January 2010
S M T W T F S
« Dec   Feb »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

Review: The Fox, Sherwood Smith

In this sequel to Inda, Sherwood Smith follows her young hero through some seaside adventures as he grows up learning to fight against pirates after his exile from his childhood home.  Inda’s complex plans and capers form the basis for most of the storyline, but exciting events are also afoot in Iasca Leror, Inda’s birthplace.  When his brother is killed, Inda becomes the heir to Choraed Elgar, his family’s realm, and they launch a search to find him.  Treachery strikes the royal court and if Inda ever goes home, he will find a completely different place than he expects.

While I really enjoyed Inda and found it was a great fantasy to lose myself in, The Fox suffered from second book syndrome.  A lot happens, but it’s spread out over the 750+ pages, and as a result the book feels fairly slow even though there is actually plenty of action.  Not much at all is resolved, but progress is generally made across the plotlines as the characters that were introduced as children in the first book grow up.

I will admit freely that part of the problem I had with this book is that so much of it took place on a ship.  I’m one of those strange people that really prefers fantasy books in particular settings, and aboard ship has just never been one of them.  The only exception to this rule so far has been Robin Hobb.  Maybe it’s because I’ve never been on a ship, but I just found it really hard to continue paying attention during the sea battles, and given that 2/3 of the book takes place there, this was a problem.  I always enjoyed it when the narrative returned to Inda’s family and friends on dry land in Choraed Elgar because I vastly prefer kingdom politics to piracy politics.  Luckily, this one seems to indicate that more of book three will be spent on land, so my enthusiasm for the series is not as diminished as it could have been.

Regardless of my criticisms, I really enjoyed how the characters developed and I found myself caring a lot about them.  I’m interested to see where the story is going and that is really what matters here.  It’s still a fairly solid continuation to a promising epic fantasy saga, and I think approached in that way would be a very enjoyable read for anyone who likes that kind of book.

I am an Amazon Associate. I purchased this book.

Share

Review: The Dark Rose, Cynthia Harrod-Eagles

The Morland family has survived the Wars of the Roses to see the Tudors take the throne of England.  French Paul, the great grandson of the founders of the dynasty, now runs the Morland properties, but struggles with jealousy of his half-siblings and dislike of his wife.  Only his mistress in the city of York brings him happiness, but she also brings strife within his family.  Meanwhile, Paul’s niece Nanette becomes a beloved maid to Anne Boleyn, witnessing first hand the conflict and drama inherent in the Tudor court.

This second volume in the Morland dynasty may mark my abrupt end of reading the series.  This is just far too romanticized a version of history for me.   Most historical fiction does it to some extent, but this goes a little too far.  It’s like a story you would tell a small child, rather than an attempt to actually imagine history as it might have been, at least as far as I’m concerned.  When Nanette has witnessed the many murders of Henry VIII, including that of her friend Anne Boleyn, and still manages to see these murders as something that just had to happen and doesn’t fault him at all for it, I just have to take exception to that.  Yet the characters that don’t appear are purely villainized, like Henry’s next wife Jane Seymour, who is called something like the honey scorpion.

The author clearly attempts to have characters with multiple sides to them.  Paul’s bastard son is one such, as the author makes him a love-starved boy that finally seeks vengeance on the father who never gave him what he needed.  Despite that, everything just feels painted with a rosy brush.  Of course Adrian would have been a good man if he’d been given love.  Of course the council would never do anything evil, even though clearly the king would never do anything evil either.  There is incest in here that made me distinctly uncomfortable, but no one seems to mind when an uncle marries his niece, even though the characters mention the difficulty they might have with it.

The entire series has a nice dynastic feel that I like, but overall I feel like I’m reading a fairy tale that has little to do with actual history.  For that reason, I’m unsure if I’ll continue.  The Dark Rose was entertaining, but I think I’d rather spend my time reading something with a historical feel instead of a rosy “oh-wasn’t-the-past-great” one.

I am an Amazon Associate. I borrowed this book from my local library.

Share

Review: The Bird Room, Chris Killen

Since he is such a socially awkward person, Will is astonished when Alice spontaneously makes her interest in him clear.  She’s Will’s first girlfriend, as well as beautiful and smart.  He can’t stop obsessing over her and worrying what’s going to go wrong.  As always happens in such situations, his obsession begins to drive Alice away, and it’s only then that Will’s passion displays its most damaging consequences.

I wasn’t sure what to expect from this book and I was surprised, in a pleasant way, by what I found.  This book reads partly like an example of how not to conduct a relationship.  The situations are occasionally as sad as they are hilarious, but it’s impossible not to laugh.  The author has taken obsessive love to an extreme which is difficult to believe in, but which provides uneasy entertainment nonetheless.  We know there is something sad and wrong with these people, but at the same time they are mocking themselves.

The book alternates narration, using first person only when Will has the viewpoint perspective and third person for the other character.  This gives the reader an insight into his uncomfortable and obsessive mind, since otherwise we’d have no reason as to why he behaves the way he does, but at the same time contrasts his inner thoughts with his outer appearance and behavior.

The Bird Room doesn’t flinch in describing any aspect of these relationships.  A lot of the novel is obsessed with sex, as young people in new relationships generally are.  One of the characters is an actress using her body to get by and to erase her previous school persona, so there really is a fair amount of graphic content.  The book feels edgy, using the characters’ sexuality to portray the other happenings in their lives.  Helen, always lacking confidence, feels beautiful when a man wants her enough to sleep with her.  Will needs Viagra to encourage him along when his obsession with Alice takes control of his life.

A darkly comic tale about the extremes of obsession, The Bird Room manages to finish with hope and provides some very provoking thoughts to consider.  This little book is worth a read for those who enjoy character studies.

I am an Amazon Associate. I received this book for free from the publisher for review.

Share

TSS: Joining in on reading deliberately

tssbadge1Over the past few weeks, I’ve taken a step back from blogging and focused more on my other interests.  I had a fairly quiet Christmas with hubby’s mother and brother, and though I didn’t receive any books as gifts, I did receive some cash and I am deliberating over my potential acquisitions.  It’s also almost my birthday, so I have more potential for bookish gifts.  These days I try to only buy what I can’t get from the library as I really don’t have space for all the books I’d like to own and I’m finding that I actually don’t want to reread all that many books.  So I’ve been spending time comparing lists and contemplating!  My mother-in-law also gifted me with a knitting project, so I’ve been learning to knit.  Although I’m not very good yet, I am excited by all the projects I can now contemplate, and it’s really not as hard as I remembered from when I was a little kid.

That, and my newly revived interest in video games (perhaps not the most worthwhile of hobbies, but I’ve been feeling low lately and it really helps), has shown me that I’ve maybe been spending a little too much time reading and blogging this year.  I’ve enjoyed diversifying my activities and it’s much easier to spend time with someone doing something that isn’t sticking my nose in a book.  I have no intentions to stop reading, but I think I want to read less, and to read more specific books.  I mentioned some of this in my 2009 wrap-up post, but here is an outline of my goals:

  • Read more classics. I love classics and I’m finding them so much easier to read these days, I think because I have 4 years of literary theory behind me.  I want to get to more of the ones I own in particular.
  • Read more non-fiction.  I feel such a lack of learning in my life right now, and while I’m still unemployed and have the mental concentration, I should seize this opportunity to learn about other subjects, cultures, and people.
  • Stick to a reading plan. I want to read 1/3 of my own books, 1/3 review copies until I can cut that number down, and 1/3 library books, so that I can diminish my TBR pile but also feel like I’m reading something new with the library and review books.
  • Read one longer and/or more difficult book per month.  I saw this on another blog and I love this idea.  I want to read one huge chunkster or longer classic a month.  I’ve had A Suitable Boy by Vikram Seth sitting at me from the top of my immediate TBR pile for at least a month now.  It’s my January project and I want to start it as soon as I’ve finished my current read.
  • Don’t feel guilty. This is my most important goal.  I don’t want to feel guilty for not reading every day, for not blogging every day, for doing something else with my time.  I don’t want to beat 2009’s total of 283 books.

If I don’t achieve these goals, that’s okay too.  They’re just outlines.  And if all I want to do is read in my free time, that’s okay too, especially after I get a job and my time is more limited.  I’ve seen a lot of similar posts to mine this week, and I wish everyone success with their 2010 goals.

Share

Review: Battle Royale, Koushun Takami

Shuya Nanahara and his junior high class of fifteen-year-olds are going on a field trip.  Shuya is so optimistic that he’s even brought along alcohol.  But on the bus he notices something strange; everyone is falling asleep, and that new tough kid Shogo is trying to break the window.  Before he can think too much, he’s asleep, and doesn’t wake up until he’s in a strange classroom, and he and all his friends have cold metal collars around their necks.  They are told that they are about to kill one another on an isolated island, and to Shuya’s horror, the seriousness of this proposition is proven when his best friend is killed before his eyes.  Shuya’s worst nightmare is about to come true as he tries to protect the girl his best friend loved as his classmates set about playing the game.

I have a lot of conflicted feelings on this book.  My most immediate basis for comparison is The Hunger Games.  Battle Royale* is set in a dystopia based in Japan, but both essentially involve isolated kids killing each other after being given random weapons.  It’s a thriller and apparently both very popular and shocking in Japan.  I didn’t find it to be particularly shocking, although it did read very quickly for a 600 page book.

The problems started right at the beginning.  I found the writing to be very plain.  It’s readable, but there is something very juvenile about the sentence structure.  I kept noticing the poor writing and it constantly threw me out of the story.  Some of the characters quote poetry and song lyrics, but even these never rise above to form anything I’d consider quotable.  I don’t know if this is down to the fault of the author or the translator, but I definitely felt let down.  I didn’t like the narrative structure, either.  The main focus is Shuya, but the viewpoint switches often.  Unfortunately, after a few switches, it becomes apparent that almost every time the author introduces a new student, it means they’re going to die within a few pages.  Few of the students are really interesting, but the author also tends to include a flashback from each one of them, introducing background that is generally unnecessary and boring.  I get that they’re supposed to be regular kids who are forced into killing each other, the background is showing their personalities and motives, and that’s meant to be shocking, but again, I’m already familiar with the horror of this premise, and so this time it didn’t work.  Three to five pages was not enough to make me care.

I also couldn’t say I liked any of the characters.  They are only fifteen, but they are all in love with one another.  Naturally, most of them are in love with Shuya, but we’re also treated to little dramas between all the other characters that are in love.  To me, these seemed like simple crushes, and while everything is intensified in this sort of “game”, I simply got tired of the constant surprise each character exhibited upon learning that someone they barely knew loved them enough to die for them.  I couldn’t imagine this happening in real life.  Maybe if I was also fifteen years old, when I was convinced that a smile from a boy was everything in the world, I would have found this to be terribly tragic and romantic.  As an adult, the students annoyed me without exception.  I got tired of reading their irrelevant backstories and I didn’t really care much when any of them died.  For some I even found myself flipping ahead to see how long before they died because I was so impatient.  The book didn’t engage me at all on an emotional level.

There is also a lot of criticism against girls here which really bothered me.  All the boys are convinced that the girls would never kill one another, not only because they’re all good but because a girl wouldn’t have the stomach to do such a thing.  Worse, the author seems to agree; the girls are universally portrayed as weak and needing protection by the boys, none of them are intelligent enough to come up with an escape plan, and in general they do absolutely nothing of interest except act stupidly and get themselves killed.  The only girl who does fight with some skill is a bully, beautiful but despised universally, who doesn’t hesitate to kill her friends.  Even though her behavior is understandable to some extent given her backstory, out of so many girls is there really only one who can stand up to the boys?  And does she have to use her body to do it?  It just bothered me.  I missed the strong, smart girls so prevalent in today’s YA literature.

Largely, this book suffered a lot from comparison with The Hunger Games. There, the concept of kids killing each other is carried out, in my opinion, to the best possible result, providing an emotional, riveting, exciting, and unpredictable read.  If I’d read this first, maybe things would have been the other way around, but given what I’ve said here, I doubt it.  I can’t say I really hated Battle Royale, as I certainly read it fast enough and wasn’t conscious of all its faults while I was still wading through it, but I didn’t like it very much.  It brought up some interesting questions about trust and suspicion between friends, but not enough to save it from bad writing/translating, boring characters, and frustrating structure overall.  It’s interesting for anyone who’d like to see what all the fuss is about, but I wouldn’t read it again.

*This link goes to a new translation which I hope will prove better than the one I read. I am an Amazon Associate and will receive a few pennies if you click these links and buy something from Amazon. I bought this book.

Share

2009 Reading

My reading has slowed way, way down this month.  I’ve only read 11 books, roughly half of what I’ve read each previous month this year.  I’ve had fairly frequent distraction in the form of a husband who has had about half the month off work due to the holiday we were saving to visit my parents.  We didn’t get to, and as a result we’ve been hanging around here, and believe me, it’s hard to read with someone who often wants attention and distraction.  I have no idea how anyone who has full-time jobs and kids manages to get anything read.  I applaud all of you.  I know that when I eventually land one of the five million jobs I’ve applied for, my reading will go way way down, as I won’t have the alone time I’m used to.

We also happened to acquire an Xbox 360 a couple of weeks ago, and have shifted full on into gaming mode.  Obviously I’m still reading, but at a much reduced rate as my in-laws have taken the opportunity to buy us lots of new games.

I doubt I’m going to read another book in the next hour, and so I bring you reading statistics for 2009. I read a total of 283 books.  In genres (these don’t add up, as I’ve included some overlap):

  • Historical Fiction: 76
  • Literary Fiction: 34
  • YA: 29
  • Fantasy/Science Fiction/Horror: 88
  • Non-fiction: 23
  • Romance: 36
  • Graphic Novel: 4
  • Women’s Fiction: 8
  • Classics: 6
  • Thriller/Mystery: 11

I read 15 5-star (according to LibraryThing) books this year.  Choosing a favorite out of those fifteen is hard!  Unlike the past two years, I haven’t had a book jump out at me as an instant favorite for the year.  Those that will remain favorites include Possession by A.S. Byatt, Nothing but Ghosts by Beth Kephart, Heart’s Blood by Juliet Marillier, The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, and Emma by Jane Austen.

I definitely have some things I want to change for 2010 about my reading.  I want to read more classics for a start.  I loved five of the six I read this year and I have so many sitting around waiting for me.  I’m pleased with the non-fiction I read, but I want to read more of both history and memoirs and perhaps other topics as well as they interest me.  I also want to approach blogging differently.  I want to include more non-review posts, but while I have so many reviews left to write, it’s hard to make this a priority.  I do want to continue reviewing every book I read, so until I start to read less consistently, I will have to brainstorm.  I also want to visit more new blogs and leave more comments on the blogs I do read.  I’m still very shy on others’ blogs when I know I have no need to be.

champagne_toast

As it is nearly upon us, I’d like to wish you all a very happy New Year!  Here is to a successful, happy, and healthy 2010 for all of us.

Share