October 2007
S M T W T F S
« Sep   Nov »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  

The Brothers Karamazov, Fyodor Dostoevsky

How does one review such a book? The Brothers Karamazov is a personification of Russian culture, expressing so much about its history through fiction. There is the church, small village life, the Russian spirit, even the corruption which never fails to pervade government, the superfluous man – all central themes to Russia in the 19th century. The never-ending struggle of the nobles to find a place for themselves once they are no longer forced to serve reaches a climax in the character of Mitya Karamazov, who must deal with a father who will not give him his inheritance and a life which serves no purpose.

This translation, by Pevear and Volokhonsky, has been praised and awarded for its retention of Dostoevsky’s spirit and language, and for what it’s worth, I would agree. The novel is lively, with an edge of ridiculousness on top of the depression, and a final, somewhat uplifting message. Each brother is different and embodies a specific character, and the three are entangled with various other characters, creating a fascinating, multi-faceted whole. The plot has love triangles, mystery, and excitement enough to keep the reader going through as fast as possible.

It’s long, but worth it. Definitely recommended.

Share

The Road to Wigan Pier, George Orwell

The Road to Wigan Pier is composed of two separate parts: Orwell’s exploration of the working and unemployed classes and later on his examination of middle class prejudices and socialism. I enjoyed the first half of the book as information; Orwell’s writing is persuasive and interesting, though I can’t say I’d regard his reporting as entirely honest, given a comparison with the diary he kept while writing the book. I assume that he’s giving us a picture, anyway, that is characteristic of the times. His images of the times are certainly very fictive, which adds to the enjoyment, not the reality of the situation.

The second half was not nearly as interesting. I’m not sure if middle class British perceptions towards the working class have changed, but overall this is not exactly what I’m interested in. Much less am I interested in socialism and how it can be applied to the situation. Moreover, Orwell skirts the deep issues and portrays only the surface of each ideology. He never quite manages to explain how socialism will solve the problem, only that it will.

Overall, an interesting read, but not entirely reliable.

Share