|
|

Have you ever been a member of a book club? How did your group choose (or, if you haven’t been, what do you think is the best way to choose) the next book and who would lead discussion?
Do you feel more or less likely to appreciate books if you are obliged to read them for book groups rather than choosing them of your own free will? Does knowing they are going to be read as part of a group affect the reading experience?
I haven’t been in a book club since I was in sixth grade, when we read the books our group leader told us to read. Her name was Mrs. Lloyd and that’s about all I remember of that experience. I obviously don’t think this is the best way unless your group is full of 11 year olds and you are a school-based group, which is almost just a class anyway. I’d like to participate in a real-life book club, but I didn’t think until it was too late at my university and I’m not staying here with my parents long enough to join one here. I expect I’ll join one for real once I get out of graduate school.
I’m not sure how my ideal book club would operate. I think that if it’s a relatively small size, the club could rotate months and each month one person would both pick the book and lead the discussion. Otherwise, if it’s bigger than say 12 people, there would have to be a vote. That is my best guess, anyway. A book club with the book selected by just one of the people each time would probably not attract too many members.
I think if the discussion was valuable and the book was interesting, I might enjoy it more in a book club. I know that some of the books I’ve read for classes have been much more enjoyable thanks to discussion and analysis. I guess I will have to see and report back when I do join one, whenever that is!
It appears that I’m going to have a lot of time this summer until I leave for grad school in the fall. I haven’t managed to find a job, probably due to the economy and my location and my pesky sense of honesty about how long I’m going to be here, so I might as well embark on another challenge.
The 2008 Classics Challenge begins next month, on July 1st, and continues until December 31st. I don’t actually have that many unread classics, but I have enough for the rules of this challenge, which since I’m following option 1, are simple. I’m to read five classics, plus one “modern” classic of my choice, in the time given. My choices are:
My Antonia, Willa Cather
The Epic of Gilgamesh
The Mabinogion, Mair Jones
Adam Bede, George Eliot
Emma, Jane Austen
A Suitable Boy, Vikram Seth (as my modern classic)
That last one may change – I have a lot of the modern classic options, so it depends more on what I feel like at the moment! I would like to read it though, so it’s on there for now. In addition, rereads are allowed, so I might actually decide to reread Jane Eyre or The Age of Innocence (my favorite books) just because I can, but we’ll see! I’m looking forward to reading these books.
David McCullough breathes new life into one of America’s foremost patriots with this excellent biography. It does everything a biography should do – it covers every detail of Adams’ life, his family, his interactions, and his immense influence on early American government, and more importantly, it makes him feel like a real, fully fleshed out person. He and his wife Abigail jump out from the page in numerous excerpts from their letters to each other, with the situations elaborated upon by McCullough in strong, clear writing, which is never boring as he manages to make tedious issues of government understandable and even interesting.
What struck me is how little about Adams I had learned previously. The great patriots seem to always be Washington and Jefferson. Both are included in this biography, especially Jefferson, but are shaded in a different light. We objectively know that no one is perfect, but somehow the founding fathers escape our scrutiny. McCullough does not spare them, but neither does he spare Adams – he is merely showing us the men as they were. This makes them feel far truer than any high school history class that simply extols their virtues has ever done. Adams’ contributions to American independence are given full weight and consideration here and it is hard to understand just why we don’t admire him the same way we admire the other patriots. Perhaps because he was a stubborn man whose enemies attacked him to an extent no longer allowed in American politics? Perhaps because he occasionally lost his temper and made some attacks of his own? I don’t know, but I certainly admire him all the more after this refreshing biography. It’s clear he was a brilliant man, and McCullough displays this equally alongside his faults.
Would I recommend this biography? Yes! I think it’s essential reading for every American. Especially now, when we are embroiled in a frustrating war, it’s important for us to realize that it was not always this way and that men did fight for peace when it counted, like Adams did even though it lost him the presidency. This man should be given more credit than he is now – McCullough has convinced me. He should be up there with Jefferson and Washington for his contributions. This is a brilliant work of history and it most certainly deserves that Pulitzer.
Year of Wonders tells the story of a plague year and a village that shut itself off from the world through the eyes of Anna Frith, a widow with two small sons. Her sorrow grows as so many that she loves die from the plague, but she also comes to realize more about herself, her endurance, and what is truly important to her. This is the reason for the “wonders” in the title, since otherwise a year full of tending plague victims would not be anything near wonderful.
I enjoyed this book. I liked Anna’s interactions with Elinor, so characteristic of someone who has lost everything and thus clings on to the one thing she can have. Anna’s sorrow and growth were both so real. In truth, nearly everything in this book felt very human and very understandable. People’s reactions to losing their whole families result in fear, suspicion, and murder, especially in this time in history when so much could be blamed on a “witch”. Brooks writes well and draws you into this small community’s difficult and deadly year.
I think this book has value for every reader since it says so much about human nature – it goes beyond the historical fiction genre to convey meaning about suffering and understanding. I would certainly recommend it.
Today’s question is about tags- do you tag? How do you tag? How do you feel about tagging- do you think it would be better to have standardized tags, like libraries have standardized subject headings, or do you like the individualized nature of tagging? What are your top 5 tags and what do they say about your collection or your reading habits?
I like tags. I use them for myself, not really for the benefit of anyone else – I tag things like genre, subject, location, when I read the book, if I haven’t read it yet, and so on. I particularly like being able to sort my library by said tags, because I wouldn’t normally see all those books put together on the shelves, since I typically shelve in alphabetical order. I do sometimes tag a bit haphazardly. I have a tag “England” which is meant to be all books set in England, but I’m not always good about applying that and other location tags, for example. I like them, but I don’t generally have a long string of tags attached to each book, just 2 or 3.
I don’t think that standardized tags are necessary. When you click on a book, you can see the most common tags, which generally eliminates rare ones that aren’t useful to the wider population. I think user-generated tags are much more interesting than a bunch of standard ones.
As for my most common tags, they are fantasy (210), historical romance (178), historical fiction (156), england (140), and school (136). I do read a lot of fantasy and historical fiction. I think the historical fiction tag has probably experienced the most growth lately. The historical romance is a throwback to high school. England is basically my favorite country, and I have history and historical fiction mostly from there, so its presence in the top 5 is not unexpected. Lastly, the school tag is not surprising, as I’ve acquired plenty of books through classes, especially English classes.

Have your book-tastes changed over the years? More fiction? Less? Books that are darker and more serious? Lighter and more frivolous? Challenging? Easy? How-to books over novels? Mysteries over Romance?
My book tastes have changed quite a lot for someone as young as I am, or so I think. When I was younger, I read mostly YA novels, but I didn’t really have a specific focus, I just read whatever I could find, and usually multiple times. My first “adult” books were romance novels, mostly because that was what my mom read. After a short time, I specifically latched onto historical romance, mostly because I really love history and didn’t quite realize it at the time. In high school, I made a friend who recommended the Wheel of Time to me, and there began my love affair with fantasy novels. So, for a while, I was reading romance and fantasy pretty much exclusively, although I never really noticed that none of my favorite books were romance – I did notice that they got same-y after a while, though, and by the end of high school I was embarrassed to be reading them at all, so I stopped.
I went to college and barely read at all for the first year and a half, except for required reading for my English major and a few books over the summer. I was unhappy during most of this time, except while I was in England, and looking back I think losing my guaranteed “escape” made it a lot worse. My brother (my only sibling) passed away in December 2005 from non-Hodgkins lymphoma and I realized that I really needed to read again, so as a distraction I began my first ever list of how many books I read. Around this time I also realized that I really, really loved history, in particular medieval history, not only as a setting for romance novels but as a subject and as a setting for all sorts of other novels. This is a love that I suspect has existed all my life, because I recall that my favorite books from childhood were often either fantasy or set in medieval Europe. In 2006 I read 76 books, largely historical fiction and fantasy. At the end of 2006, I discovered LibraryThing, and my reading skyrocketed, because in 2007 I read 139 books, again mostly composed of historical fiction, fantasy, and history. So far, these have remained constant, although I have been introducing a bit more modern literature into my TBR piles ever since I read The Remains of the Day last year.
So, there is my reading history, long and complex and boring for everyone but me I’m sure!
On going through the lists for The Book Awards Challenge II, I realized that I really don’t read enough award winners. This is especially true considering some of the books on there are among my favorites. I also realized that I have 9 award winners on my unread pile (given that it is 100 books tall, this isn’t very many), so I think it is time to enroll in my first challenge.
The rules:
1. Read 10 award winners from August 1, 2008 through June 1, 2009.
2. You must have at least FIVE different awards in your ten titles.
3. Overlaps with other challenges are permitted.
4. You don’t have to post your choices right away, and your list can change at any time.
5. ‘Award winners’ is loosely defined; make the challenge fit your needs, keeping in mind Rule #2.
So I will be reading the 9 that I have, which means I will be acquiring one more award winner soon. Some of these books may have won multiple awards, but I am just listing the first that it came up under. The books are:
- Possession, A.S. Byatt, Man Booker Prize
- The Glass Castle, Jeannette Walls, Alex Award
- Nickel and Dimed, Barbara Ehrenreich, Alex Award
- Quicksilver, Neal Stephenson, Arthur C. Clarke Award
- Lisey’s Story, Stephen King, Bram Stoker Award
- Eats, Shoots and Leaves, Lynne Truss, British Book Award
- A Suitable Boy, Vikram Seth, Commonwealth Writers’ Prize
- On Beauty, Zadie Smith, Orange Prize
- Fugitive Pieces, Anne Michaels, Orange Prize
- The Inheritance of Loss, Kiran Desai, Man Booker Prize
Number 10 is fairly likely to change, considering I do not own it and I will probably read the other 9 first and see what I can pick up. Some of these books are in England, so I literally can’t read them until early October. Regardless, I think this challenge will be a great one and I am happy to participate.
I find Jacqueline Carey’s work to be addicting and intoxicating, particularly her Kushiel’s Legacy series. KUSHIEL’S MERCY is no exception to this rule, considering I received it yesterday (early, considering it is due out June 12th!) and read most of it in an hours-long marathon read overnight. It is impossible to put down.
Imriel and Sidonie’s love for each other has finally become public, but for it to acknowledged by the Queen of Terre d’Ange, Sidonie’s mother Ysandre, Imriel must find his mother and bring her to justice for the crimes she committed in Carey’s first trilogy. Imriel takes on this challenge to win his love, only to be confronted with even more insurmountable obstacles that endanger everything he holds dear.
This is a fabulous book. It is well-plotted, never a dull moment, events popping up that I never would have expected. As I mentioned, I literally could not put it down until I was done. Carey’s writing remains spectacular and her character development proceeds at a running pace. Imriel’s development is absolutely stunning, considering where he came from in KUSHIEL’S SCION, and she has done a wonderful job here as well. Princess Sidonie comes into her own, providing us with another of her very strong females, though she and Phedre are vastly different. Carey excels at creating characters to fall in love with – not only that, but who fall in love (and make love, though it’s never the focal point here) with each other in believable and wondrous ways.
This is a journey to treasure and a book I will read over and over again. I am sad that Carey will be turning away from these characters to set another story generations later in Terre d’Ange, but I will recommend these books whole-heartedly.
ROMA is an ambitious saga that portrays the early days of ancient Rome, from its first bare beginnings as a salt trading post to the the struggle of the heirs of Julius Caesar. Each chapter is from a different period, though the time between them varies and shortens as the book goes on. The chapters are held together by several families, the most important of which holds an ancient talisman which is passed down through the generations.
Of necessity, the book truly isn’t gripping. Since each chapter is told by a different person, it’s hard to become attached to any of them, and a genealogical chart somewhere tracking their descendants would have been very useful. Still, each chapter was well told and interesting. I enjoyed the way Saylor showed how something simple becomes a legend only to become mystical and forgotten. He also succeeded in linking together all the chapters enough to make the book feel like a cohesive whole. Roma itself is a personality just as those who inhabit her are, which helps a lot with the narrative in later parts of the book.
Still, I am left feeling that although it was enjoyable, it could have been better. Rutherford’s LONDON is the best novel I’ve read of this type, and I would recommend that one first. This book provides a painless, enjoyable fictional introduction to early Rome and would also serve as a good stepping-off point for those interested in its history.
“Why LT?
Why did you choose to open and maintain an LT account? Do you/did you use other online cataloging/social networking sites, like GoodReads or Shelfari? Do you use more than one? Are they different or do they serve different purposes?”
I chose a LibraryThing account originally because it was the first book cataloging site that I found. I heard about it from a friend and the idea of having a record of all my books in one place, plus the ability to tag and organize them as I wished, immediately appealed to me. It appealed even more once I realized that there was an entire community dedicated to books. I have never met so many voracious readers! In fact, I have never met anyone who reads more than I do, and here there are reams of people who do.
I have not joined any other book cataloging sites, but I do use reading applications on my facebook profile – they don’t really do much but sit there, though.
|
|
Recent Comments