woman I’ve read about in various other sources.
I did think the idea that Sarah and Princess Anne were physically intimate a bit strange. I’d not seen that suggestion elsewhere, and considering the book mentions how hard it is to keep secrets in court, it doesn’t seem to fit. I am able to accept the theory though, since no one can ever know what happened between them when they were alone. It just seems off. It is true that they were very close, I just am not entirely comfortable with the idea that it led to sexual activity.
Overall I suspect Queen Anne may have suffered a bit, but I don’t really know much about her reign so I can’t comment. If anything, she was certainly very dependent on Sarah and later on Abigail Masham, as well as all her advisors, so perhaps this image of her is not entirely unfair.
The writing is good, no cultural errors or colloqualisms, everything is in line. It is fairly obvious at times that the author is a romance novelist, considering how she writes the romance between Sarah and John. Not that I mind much, considering their love was a huge part of Sarah’s life, and a romance novelist is well qualified to cover that. I think it’s a great achievement for Scott (also known as Miranda Jarrett) to step out of her genre and try this, and she does an excellent job. Sarah’s resistance to John’s wooing is expertly done.
The real Sarah Churchill was a phenomenal woman, seizing power for herself and her family in a time when no woman besides a sole reigning queen ever had any. I’m glad that she has a good fiction novel based on her life so she can become more accessible to the world at large.
This biography is probably among the worst that I have read. It reads like a novel, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but in this case, it fails to provide a convincing portrait of Josephine.
Carolly Erickson covers Josephine’s life from the great storm of her childhood in Martinique to her death. At times, her portrayal of Josephine as sweet, generous, grateful, and natural is at odds with the calculating promiscuous woman she also attempts to show. She doesn’t debate either view, but instead attempts to combine them and it comes out a bit strange. The book reads like a tabloid at times, not using Josephine’s own words but those of her observers. Josephine’s letters are occasionally used, but not often enough, especially when Erickson boldly states what Josephine was thinking or how she felt. As ostensibly history, I feel that a biography should state where these impressions are coming from, or if they’re the biographer’s imagining, since they are not fact. The sources are largely in French, which does make sense, but prevents me from researching further in order to discover the truth.
I found I didn’t like Erickson’s Josephine; despite protestations of strength she comes across as weak-willed, jealous, and whiny. That may well be how she was, but overall I didn’t like her much. I preferred Sandra Gulland’s Josephine, since while her trilogy is historical fiction, it uses more source material and provides a view of a Josephine harassed in every way but still true to herself, jealous but attempting to deal with her husband’s infidelity. That isn’t necessarily the truth either, but I preferred it. Also of note is the fact that Gulland maintains that Josephine never had the numerous affairs that Erickson ascribes to her. The evidence for these affairs is in fact scanty, and until more is found we’ll probably never know whether or not Josephine was loyal to Napoleon.
In addition, this book is only 350 pages long and doesn’t delve into any of the issues of the time, merely grazes over them in an attempt for a summary.
I think I will seek out a more scholarly account of Josephine since I don’t trust this one. I prefer a biography to be written more as a history, dealing with conflicting viewpoints and attempting to discern the truth, rather than a popular account that reads like a novel and challenges nothing. Very disappointing.
This is the third book in the Deverry series, which I believe has 11 or 12 books now. In short, not precisely a series to get involved with if you aren’t prepared for the long haul. As a big fan of Robert Jordan etc., it never bothers me when a series is long. It does bother me when the series seems to deteriorate in quality, because at that point I’m invested in the story and feel a need for completion, but don’t feel a desire to read the book.
Rhodry and Jill, my favorite characters, spend most of the book apart. Perryn drives me mad, and overall the story progresses but in a frustrating, bleak way. Nothing is going in a positive direction. There are no light moments, nothing to break the tension, something I’m getting increasingly tired of. There should be a balance to prevent a book from being too depressing, if you ask me, particularly if it’s fantasy, a genre (imo) not meant to be thoroughly depressing. Even the time interlude, a constant staple of the last two books, drifted off without any conclusion. The entire book was nothing but a relentless narrative with no cheer; everyone is always leaving everyone else, being frustrated, and going off to war.
To be honest, I’ve liked other negative books, but usually they’ll have some other quality to recommend them, such as excellent writing or compelling characters. I believed this series had potential in the first book, which I unexpectedly loved. The second was not as good, but still okay. This one was not. The writing was conventional and bland and the characters used the same absurd curses every few pages. The story has some potential, I have to say. It is interesting, but it’s mired down in bad writing and poor plotting. It is as though Katharine Kerr’s editor really went through the first book and made it excellent, and by now has simply given up and let her continue without any assistance.
At this point I’m not sure it’s worth it to continue with the series. I don’t like the cliffhanger, but I also don’t want to read 400 more pages of poor writing, plus however many volumes are left in the entire series.
|
|
Recent Comments